Used price: $11.00
Buy one from zShops for: $22.95
Used price: $1.50
Collectible price: $7.41
Buy one from zShops for: $6.25
The index of this book lists only the names of particular people, not their ideas, so it is difficult to use it to locate signs of decline like neutron bombs or the ultimate collapse of a star "into some kind of neutron slush." (p. 210). Chapter 7, "Even Stars Must Die: Red Giants, White Dwarfs, Black Holes," describes what is expected to happen in "star ovens" as their density and temperature keep climbing. The ultimate description of ourselves as previous stars is "With the exception of hydrogen, all the atoms--or rather atomic nuclei--of which we are made were once located inside stars that subsequently exploded as supernovae." (p. 209).
Nietzsche is in the index, and gets credit for the desire "to regain this world after God and the next world had been lost." (p. 32). Written a hundred years after Nietzsche's books, this book is not afraid to admit that German ideas "betrayed his own life-affirming philosophy; thus providing a direct path to the nihilism of our century, which found its most terrible manifestation thus far in Nazi ideology." (p. 33). Some of the results of physics were pretty terrible in the twentieth century, too. Instead of taking such a gloomy view of reality, it is more cheerful to admit that Nietzsche had some amazing ideas that relate directly to the title of this book, and to the novel, LAUGHING WAR by Martyn Burke:
*Todlachen* said Sam Senior one day when they sat together in a booth too close to the jukebox. It means laugh till it kills you. It's a German word. Oi, God too has a sense of irony. (Burke, p. 34).
Nietzsche pictured that laughter most powerfully in Part Three of THUS SPOKE ZARATHUSTRA, at the end of the section called "Of Apostates." (Penguin Classics, translated by R. J. Hollingdale, p. 201. THE PORTABLE NIETZSCHE, p. 294).
The conclusion of this book exhibits a modern level of sophistication. "As with relapses into mythical and mystical thinking in past epochs, here, too, a deep religious exhaustion leads people to expect solid proof for the unprovable. In a way, modern science adds fuel to this hope." (p. 238). Though it is rarely mentioned, theology is still ticking, and Paul Tillich gets credit for saying, "This is the God Nietzsche said had to be killed because nobody can tolerate being made into a mere object of absolute knowledge and absolute control." (p. 246). Readers of this book might not be aware of how limited any outlook based on ideas seems in a comparison with a monstrosity of teeming feelings which exceeds the scope of consciousness even more than this book, for GOD'S LAUGHTER is rather puny compared to the vast scope of Nietzsche's work. The funny thing is that any decline in philosophy since the time of Nietzsche might have been intentional as far as everybody was concerned, so help me God.
Used price: $15.88
Collectible price: $47.65
As a high school junior doing an independent study on religion, I chose this book from the recommendations that said that it was a good overview, a good book for a beginner. I found, however, that this praise was highly misleading.
The book is divided into sections: history, basic ideas, topics, and personalities. Each of these sections are subdivided into chapters, each a few pages long.
Many of these chapters are interesting, but they lack full explaination of the ideas included. Often, there was just a list of facts and opposing viewpoints, and when i found a sentence that was interesting, Scholem would immediately move on to another source, another name, another viewpoint. Pages would go by before the point of the chapter could be discerned, and even then, was often revealed only vaguely. The hebrew transliterations were also difficult to navigate, for after the english translation was given once, it was as though the reader was simply expected to know it. The chapters often consisted of page after page of other books to look at, other authors to read.
As a general overview for a beginner, Kaballah certainly does not qualify. I later learned that the book was written as an encyclopedia, a reference book for scholars. For someone who already had a knowledge of the Kaballah and its ideas, as well as a knowledge of hebrew, Kaballah is most likely a much more interesting and useful book to own. As for someone beginning their studies into this esoteric and mysterious branch of judaism, a more simple, fact based book would serve a much more useful purpose.
The topic of Kabbalah studies has recently been overloaded by a spate of publications that vary in scholarship and accessibility from the arcane to the truly pathetic. Scholem's book, while slightly older, is definitely a cure for all of the smarmy new-age occultism that threatens to turn the study of the Kabbalah into a subject on par with palm reading or UFO abductions.
Scholem is a first-class scholar, and what he provides here is a thorough history of ideas that surround the Kabbalah. He treats the subject with all of the respect that the best religious scholars would give to a subject, and he's extremely well-versed in the materials upon which he comments. He guides the reader through the history, development, and transition of the Kabbalah through European intellectual history, and through the changes in the Jewish tradition. For that reason, it's as much an interesting story of the history of Judaic thought as it is an investigation into 'mysticism'.
Scholem is consistenly clear in his terminology, precise in his historical references, and honest in his accounts. He provides excellent bibliographies to help the read get at some of the essential issues and personages.
