I have mixed feelings about the characterization and plot of the book itself. I would've liked to have gotten a deeper look at the personalities and motivations of the various characters in the book--but--that's only because I found them to be interesting as characters to begin with. I hope and expect that later books by Mr. Marks will continue to expand on the dramatis personae he provided us with in his first work.
Overall, he paints a vivid picture of Sanctuary (the Diablo world). Heroes such as Arkaine, Velund the Smith, and Tyrael make appearances, and earlier events and critical wars are discussed.
I would say that Mr. Marks had a very difficult job. Honestly, I believe its impossible to build a deep, complex, and completely immersive world, PLUS add excellent characterization in 100 pages. What Demonsbane does best is set the stage for the books (hopefully others by Marks) that will come after it. It's a worthwhile read, a good story, and I expect that the books that come after it will continue to expand the world of Sanctuary and populate it with interesting and deep characters. Worth your time.
Used price: $8.50
The basic plot is interesting, in a nostalgic way, and if the authors would have gone deeper, maybe this story could have been salvaged. Focusing on a grim-and-gritty "post-Village" life for Nos. 2 and 6 sounds like an interesting read (especially No. 2's incarceration and subsequent book, and 6's breakdown). The problem is that you barely get to read about them at all. The focus is instead on bland new characters who are uncovering the existence and purpose of the Village, and 2 and 6 are secondary. Furthermore, it undoes some major points that were established in the series finale "Fall Out", and once they go messing with that, I don't get interested; just angry. So I guess that this book isn't meant for long-time fans of The Prisoner, because why would we want to read about the adventures of a bunch of nobodies uncovering (or undoing) what we already know?
The writers, however, try to reel the fans back in and impress us with their "clever" use of dialogue and scenery from the TV series, but this is another thing that makes the book so irritating. It's as if they picked their favorite blocks of dialogue from the show, and purposefully wrote the entire book around their incorporation. An occasional "be seeing you" would be fine, but Motter & Askwith use SO MUCH dialogue from the TV series that I challenge their claim to be the writers of this book.
Let's not forget the art: horrific pencil scratches that benefit little from the inking, and flat washed-out colors that make deciphering the panels a chore. Also, would it have hurt to include some backgrounds in the panels? Overall, the art has no detail or depth and makes this a visually boring tale. My advice is, watch the TV series, revel in its greatness, and skip this book.
A revisitation of the Village and Numbers Six and Two (appearing in the favorite Leo McKern incarnation), SHATTERED VISAGE is likely to leave the casual fan entirely befuddled and even the hardcore enthusiast scratching their head. As obtuse as the final series episode, FALL OUT, and poorly illustrated, SHATTERED VISAGE satisfies only in that it faithfully maintains the clever wordplay of the series in its dialogue, but this is little compensation for the lack of a cohesive story.
Many Prisoner fans enjoy the mystery of the series' finale, forever exploring possible meanings behind its intriguing images, but a successful sequel must answer at least some existing questions before asking others. Therefore, SHATTERED VISAGE fails in nearly every department. Only the most devoted completist need bother - and even then, this title is likely to simply take up space on your shelf.
The art is a bit of an acquired taste (particularly the coloring), but the story riffs on some of the same themes and ideas that made the original such a cult favorite, while bringing it into modern times.
Some reviewers have complained about it not making any sense, or being obtuse, but I disagree. Like anything worthwhile, it takes a bit of effort, and if you only try to passively "be entertained" you may not get everything out of it.
Overall, solid story work by Motter with art that grows on you. A worthy "sequel" to the TV series.
Many people disagree with me, because the thumb mark is made in a way different from the Norwood builder's. But this is really a minor issue. Once the author decides the thumb mark is fake and actually conveys this idea to the readers, it is no good to spend much pain on how it is made. A detective story is not supposed to be a science story. The former emphasizes on DEDUCTION rather than profound science knowledge, because not every reader is a PhD or MD as Freeman. Even if someone is, he might well be in a different discipline. Doyle is in no way less educated than Freeman, but he always applies the most practical method with the least scientific knowledge in the conducting of a crime. This makes Doyle's story not only full of surprises (Watsons would say: ah, it's that simple), but also more read-able than Freeman's lecture. Even in the view of science story, people would question whether Polton's (Thorndyke's assistant) various patents are realistic.
Nevertheless, I can't deny it is helpful for Freeman's future career, which makes Thorndyke a distinct character rather than a mimic of Holmes. The only difference between Doyle and Freeman is that the former is a genius while the latter is just talented.
In this first Thorndyke story by R Austin Freeman (the first of many in the series), Thorndyke takes on a new assistant Dr. Jervis. Dr Jervis is the foil to Thorndyke, just as Dr Watson is to Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes. Thorndyke also explores more than just the case, by having Jervis fall in love. Dr Jervis' love affair is an interesting diversion in how it reveals middle-class values at the turn of the century.
The basis of this story is interesting: can forensic science be wrong; can you fake fingerprints on evidence ? The book is not a 'who dun it' in the conventional sense. Most readers will identify the obvious villain early on. The challenge is to work out how the crime was done and then to prove that it was done that way. Of course, Thorndyke frees the innocent man in the end.
Thorndyke is a more scientific detective than Holmes and achieves surprising results, even within the primitive knowledge and techniques of his day.
