Used price: $18.13
The book is indeed entertaining, although there are many dark moments and the whole story is suffused by the determination or desire of Emma Watson to be independent (something that might be labelled as post-modern interpretation, or feminist interpretation). For those of you not completely familiar with THE WATSONS, the book begins when a young lady Emma Watson is obliged to return to her family - a widower clergyman father and his many children - when her rich aunt marries a fortune-hunter and moves to Ireland. Much of the story is preoccupied with the economic and social position of the Watsons, particularly the three unmarried daughters (a fourth unmarried daughter marries at the outset) and the situation of Emma Watson in particular as she is bounced from home to home. The ending is a trifle unrealistic, since it appears to be a pastiche of Austen's own encounters with Royalty and the happy ending of PERSUASION.
The tone is completely unlike that of Austen; I thought I should make that clear for anyone seeking the wit and irony of Austen herself. Although I have not found any sequel or continuation or pastiche completely satisfactory, Aiken's JANE FAIRFAX was the most faithful both in plot and spirit to Austen's own works. This book draws more from Austen's own life and considerably from the situation of the Dashwood sisters in Sense & Sensibility. [In fact, think of this story as Sense & Sensibility, combined with a bit of Persuasion for the ending, with some other highly romantic elements thrown in].
I found the book rather disappointing if I approached it as a Janeite. [Most of Aiken's recent works using Austen characters have been similarly disapointing.] Even as a stand-alone novel, I found the work oddly disjointed. The most brilliantly drawn characters were those who were the villains or the most disagreeable. The personalities of the more likeable characters seem oddly flat, and one of them - the Rev Mr Howard - very different from start to finish. Emma Watson herself, although showing traces of Austen's own character, seemed oddly passive in her relationship with her aunt who had cast her off in preference to a young second husband, a stand that I found too self-sacrificing (compared to her general thoughts and attitudes). I think this could have been an interesting and even a great novel if some characters had been better developed, and if the ending had been made more realistic. For a really good example of how this is done, read Jean Rhys's WIDE SARGASSO SEA.
Used price: $0.65
Collectible price: $2.98
Buy one from zShops for: $4.99
Used price: $5.00
Buy one from zShops for: $7.76
Used price: $8.49
Collectible price: $30.00
Buy one from zShops for: $11.98
Things start out rather well, actually, as the novel follows the romantic adventures of Fanny's younger sister Susan as she resides at Mansfield while Fanny and her husband are away in Antigua. Many of the old characters return, and I have to give Aiken credit for creditably fleshing out the character of the wicked Mary Crawford. Since the end of Austen's novel, Mary has suffered a great deal, and Aiken does a good job of making her a tad more complex. What she does with Henry Crawford is interesting also; although here Aiken sows the seeds of her novel's undoing. (SPOILER) She sets up Henry to be the romantic hero of her novel, a mildly shocking idea for fans of the original. The next third of the book is devoted to the evolving relationship between him and Susan, and we come to expect the inevitable. And then, in a highly annoying manner, Aiken wimps out and sticks her with another character who has spent the length of the novel being loutish and vulgar, and who at end is redeemed in a completely unbelievable way. I felt extremely sorry for poor Susan, and I don't think that was Aiken's intent. (END SPOILER)
So, while it starts out promising, "Mansfield Revisted" ends badly, leaving a sour taste in the reader's mouth. I do not recommend it, especially not for Austen fans.
Used price: $1.06
Buy one from zShops for: $5.25
I read the book and athough probably not the best in the world, I felt it certainly did not deserve the slams it received. Yes, the characters are flawed, but so are real humans. While most of the other reviewers had a hard time with the heroine, Leigh, I had the greatest difficulty with the hero, Michael. What an incrediably obnoxious, arrogant, INSENSITIVE man. All he could do was laugh at every situation not matter how the other person was suffering. I don't think Leigh treated her father like dirt. Considering the brainwashing her mother had accomplished on her, I think she treated her Dad with kid gloves. So she misunderstood her Dad - tell me who isn't misunderstood? I, too, didn't care for how everything was tidied up including the final interchange between Leigh and her father. Life is not tidy. Very, very few of us have a sudden ephiphany where everything in our life is resolved. But then, the majority of romance books are just that -happily ever after endings. We keep buying them, don't we?
It seems that some authors cannot resist the temptation to rewrite Joan's history in terms of their own ideology. The end result hardly qualifies as history.
Used price: $0.01
Collectible price: $3.00
Buy one from zShops for: $1.25
According to the first paragraph on back cover the story is about Kate Quinn, an orphaned girl, who is raised by her wealthy stepfather. The young Kate feels lonely and out of place until she meets the boy next door (Ethan Winston), who becomes her best friend and soul mate. The second paragraph of the synopsis states that Kate, as the legal guardian of her half-sisters, must raise them alone just as Ethan is raising his young DAUGHTER alone (actually he has a son and not a daughter). Kate, who has always loved Ethan, suggests that they join forces and raise their dependents together.
Well needless to say I expected the book to be about Kate and Ethan's marriage and life together... but it was not. I found the book frustrating because I kept waiting for things to happen that would allow the two to get married. It sounds kind of morbid, but I kept waiting for Kate's stepfather to die so Kate would become her half-sisters guardian. I also kept waiting for something to happen to Ethan's wife (how could he marry Kate if he was already married to someone else). Well neither of those things happened until late in the book, and Kate and Ethan don't end up married until almost the very end.
I found myself on edge the entire time I was reading the book. When was this going to happen, when was that going to take place. I think if the synopsis had been worded differently, my impression of the book might have been totally different (but then again maybe not).
Used price: $4.63
Buy one from zShops for: $9.79