Used price: $0.65
Used price: $1.59
Buy one from zShops for: $3.80
It wasn't until around the midpoint that I began having difficulty finishing the book. For starters, the dialogue was slowing me down because of some of the character's accents, like this Scottish one: "This world's gangin' all aglae!" Then there were the occasions where the author wanted to preach at the reader instead of being a storyteller, which is her obvious intention by reading her bio--of being a "messenger" over a writer. So I'd just skim over these parts and move on to the bigger story.
While Livingston-Hill is a well-known Christian romance writer, there is no romance in this book. Yet I would hardly call it a suspense novel either. But readers who like wholesome, well-written stories that are somewhat akin to L. M. Montgomery, then I'd recommend this book.
Used price: $2.49
Used price: $5.45
List price: $18.95 (that's 79% off!)
Used price: $3.05
Collectible price: $14.28
Buy one from zShops for: $3.11
Used price: $13.29
Buy one from zShops for: $13.29
Ultimately, I think one's comfort or discomfort with Cobb's attempt will be shaped by whether or not the reader agrees with the claim that Wesley's theology is too particular to his own time to be relevant today. For my part, I think there is much in Wesley that is still relevant. I therefore disagree with Cobb's premise.
Nevertheless, this book IS worth reading, and no student of contemporary Methodism should be unfamiliar with it.
Cobb writes from the perspective that because our current situation is very different from the culture that John Wesley lived in, much of what Wesley taught is no longer useable for today's United Methodist. Cobb recognizes the lack of a unified sense of identity among United Methodists and suggests that a clarified role in the mission of the church must be preceded by a unified theology. He attempts to come to terms with the theological heritage from Wesley by reappraising his work and finding relevance of Wesleyan thought for the contemporary world.
List price: $19.99 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $12.00
Collectible price: $12.71
Buy one from zShops for: $8.74
Dr. Evans, please think this theology through! There are Christians who have given (and are now risking) their lives to proclaim Jesus' Gospel! Look elsewhere for sound doctrine on Salvation; start with a good study Bible and a commentary on Romans!
Please read this book!!
Used price: $5.50
Buy one from zShops for: $8.99
The disrespect for Mr Armstrong is evident from the outset.
In the 'real' Worldwide Church of God no one would be called 'Smith', 'Johnson', or 'Armstrong' !
The attempted disintegration step by step of every major belief of the 'real' WCG merely shows that these authors never believed those precepts to begin with. The authors present a 132
page account of guerilla warfare, a foray,if you will,of unbelievers into a territory strange to them with the sole intent of destroying the government of that territory!
To the Protestant world, those faithful folks who use the name of Christ to their own advantage, Mr Tkach is a hero! If a person
who has heard the truth (faith comes by hearing) has a shred of doubt and needs a club of cohorts to assure him that obedience (to the ten commandments) is not relevant, this is the source of comfort they need!
Mr Herbert W Armstrong was just a man, tempted just as we are!
Yes! He sinned! Just as we do! Jesus Christ was tempted just as we are! Yet without sin.... therein lies our only hope of salvation! Mr Armstrong was a man of faith, charachter assassination is only to his credit! It shows he was more correct in his understanding of the word of God than his detractors! He did not acheive his goals by trickery. He did not 'lie in wait' for someone to die then grasp an opportunity build his own ideals in the middle of someone elses' work then knock down the walls and present some bright shiny new thing to be accepted by a deceived world.
With respect to law and grace, Herbert Armstrong never taught that we are saved by works. The current WCG leaders even admit in their interview on page 123 that "HWA knew that salvation was by grace, not by works" and that HWA "meant that lawkeeping was a consequence of faith, not a cause of salvation." Armstrong wrote thousands of pages of books and articles and no one has ever produced a quote where he taught salvation by works. The teaching was quite plain and clear-works are what we owe to God, but they do not save us. The authors, as well as Greg Albrecht (who says on p.109 "Christians want to read about Martin Luther") are fond of Luther's theology. This is the same Martin Luther who was so confused about works and grace that he called the epistle of James "an epistle of straw" which he claimed did not belong in the Bible. Luther's 'soundness' of mind is shown in his work "Concerning the Jews and Their Lies"(1543), where he "not only repeated all medieval libels against Jews but went further than his predecessors in explicitly preaching violence: 'We are at fault in not slaying them,' Luther wrote"(The Holocaust Encyclopedia-p.18).
Then there is the circular reasoning (p.42); one cannot use councils and creeds of one's own church as proofs against those who claim to be the spiritual heirs of the early dissidents. Also, on page 50, the authors cite 1Corin15:42-44,51-52 as 'proof' of the immortal soul, but ignore verse 53 which says that "this mortal must put on immortality". By the way, was Jesus teaching salvation by works when he said in John14:15 "If you love Me, keep My commandments"? How about in Matt19:17 when He said "But if you want to enter into life, keep the commandments"? Was Peter teaching salvation by works in Acts2:38 when he said "Repent"? How about Paul in 1Corin7:19 where he says "Circumcision is nothing and uncircumcision is nothing, but keeping the commandments of God is what matters"?
The point the authors (and Luther) miss is that Paul in his writings is addressing those who thought they could be justified by keeping the law (see Gal2:16,21), not those who kept the law out of obedience and love toward God (see 1Jn2:4 and 1Jn5:2-3). James, on the other hand, was addressing those who thought they could be saved by faith without any accompanying works. We should always take the clear, unambiguous Scriptures and use them to interpret the confusing ones. The authors write (p.59) "The church is described in a number of ways in the Bible. ...None of these designations for the church alludes to the keeping of the sabbath, or to any law categories whatsoever." Well, none of the 13 verses they cite does, but Rev12:17 and Rev14:12 CLEARLY describe the Church as those who "keep the commandments of God." How is it then legalism for Armstrong to say that we must obey the commandments? If Jesus, knowing this controversy would arise, had wanted to settle the matter in advance, He could not have taught more clearly than He did in Matt5:17-19 when He said "Do not think that I came to destroy the Law or the Prophets". Likewise Paul when he said in Rom3:31 "Do we then make void the law through faith? Certainly not!" And those who claim to be New Covenant Christians would do well to read Heb8:8-10 to see what that covenant is.
And finally, the Global Church of God was started near the end of 1992, not in 1990 as the authors claim on page 74.
The book was disappointingly brief and somewhat academic in its approach. What could have been made to be an exciting narrative on events that lead to the dramatic turn around in the WCG is instead a short look at main points. Further, the book hinted a problems and concerns within the church but never explored them in any detail or gave any indication of sources.
Outline: 1) Present Situation (pg 15-17) 2) History of Herbert Armstrong (pg 19-40) -- drew heavily on Armstrong's autobiography and did not really go beyond the surface 3) Teachings (pg 41-59) -- good examination of WCG teachings 4) 1986 to now (pg 61-71) -- only ten pages are actually dedicated to the title of the book -- a disappointingly short, cursory explanation of what happened. 5) Reaction (pg 72-83) -- once again, too brief -- only six paragraphs are dedicated to "the dissenters." 6) Future (pg 83-89) -- offers only a number of "we hopes" but no informed expectations. Appendix (pg 90-132) is an examination of the new WCG teachings and transcripts of interview with WCG leadership.
Overall, I found the book accurate but a disappointing effort and not worth the price.