Used price: $3.00
Collectible price: $15.88
"The Protestant Face of Anglicanism" has many flaws. Polemical in tone, strident in style, unnuanced in its history, and often purple in its prose, its brevity doesn't allow the author to make a substantial case for much of anything. The book also suffers from a lack of precision in crucial definitions. For instance, early on in the book, Zahl posits a distinction between "protestants" and "evangelicals." But thereafter, he uses the two terms as synonyms.
The lack of documentation was irritating. Many of Zahl's assertions about English history and the development of Anglican theology were uncited, so there's no way to check his sources or read further. Even fascinating tidbits -- like the complicity of Thomas More in the assassination of William Tyndale -- were uncorroborated. That's too bad. More's one sacred cow that could use a dose of real history.
Unfortunately, while Zahl does state he does not want to be "anti-Catholic", he ends up being just that. His greatest error is his broad-brush theological characterization of the difference between Protestant and Catholic, namely, that the latter is "incarnational" and the other is "atonement" based. While there is some general truth to that, one may ask if both have merit, for he clearly has problems with the incarnational perspective. By "incarnational", Zahl refers specifically to the Orthodox (not even Catholic!) view of theosis. If he wants to do that, then he needs to see how strongly catholic even Luther was and even reflected strong theosis sympathies, as shown by the Helsinki school of Lutheran study. In the end, Zahl is simply being polemical at this point.
I agree, as an evangelical protestant Anglican, that Anglicanism is not a "third way", but rather a Protestant faith with an Episcopal, historic model. Nonetheless, there is ALSO a "Catholic" face to Angilcanism, whether he (or I!) like it or not. Moreover, he uses "Protestant" and "evangelical" very loosely and I was often unclear what his definitions were.
In the end, the book captured my interest, but was thankfully short. I got this feeling it was written by someone who was annoyed by Anglo-catholic elements in his denomination and wanted to write against them. I also found the dearth of discussion around third world Anglicanism (a VERY protestant and evangelical movement!) to imply that England, and to a lesser extent, the US, was where one discussed "Anglicanism". This is a mistake.
Used price: $7.46
These "IN 90 MINUTES" books are wonderful introductions to the greatest minds of the Western world. I take sincere issue with those (see review below) who would attempt to cloak the study of philosophy behind a smokescreen of intellectual elitism. Such snobbery is contradictory to the goals of all philosophical thought.
Philosophy is for EVERYONE!
Sartre is difficult, yes, but not beyond the intelligence of anyone truly interested and dedicated to understanding.
I recommend this book without reservation.
Used price: $3.75
Used price: $2.48
Collectible price: $9.53
Buy one from zShops for: $2.49
and misconception in this book that I wonder if Brecher really
believes what he writes.
Here is the first that I noticed, and it shows how shallow
Brecher's understanding is:
He says that Tai Chi Chuan means Yin Yang Fist. Wrong! Yes,
the Taiji symbol is the Yin Yang that we are all familiar with.
However, everyone knows that the Tai Chi in Tai Chi Chuan means
Grand Ultimate, or Grand Extremes. No authoritative book on
Tai Chi Chuan would ever call the art Yin Yang Fist.
His explanation that Tai Chi fighting should be all Fa Jin
is wrong. If you don't know what Fa Jin is, you certainly don't
want to learn from Brecher. In addition, he says that you should be striking accupoints. As if. Try to hit a spot on
someone the size of a dime while they are trying to kill you.
Good luck.
The sections on Bagua and Xingyi are weak, also. I'm not saying
that everything in the book is wrong, but there are some major,
major errors.
His discussion of the Wu Dang Shan Qi disruption forms is
practically non-existant. He does put in a nice plug for his
teacher, Erle Montague, who has lots of things to sell.
Save your money, B.K. Frantzis "The Power of Internal Arts" has
much more useful information if you are serious about trying to
understand what the internal martial arts are about.
The sections on Bagua and Xingyi are weak, also. I'm not saying
that everything in the book is wrong, but there are some major,
major errors.
His discussion of the Wu Dang Shan Qi disruption forms is
practically non-existant. He does put in a nice plug for his
teacher, Erle Montague, who has lots of things to sell.
My hardback edition has a great presentation of format and color. I do like the photo's in the book, even though they are all not relevant.
Used price: $2.25
Collectible price: $3.18
Used price: $12.48
Buy one from zShops for: $12.48
Don't waste your money on this!
Used price: $0.01
Collectible price: $1.57
Buy one from zShops for: $0.89
Used price: $36.33
Used price: $7.72
Collectible price: $8.42