Many times I found myself arguing against the assertions made about literature and theory in this book. I think, perhaps, that sometimes particular "American" critics fail to capture the fullness of the arguments by French theorists. This is not to say that "American" theorists "do not get it"; however, it should make you weary about simply accepting the presentation of the topics in this book. The ideas presented by literary theory are inordinately complex, and sometimes it takes actually grappling with the confusing language of the French, or of the translated French (though this introduces yet another problem) to actually understand what critics actually say about literature.
By all means, buy this book for a concise rendering of the issues. However, do not think for a moment that this book accurately portrays contemporary literary study in its fullness. There is so much more than this book initially communicates.
Used price: $1.50
Collectible price: $3.59
Buy one from zShops for: $1.75
Used price: $127.53
Sorry I had to give it one star. There is no category on this form for zero.
I would buy 10 copies if I could.
Used price: $38.95
The CD does not work for almost half our class.
Vic
CNC Workshop is a big disappointment. As the other person pointed out, you can get far better simulators (freeware) from the web. There is very little of use to anyone but highschool kids in this book.
Buy Smid's or Mike Lynch's book for REAL cnc knowledge.
This is not college level text and it shouldn't be. The average machinist reads on a 7th grade reading level. I've used training material costing thousands of dollars and the trainees were so intimidated that half of them struggled. The CNC Workshop package gets rave reviews from the trainees and there is a significant performance increase on the shop floor.
One of the best bargains you will ever find!!
Used price: $5.00
Collectible price: $8.47
List price: $14.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $5.79
Collectible price: $13.75
Buy one from zShops for: $10.39
And when the Inquisitor says comments on how 'cute' something is. I don't think a) that would happen or b) cute was a term of the time.
Give me a break.
This book has missed about 80% of CNC programming facts and theory, and the 20% that is present is littered with errors.
Smid's book is far superior, as is Mike Lynch's work.
The CD that comes with this book crashes easily and the G-code do not represent true CNC commands (only vague movements.)
Valentino's book is far better. Smid's book is great. They seem to know CNC concepts far better than Nanfara and company.
I disagree that this is a good value for the money. It is written for Gr.9 level technical education. Adults would be better off spending (money) and buy a real book and download a free simulator off the net.
Let's start with the pros and cons.
CONS:
The print quality of the book is terrible compared to first edition that came out. The book wastes print by addressing CAM software not commonly used in the machining industry. The material does not dive extensively into the subject matter. Other than corrections and a software update, this release is identical the first release I bought in 1999.
PROS:
You may be asking "why five stars?". Simple...it is the CNC bargain of a lifetime. The CD that comes with the book is the real gem. The CD has been updated to run on the latest Windows operating systems.
The CD contains an interactive multimedia presentation that covers the basics of CNC. Just put the book away and let the CD educate you on the basics of CNC at your own pace. EIA standard G codes and M codes are presented and animated for both turning and milling operations.
Milling and turning simulators are included and are easy to operate. You can experiment all you want on your own computer. You can write simple CNC programs, see your mistakes in the 3D animation and learn by working out the bugs. Avoid cocky instructors or punks in the machine shop that will rub it in if your program doesn't run right.
You have to learn the basics before you can dive deep into CNC. There is no easier way to learn CNC basics than by using the multimedia CD included in this package.
I am recommending this package as strictly an introductory course. It is perfect for the CNC newby that wants to learn by seeing a task performed and having an opportunity to make mistakes and fix them instead of just reading a boring technical book.
FIVE*****STARS!!!!!(At this price it's a steal!)
List price: $19.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $10.00
Buy one from zShops for: $13.50
Used price: $2.22
Collectible price: $10.59
Buy one from zShops for: $5.50
The author also failed to effectively use metephores to illustrate his point. Rather, his analogies were clumsy and unremarkable.
Save yourself some time and rent Murphy's movie Boomerang instead.
Used price: $12.99
Collectible price: $13.20
Buy one from zShops for: $14.66
The editors seem to have taken great pains to select works written by people who feel a need to choose the longest word they can find to represent an idea; if a suitably long word does not exist, they combine a word with prefixes and suffixes until they are satisfied. There is no reason to write like this, especially if you're trying to teach someone something. The chapters of the book can be translated into speaking man's English to good effect, and every one of the 28 critical terms really is simple enough to explain without the comically frequent fallback on Latin phrases and words.
I don't know why so many people think this is a great book. Maybe because it's filled with words like 'prosopopoeia,' which is, I'll admit, a valid English word, but a little bit limited in its general use among readers beginning to learn about critical theory. The flow of the essays becomes stinted by the necessity of referring to a dictionary at every fourth word and then translating the resulting mess into a sentence that normal people understand.
In short, this is a bad textbook. The authors have hidden very simple concepts behind such a thick wall of confusing use of language and terminology that the reader becomes a gold miner, chipping away at the useless mountain of words before him to extract what little vein of content he can find.