Used price: $0.99
Buy one from zShops for: $4.95
Uros
Used price: $61.00
Used price: $5.48
There is some good information and thought in the book. When the book focuses on telling the story of Jackson and his activities, it is good reading and, in the main, does not present an appealing picture of the United States's or Jackson's treatment of the Southeast Indians. Jackson's Indian Wars and subsequent removal policy come in for strong criticism. Rogin has interesting things to say about the conflicted character of American attitudes to the Indians and how these attitudes were both reflected and created by Jackson. It is also interesting to approach Jacksonian democracy from the perspective of Indian affairs. Rogovin's book was among the first to focus on Jackson's Indian policy in an attempt to understand Jacksonian America. Rogovin's judgments both on Jackson and more broadly, on the growth of democracy and industrialization in the United States, seem to me overly harsh.
The book is seriously marred by its attempts at psychohistory. There is a lot of second and third hand reliance on works by Freud, Erickson, Melanie Klien and other founders of psychoanalysis and a lengthy, unconvincing, attempt to apply Rogin's understanding of psychoanalysis to Jackson and to the American experience. It didn't work for me, to say the least. The book's overreliance on questionable psychohistory does lead me to be skeptical about much of the argument and conclusion of the book. The book is good at relating the literature of the day to Jacksonian America with some insightful comments about the work of Herman Melville. (Rogovin has also written a book about Melville).
There is something here worth knowing and saying about Jackson. Our Indian policy was indeed tragic and exacted a great human toll. The book though doesn't appreciate the difficult pressures in foreign and domestic affairs facing a young America. It is overly angry with the United States and too dependent on questionable psychologizing. The book shouldn' be anybody's sole source of information about Jacksonian America or Indian policy.
Used price: $34.14
Buy one from zShops for: $73.55
Used price: $19.95
Buy one from zShops for: $64.54
List price: $20.00 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $8.00
Buy one from zShops for: $13.66
Used price: $20.00
Buy one from zShops for: $14.89
Used price: $29.95
"Old Marxism" is roundly condemned. Yet no real analytical explanation of why those political parties failed is presented. Instead the narrative of failure moves along like a free-flowing stream without hint of the surrounding shore. Buhle has more success with accounts of the New Left in which he participated. But once again there is no sense of context, i.e. period potential or lack thereof. Nowhere, for example, does he address the political potential of an anti-war movement evolving within a larger context of general prosperity. For a work on Marxism, the absense of economic context here, as elsewhere, amounts to a paradox and characterizes the book as a whole. But then, inclusion of such themes would perhaps smack too much of the Old Left.
Recurring instead are cultural themes. That Marxism failed in an elemental way to connect with American culture is a powerful and provocative thesis that lies buried somewhere in the text. Resurrecting it and addressing the historical subplots would amount to a real contrbution. But alas, as the book stands, New Left thinking may make for energizing politics, but in Buhle's case, it makes for poor historical writing.
Used price: $0.85
Collectible price: $2.64
Buy one from zShops for: $12.75
Used price: $20.00
First of all, I want to substantiate the fact that Paul Karleen has a respectable knowledge of the Holy Scriptures. That said, I am convinced of the validity of the Pre-Wrath Rapture of the Church versus the Pre-Tribulational Rapture doctrine argued for in this book.
As a graduate of the Institute of Jewish Studies (IJS), a school of the Friends of Israel Gospel Ministry (FOI), I am also personally acquainted with Marvin (Marv) Rosenthal, the author of "the Pre-Wrath Rapture of the Church", the book that Paul Karleen argues against with his own book here. This is due to the fact that, for many years, Marv Rosenthal served as the Executive Director for the Friends of Israel.
Despite the fact that I have often found Paul Karleen's teachings to be profound and scholarly, this being substantiated by the fact that he once served as a Professor of Philadelphia Biblical University (PBU), the Institution wherein I, myself, received my Bachelor of Science in Bible, I found his arguments in this book to be rather simplistic and unconvincing.
If someone is looking for an Apology against the Pre-Wrath Rapture of the Church, I recommend "Maranatha" by Renald (Renie) Showers as a preferable alternative to this work. I also sat under the teaching of Renie Showers and I consider his book to be far more scholarly and convincing, although I still remain a Disciple of the Pre-Wrath doctrine.
Shalom - Soror Samhain