This isn't a 'how-to' book on Kabbalist 'magick' as so frequently appears on the shelves of esoteric bookshops. This is a critical work that is written in strict academic style, yet is highly readable, challenging, and very thorough. It's the sort of book that, if you read it, you'll know more about the topic than %99 of the people out there currently babbling about it. It does a genuine service to affirm the proper importance of Jewish theology and Jewish spiritual traditions in the world of scholarship. And, to be honest, I'd highly recommend it students of religious studies, to the current crop of occultists who're looking for the genuine article when it comes to the Kabbalah, and for those who're keen on studying theological enquiry.
Especially nice, I thought, are the glossary at the back and the second section of the book, which is a collection of 'topics' which are read much like large encyclopedia articles. One can look up 'evil' and see the theodicy of the Kabbalah; or you can find 'Torah' and see a discussion of Kabbalistic midrash (commentary).
I've read lots of rubbish with the word 'Kabbalah' on the cover. This book made me forget about all of that.
Read it - and get the heart and root of a glorious endeavour of human communication with God.
Used price: $11.95
Buy one from zShops for: $9.99
Used price: $9.75
Buy one from zShops for: $9.75
"Some say, "I would feel better about God hearing my prayer if I were more worthy and lived a better life." I simply answer: If you don't want to pray before you feel that you are worthy or qualified, then you will never pray again. Prayer must not be based on or depend on your personal worthiness or the quality of the prayer itself but on the unchanging truth of God's promise. If the prayer is based on itself, or on anything else besides God's promise, then it's a false prayer that deceives you - even if your heart was breaking with intense devotion, and you were weeping drops of blood. We pray because we are unworthy to pray. Our prayers are heard precisely because we believe that we are unworthy. We become worthy to pray when we risk everything on God's faithfulness alone."
Used price: $15.50
This is an excellent text for a graduate course that stands the test of time. If it has been revised, I am not familiar with the new edition and any possible changes that may have occurred.
List price: $14.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $10.42
Buy one from zShops for: $9.82
Used price: $15.95
Buy one from zShops for: $19.86
List price: $80.00 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $47.65
Buy one from zShops for: $54.98
The first is known as the "root fallacy." The ancient origin of a word [100-5000 years earlier] has little if anything to do with its use or meaning in a particular text in the New Testament. This is also known in modern semantics as the 'etymological fallacy.'
Similarly, there is an enormous difference between diachronic [through time] linguistics and synchronic linguistics [same time]. The use of a word 100-5000 years earlier or later has little if anything to do with its use at a particular time by a particular person.
Another now classic fallacy has been called the "illigitimate totality transfer." That is when a reader of a particular N.T. text illigitimately imports or includes all possible uses found everywhere else throughout all time into a particular text in the N.T.
The reader is referred to excellent books on the subject by James Barr [who broke the grown in applying modern linguistics and semantics into Biblical exegesis] and more recently D.A. Carson ["Exegetical Fallacies"].
Regarding the Nazi affiliation of its editor and some of its authors, we are all a mixed bag. Do we refuse to listen to music conducted by Herbert von Karajan because he was a Nazi, or of Strauss because he was a womanizer? As James Sveda said on a "Record Shelf" program on NPR years ago on this subject, "Perhaps the last word on this subject was said by a carpenter who lived two thousand years ago, 'Judge not, lest you yourselves be judged.'"
This is a wonderful resource, especially for those lacking the expertise (or the $$) to tackle the full 10-volume work.
Used price: $39.94
Buy one from zShops for: $45.00
I do not recommend it, not even to beginners, though it can be a good introductory book. It indeed is much less abstract than a classic text of the same level, with many illustrations, and in depth detailed explanations (for beginners serious after the idea of doing Mathematics, I suggest Rudin's "Principles of Mathematical Analysis"). It has many things at its advantage anyway. It shows for instance how many astoundingly insecure results were granted, and thus illustrates well the experimental aspect of mathematics, often denied. It comes with false proof (for instance Euler's taking limit of series or Ampere's theorem about derivatives of continuous functions), and reveal the difficulty of such giants like the Bernoulli, Cauchy or Weierstrass with the problems of convergence. It sure helps understand how mathematics are partly a science of discovery, not a science of just invention. It shows mathematicians are mere people, after all, and that one's difficulties have little significance. In the overall, it sheds light on the genuine mathematical world, which is often seen as a cold topic where one makes its way to the solution through lengthy linear computations. This a book that can definitely make you love mathematics, and ask once you caught the hint for more abstract, deeper texts (Rudin for instance).
Thus while the merging (once more not the simple association) of the theory with its development's history was not necessary, it has been _very well_ done. If this approach pleases you, this book is for you.