Used price: $7.75
Buy one from zShops for: $6.90
"Imagining Reality" is a book of short, sharp readings by filmmakers and critics about documentary film from its beginnings with Edison and Lumière, to the feature documentary "Crumb" (1995). After years of seeming neglect through the middle of this century, documentary film is again undergoing a wholesome reassessment by a new plethora of practitioners, commentators and academic scrutineers. We can hope that this will contribute to the long-standing integrity and innovation in this form of film, which founded the beginnings of cinema. It all began in 1895 with Lumière's patrons diving under their seats as a locomotive rushed towards them on the screen. The fiction film then took over in 1903, coincidentally, with the intervention of film editing techniques.
The literature about documentary of recent years is preoccupied by the questions of where to now, the imminent death of the documentary and how close to the "truth" is this film genre? After this questioning and the continual pushing of the boundaries of form, style and means of expression the documentary is still very, very alive. Heated debate continues for definitions of the very essence and nature of the genre. Many of the innovations introduced over the years by documentarists have been quickly adapted into mainstream television and feature films.
Recent titles of books about documentary film express this lively debate: "Representing Reality", "Blurred Boundaries", "Claiming the Real", "Theorizing Documentary", "Fields of Vision", "The Art of Record", "Documentary Dilemmas", "Framer Framed", "Innovation in Ethnographic Film", "New Challenges for Documentary" and the book that is the subject of this review "Imagining Reality: The Faber Book of Documentary". If "Imagining Reality" had been published before the debates raised in the recent books mentioned above, it could well have been titled Imaging Reality.
The editors of "Imagining Reality", Kevin Macdonald and Mark Cousins from the UK have made a careful, considered and very readable compendium from which to consider the major issues concerning documentary. It is a book that should interest all, especially documentary aficionados. It will also become a valuable resource for teaching about documentary film. However, from an Australian point of view their book seriously underestimates our contribution to this exciting film genre. There is no mention of any Australian films or filmmakers throughout the book. It is a serious failing. Another area found wanting is a consideration of the impact over the last forty years of films by women that provide a unique perspective on the human condition.
Although they acknowledge it in the preface, the editors have excluded the now controversial area of ethnographic film and the issues of "representation", "rights" and "reflexivity" relevant to all forms of documentary. The current debate on "reflexivity"; the open positioning and acknowledging of the filmmaker's views (and sometimes themselves, e.g. Broomfield, Mike Rubbo, or Alby Mangels) in the body of the film. In this way further layers of "truth" are manipulated by the filmmakers, as they provide the viewer with information concerning who they are and why they are making a film. The very humorous piece in this book on the British filmmaker, Nick Broomfield broaches the issue, but we miss a follow-through.
Opinion is now leaning towards the view that documentary film is as much a fiction as any other fiction. Yet practitioners of the documentary are generally well aware that from idea to final mix, their film is the product of the process of many thousands of selective decisions. These many decisions will, they hope, create a realistic re-creation and representation of the mood, atmosphere and meaning of the actual events that they are shooting and then editing into their final product.
The new development of small hand carried camcorders in the Hi-8 and digital format has allowed both non-professional and professional film-makers to make low-budget, credible and often unusually intimate stories such as the "Video Diaries" series that were produced and broadcast recently by the BBC and SBS-TV. I would have enjoyed a more detailed investigation here.
Despite these limitations "Imagining Reality" remains a fascinating read as many of the selections chosen have not been published in such an accessible form before. There are incisive and new insights into the greats of documentary such as Flaherty, Ivens, Balázs, Vertog, Grierson, Wright, John Huston, Reifenthahl, Jennings, Warhol, Welles, Ophüls, Malle, Marker, Leacock, Rouch, the Maysles brothers, Wiseman, De Antonio, Morris, Loach and Pennebaker. What a roll call, and what fascinating reading they provide! Documentary, we realize, can be all things to all.
As the Canadian turned French filmmaker Chris Marker comments, near the end of this book, we are in a technological age during which "rarely has Reality needed so much to be imagined".
John Darling Documentary filmmaker and Lecturer in Media Studies, Murdoch University, 1997
List price: $15.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $1.85
Collectible price: $6.34
Buy one from zShops for: $2.60
Used price: $0.61
Collectible price: $1.06
Buy one from zShops for: $1.49
List price: $17.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $7.95
Collectible price: $10.90
Buy one from zShops for: $11.59
Used price: $8.95
Buy one from zShops for: $9.09
Used price: $10.00
List price: $27.00 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $15.99
Buy one from zShops for: $16.75
Used price: $11.59
Buy one from zShops for: $11.54
It's rather hard to rate this book. Some of the crafts are fun and well spelled out, whereas others are not. For example, the directions for making the Dala horse can be boiled down to "1) model a horse out of clay, 2) paint it red, and 3) paint traditional designs on it." I'm sorry, but these instructions are way too little to help in making such a thing.
So, I would suggest that you get this book through your local public library, rather than spending your own money on it. My daughter and I give it a very guarded recommendation.
Again, the standout story has a strong female lead that guides the story. Jill, a clerk at a comic shop, draws the attention of an eccentric named "Steven." Steven dresses oddly and obsesses over unique things such as old romance comics and black and white films and tv shows. In his own way he is trying to build a relationship with Jill, who truly likes him, but not romatically. When he finally makes a move and she turns him down and she has the opportunity to remark on how men and women deal with friendships and relationships. Murphy does a good job telling the story through the female narrator.
In "May 27th," Murphy focuses on another female character, Connie, a college student who is about to graduate and has an internship working in a prison program. There she works with a repeat drug offender, Ray, who is trying to avoid jail and do something positive with his life. Separately and together, Connie and Ray make small steps to better understand themselves and their place.
"Tide Pools" looks at the relationship between a townie who longs to leave the West Coast tourist trap where she leaves, but can't get up the strength to do so on her own. When an outsider comes to the town to study the local marine biology, she sees her chance to get out, but will she be able to make that decision? Again, Murphy does a good job of showing his characters taking small advances towards change.
The darkest story, "The Burial," is saved for last. While I felt it lacked the emotional punch that Murphy was looking for, it was an ambitious story as Murphy juggled numerous characters and details. In the hands of another writer or with more room in which to work, this could have been a great story.
Although he hasn't entirely abandoned the coffee shop as a setting, there are a only a few short pieces that are played for laughs in this collection. It might be nice if Murphy collected these stories together. While they (and another two pieces called The Paper Route), cleanse the palate for the more serious works contained in the book, a more cohesive tone might also work to his advantage. As it is now, they act more like a one shot that interrupts your favorite comics story-arc.
Perhaps it is because I read this so soon after Adrian Tomine's Summer Blonde, but I felt that the stories and the artwork lacked the maturity that could have elevated this work. As it is, it is still interesting reading and a good use of the medium to expand the stories told to those that develop character over plot.