Used price: $15.00
Used price: $7.75
The most disappointing aspect of Hill's book is the superficial way she examines the evidence and circumstances surrounding the First Vision and the writing of the Book of Mormon. She examines the three separate accounts written by Smith of his First Vision and essentially states they are reconciliable. This echoes the assessment of the accounts made by Dean Jesse in his article in 1973 on the First Vision which occurred in Brigham Young University Studies Journal. Hill leaves out the fact that Smith stated he was a different age during each recounting of the vision, that the message delivered by the heavenly beings was significantly different in each account, and that his inability to specifically date the vision differs dramatically from his ability to date with absolute specificity the vision that told him to go dig up the Golden Plates.
Also troubling about her analysis (or lack thereof) is the following: 1. She alludes to a dream that Smith's father had which is recounted in Lucy Smith's biography of her son, but fails to mention this dream somehow found its way totally intact into First Nephi in the Book of Mormon. 2. She fails to deal with the issue of Smith's imagination and the fact he told tales recounting the early inhabitants of the Americas prior to the time the Book of Mormon was translated (Lucy Smith's biography does recount this) 3. She discusses the subject matter of the Book of Mormon, but fails to deal at all with the vast body of extrinsic evidence that tends to refute its claims (the fact that there is no evidence that animals described in the Book of Mormon lived here during the time mentioned, DNA testing showing Indians are related to Asiatic peoples--instead of Middle Eastern Jews, the absence of archaelogy establishing metallurgy, shipbuilding, etc.)
Hill does deal with Smith's 1826 trial in Bainbridge, New York for being an "imposter and moneydigger". She does admit that he may have been convicted of the crime and put on probation, but fails to grasp some of the larger implications of the event. First, the whole thing started when Josiah Stowel traveled all the way from Bainbridge to Palmyra to find Smith to look for buried treasure. In order for this to occur, Smith *had* to have had a reputation for engaging in such activities that was fairly widely known. Second, several accounts of the trial say that Stowel testified that he knew Smith could look into a seer stone and see buried treasure underneath the earth. The implication of this is that Smith had broad persuasive powers. Since people can't see what is underground with a seer stone one must conjecture why he claimed that he could.
I felt her treatment of the Book of Abraham controversy was inadequate. She admits that modern Egyptologists that have translated part of the papyri from which the Book of Abraham was written have a very different translation than that which Smith claimed. However, she suggests that perhaps the papyri only served as a "catalyst" which opened his mind to receive the inspiration to write the Book. Perhaps, but entries from Smith's own journals during this time period use the language that he was preparing an Egyptian alphabet and grammar to translate the papyri. One has to ask the question, just exactly when does a prophet say something that is accurate, and when does he not?
The book redeems itself, in part, by recounting history of the Saints, as Smith began to build the church. Her recitation of the polygamy issue in not a whitewash. The persecutions that the Mormon people endured in Missouri and Illinois are absolutely shocking. Hopefully, they will never be repeated against any group, anywhere. I hadn't realized, until I read this book, that things were so bad in Illinois at the time of the Mormon expulsion from Nauvoo, that Governor Ford actually feared Civil War.
Smith does come through in this book as a highly charismatic, very likeable, and highly intelligent individual. This is a far cry from some church works which have attempted to paint him as an ignorant country boy.
An interesting, but a superficial book.
Used price: $29.00
Buy one from zShops for: $36.47
Used price: $20.00
Buy one from zShops for: $24.00
List price: $2.00 (that's -100% off!)
Used price: $0.10
Collectible price: $1.95
Buy one from zShops for: $1.00
List price: $11.99 (that's 20% off!)
Buy one from zShops for: $8.00
List price: $69.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $41.58
Buy one from zShops for: $45.05
List price: $15.00 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $1.74
Collectible price: $4.94
Buy one from zShops for: $9.85
Published in 1941, one can't help but think that THE MIND OF THE SOUTH is an iconoclastic reaction to the immense popularity of GONE WITH THE WIND, released in 1939.
This book indeed embodies a comprehensive history of the South, beneficial and useful once the reader embraces the flow of Mr. Cash's prose and his myiad tangents. I'd recommend this book to anyone interested in the history of the South, though some readers have and will indubitably see this "classic" work as self-righteous, hypocritical and incongruent as the author's subject matter.
Cash was my introduction to Southern intellectual history, and by the time I found him I was far from the South in both space and time. I can feel Cash in my very bones; a dose of Tom Watson populism, a dose of Mencken's cynicism, and a whole bunch of the self-loathing that a defeated and impoverished people wore like tattered old clothes every day. Some neo-Southerners call Cash a South-hater, but they miss the point; Cash wanted desperately to love The South, but could find little to love except myth. You get much the same with Woodward, though in finer clothes. "Strange Career" is nothing but myth, yet it propelled Woodward to the heights of the Academy. The key to both these books is that they are Yankee approved mythology. The publishing houses are not on Peachtree Street, they are on 5th Avenue. For anyone wishing to begin exploration of Southern thought, Cash, the Nashville Agrarians, and Strange Career are the places to start. If you go no further, you won't know anything about The South, but to go further, you must start here.
Used price: $131.66
Buy one from zShops for: $142.60
Used price: $0.01
Collectible price: $1.25
The book focuses on a San Diego Police Officer who looses his son in the PSA jet crash in San Diego and escapes to a desrt town to escape San Diego and to still be near his ex wife who lives in Rancho Mirage in an exclusive Country Club.
The Main Character of this novel "Black Sid" gets an all expense paid vaction to Palm Springs to investigate a murder of a Millionares son. Black Sid like Harry Bright and the millionare all have lost their son.
The plot is very captivating and well worth the reading. Just be careful, it may inspire you enough to go to the Coachella Valley area and fall in love with the desert and buy a home in Rancho Mirage like I did!