The novel concerns Thorndyke's attempts to clear the name of a young man accused of stealing diamonds from a safe. A thumb mark (finger print) near the scene of the crime is the only evidence against the young man, but it is decidedly damning. Add a little romance, a sinister villian lurking in the background, and you have the ingredients that make up this story.
I found the work to be wonderfully exciting. Watching Thorndyke break down the evidence against the young man is a fascinating expereince. Though a person could argue that too much detail is given to the "science" aspect, you have to understand that these scenes are the backbone of this type of detective story.
In a day and age of corporate villiany, brutal crime bosses and hideous serial killers, The Red Thumb Mark might seem to some readers as painfully old-fashioned. Freeman's writing is similar (and often compared with) Conan Doyle, and there's little doubt that Freeman found inspiration from the Holmes canon. However, the novel's old-fashioned flavor is the very reason to recommend it. It's fun to walk the streets of Edwardian England, to see the sights, to hear the gentlemanly discussions, to share the thought processes of one of the great detective minds. This is the real magic of the novel.
Sadly, most of Freeman's work has long, long been out of print. I would recommend hunting among the used book stores for his other great mysteries, especially The Silent Partner, The Eye of Osiris, and my all-time favorite Mr. Pottermack's Oversight. These great novels are as highly recommended as The Red Thumb Mark. Someday, I hope the world rediscovers this highly talented writer and that he is placed along side with the other great names where he belongs.
Used price: $3.00
Buy one from zShops for: $15.00
Used price: $7.00
Buy one from zShops for: $17.24
As for the reviewer, spare us the condescension, you're attitude is the driving force behind social/economical class-ism in the US today.
Used price: $0.30
Buy one from zShops for: $1.00
"*ll*...is pronounced like the *lli* in *million*"
"*a* is nearer to southern English *cup* than *cap*"
"*o* as in *pot*-never as in *know* or *toe*"
That's too much bad information for one book, let alone one page. Authors (or at least editors) have a responsibility to check their facts. Anyone following these authors' advice would be unintelligible. I can't trust the rest of the book now and wish I could get my money back.
This book was no exception. I bought this book, planning on brushing up some more with my "North American Spanish" (the type an American learns in School, which is essentially a mix of numerous dialects, and depends on who your teacher learned from). The problem is this book teaches hardcore Castillian Spanish, which sounds slightly different and doesn't have the traditional flow that an American is used to. Regardless, this book simplifies grammer greatly, and is able to explain some of the easiest concepts of survival Spanish with relative ease. This book is clearly for begginers though, because it only teaches Usted, which is the formal word for you, for most of the chapters only introducing the informal "tu" later. This seems rather absurd because they make it seem extremely informal, although this is just to cut down on the verb endings, but one needs to learn them all at once instead.
Besides all these mistakes though. The book does teach a begginer Spanish as it intended to, and can probubly do that rather quick.
Used price: $29.00
This is by far one of the best books about how the "Christian 'Science'" organization came to exist. While the book is a classic, it is also timeless.
If you are interested in Eddy or "Christian 'Science,'" this is the single best source for you to explore. I recomend this book HIGHLY!
Used price: $0.97
Buy one from zShops for: $1.49
It can be difficult enough to understand HRT (see my other reviews on this topic) - and now we're given yet another possible treatment to replace the loss of estrogen that leaves menopausal women open to heart disease, stroke, fatigue among other things. This book focuses on the effects of Osteoporosis, ways to prevent, treat and live with it (6 of the 10 chapters focus on it). Chapter 4 is dedicated to Evista, giving lists of ingredients, women who should NOT take Evista, side effects and its interaction with other medications. There is a chapter on other HRT (Hormone Replacement Therapies) that can help a woman decide what is right for her.
This book is a good source for information on why to use Evista rather than estrogen, estrogen-progesterone if you are worried about Osteoporisis. For those of us more worried about heart disease, stroke and breast cancer, it offers one chapter "The Future of Evista and SERMS Treating Heart Disease and Breast Cancer."
The book has bits of general information scattered throughout - another decent source of information on a topic of interest to woman of a certain age. If you are reading lots of books, I'd add this one to the mix. Don't use it as your only source of information, though. Please check out other books on Hormone Replacement Therapy and Menopause, too.
List price: $14.99 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $5.96
Buy one from zShops for: $5.97
As far as the rest of the book goes, a lot of it seems to be extraneous material meant to take up space, such as a list of all the Madden cards, a list of every player in the game, a section with one person's walkthrough of the fantasy draft, etc. This was interesting from a certain perspective, but ultimately not too helpful in actually playing the game.
The thing I liked most was the tips on rushing plays. The guide does give some good advice on when to juke, spin, stiff-arm, etc. Outside of this information, I thought this strategy guide was nothing special. A couple of pages on each team and some eye candy (in the form of unhelpful screenshots), and that's about it.
I don't want to tell anything about the contents, because I don't want to spoil the story. To all the Diablo fans, I just can say, read it. I already read Diablo - Legacy of Blood, but it's best to read this first, in case you have to start. Demonsbane is a great prelude to the series and you should definately read it.
By reading these books, I like playing the game more, since I understand the world better.
Have fun with this book.
Greetz,
Geoffrey