Used price: $9.75
Collectible price: $47.65
For the most part, the tone rings honestly, and so I do believe that Willie played an active role in the writing of his autobiography with Charles Einstein - which can't be said for all athlete biographies, of course.
This was written before Jim Bouton's "Ball Four", when it first became customary for ballplayer autobiographies to compete with each other by showing as much of the game's dirty linen as possible. So there are no sensational revelations here.
But this is a good snapshot of the era in which Willie played, as he experienced it at the time.
A very lyrical phrase which begins "I remember the clouds" opens the first chapter of this book which takes place in the 9th inning of the New York Giants' deciding 1951 playoff game against the Brooklyn Dodgers.
In this inning, responding to a heartfelt plea from manager Leo Durocher, the Giants would cap a season marked by a miraculous comeback from 13 1/2 games out and stage an incredible 4-run rally in the bottom of the 9th inning to steal the pennant from Brooklyn - capped off, of course, by Bobby Thomson's famous 3-run homer, hit while Willie, a 20 year old rookie in 1951, was nervously waiting his turn in the on-deck circle.
When the book shifts to the last game of the 1962 playoffs between the Giants and Dodgers (both since transplanted to the West Coast), Willie or Einstein or both cleverly start that chapter with the same lyrical phrase that begins with, "I remember the clouds..."
The Giants, of course, are about to repeat history by staging another last-ditch comeback to win, though it will be with less melodrama than that which took place in 1951, and in view of this, the authors recite where some of the participants from 1951 are on this occasion in 1962.
"Durocher?" Willie asks rhetorically. "He was in the Dodger dugout as a coach. But I knew he remembered. I knew he remembered." Yes, one expects that Durocher must have remembered; must have awaited the start of the 9th inning with trepidation; and must have been the least surprised man on the field or in the dugout at the outcome.
On this occasion, of course, Willie is not a mere spectator, but on this occasion, eleven years later, he's no longer a nervous rookie but an established star who wants to be up there with the game on the line, and his single off of Ed Roebuck's leg fanned the flames of the rally.
For the most part, it's over the head of the Giants organization that the clouds have hung, but one must be grateful to Mays and Einstein for portraying - and in such poetic fashion - two occasions where the clouds hung over the heads of their opponents instead.
Say Hey!
Used price: $2.99
Collectible price: $6.00
Buy one from zShops for: $3.45
Used price: $1.25
Collectible price: $4.24
List price: $18.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $6.99
Buy one from zShops for: $5.19
Used price: $1.95
Collectible price: $3.49
List price: $16.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $6.50
Buy one from zShops for: $8.95
List price: $22.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $4.48
Collectible price: $19.80
Buy one from zShops for: $5.95
Musica is a book full of misinformation. Some examples:
Musician turned dance promoter Federico Pagani was not italian, he was Puertorican. Chick Webb did not die in 1932, he died on June 6, 1939. "Hall of Famer" Mario Bauza and Dizzy Gillespie did not move together into Cab Calloway's orchestra, nor did they played with Calloway in 1932. It was in 1938 that Bauza joined Calloway's band. Pretending to be sick, and without warning to Calloway, he sent Gillespie to play in his place...that is how the great Gillespie got into Calloway's band.
On page 41 a huge blunder is committed. Here it is stated that "Hall of Famer" Maria Teresa Vera was the first Cuban woman on record. Her suppose debut recording was in New York with Sexteto Habanero in 1918. Nothing could be further from the truth. The facts are that the first Cuban singer on record was "Hall of Famer" Rosalia "Chalia" Herrera Diaz. Not only was she the first singer of Latin origen on record, she is also the very first to record a "habanera". She manages to do all this with the famous "Habanera Tu" in New York in 1901!
I doubt very much that Maria Teresa Vera did any recordings with the Sexteto Habanero in 1918...first, this is the year in which the Sexteto Habanero was formed and secondly, those who have done their research indicate that the Sexteto Habanero's first recording was realized on October 29, 1925 with a tune titled "Maldita Timidez"...Maria Teresa Vera was not part of this recording. However, Maria Teresa Vera was probably the first female to direct a group in Cuba and probably in South America. She did this with the famous Sexteto Occidente that did recordings for Columbia Records around 1925 in New York. She also recorded for the Brunswick and Odeon labels. She later sold the group to "Hall of Famer" Ignacio Pineiro who renamed the group Sexteto Nacional.
The book goes on and on with countless errors. It is a shame, Because Sue Steward is a very good writer and the book has a great colorful layout, with dozens of great photos. It also has a good amount of solid information. But how is the reader suppose to decipher fact from fiction? You can see the confusion by the reviews written on this book. People who have no knowledge about the history of Latin music gave this book good reviews...they assumed everything was true and they enjoyed and believed that its content was accurate. That's the sad part of this book...people are going to read it and be persuaded that it is accurate and perpetuate the misinformation on to others.
I do believe that all is not lost...perhaps Sue Steward would take the responsible high-road and issue a revised accurate edition. Careful and meticulous research can make this book a winner. In the meantime I would hope that Sue Steward does not attempt to produce a television program based on the information in this book...that would be a great diservice to those who contributed so much to this great music and to those who work so hard at researching the truth.
Used price: $195.22
The truth about the effect of slavery on Black Americans can be found in slave narratives like "The Narrative of Frederick Douglass" and Kenneth Stampp's "The Peculiar Insitution." Leave this Willie Lynch mess to the street-corner crackpots.
Darkmandca