Used price: $2.95
Collectible price: $1.06
Used price: $6.25
Used price: $9.00
military college in South Carolina, tells the story of her experience there
in her new YA memoir, IN THE COMPANY OF MEN: A WOMAN AT THE CITADEL.
Although the writing is passable, it's not top-notch--there's a lot of
"telling" and too little "showing"--and there are some details left out that
might have helped.
HOWEVER, I do believe it will have an audience with younger high school
students (and maybe middle schoolers, are though there are a few S and F
words scattered throughout), and I recommend it on this list for that
reason. In the current national climate, there is likely to be more demand
for books about the military and training for it. I think this book is
valuable, especially for teen girls, because it depicts a woman successfully
completing a rigorous, typically male-dominated course of study. In
addition, she has ADD, and triumphs in spite of her troubles with school
work.
Mace explains that the Citadel is a functioning anachronism and always has been, that's part of its appeal. This reviewer commanded a battalion when women were first assigned to the 82nd Airborne Division about twenty years before The Citadel integrated women into the Corps of Cadets. In a long special operations career I consistently found women who met every expectation - physical and mental -- of their male commanders. My rhetorical question at that time was, if our unit is provided female paratrooper officers, why none from The Citadel? Why no female Citadel graduates in industry and politics? Mace helped to change that nitwitterey.
It sometimes seems that Mace's book is more about Mace than The Citadel which under her circumstances is acceptable, but limiting. Many girls will read this book and ask who needs all the stress created by the 4th Class system along with the other pressures of college? Unfortunately, Mace doesn't provide the answer. Here is the answer: The Citadel graduates a higher percentage of its freshman class in four years than any other state college or university in South Carolina and among the top five percent in the nation. The Citadel does this providing a superior education, an honor system that works, a commitment to national duty and fidelity, and a sense of self worth rare on most campuses. Cadets are taught by professors, not graduate students, the education is demanding, and one of the best education values in this country. The Citadel "system" develops a young person's mind, physical capability, and character in a crucible of measured stress. It's a good preparation for real life. But, a word of caution - the motivation for all this must be from within the student, not urged by the parent.
I don't often get into 'juvenile literature,' which is how this book is categorized. In fact, the last 'juvy' book I read was 'Battle Dress,' Amy Efaw's fictionalized account of her first year at the US Military Academy, a title to which 'In the Company of Men' bears certain obvious similarities. Some of the things other reviewers have considered lacking in this book -- insufficient legal context, not enough sociological analysis -- can, I think, be explained by looking at for whom Mace was writing. Having read Strum and Brodie about VMI, as well as Catherine Manegold's tendentious 'In Glory's Shadow,' I too hope to see some of these issues addressed first-person on an adult level. But that's not to take anything away from this book.
Nancy Mace's story is well written and inspirational. And though I understood the strong feelings and resentments many of The Citadel's alumni and friends bore about the (inevitable, in my opinion) decision to admit women, I was still shocked by the vehemence of the abuse she received -- especially from 'the wealthy Charleston women who formed the backbone of Citadel social support,' known as South of Broads (referring to Broad Street), or SOBs. Mace considers the abbreviation apt, and I can't say I disagree with her. Similarly, the drunken alumnus who took it upon himself to personally berate Mace at every Citadel football game should be shamed into seclusion by her portrait of him (though I suspect he still considers himself a hero).
At the same time, there's also a lot of humor in this story, as well as touching comradeship with (some of) her fellow cadets and a deep and reciprocated love for her parents. Mace may not address the larger question of why a young woman (or, for that matter, a young man) might want to attend The Citadel, but it's clear why *she* did: she loved her father, and she loves the school. I'd been looking for some time for a book that details the life and experience of a cadet at VMI or The Citadel, and here at last is that portrait. It's moving, challenging, and its target audience should, I hope, find it inspirational. I commend the author for writing the book, but more importantly for her determination to confront the challenges and emerge on top.
Used price: $0.99
Buy one from zShops for: $1.00
This book was in the young adult section at the library... and the whole time I was reading it I felt like Mary Pope Osbourne was dying to write a mermaid bodice ripper, but didn't want to upset her magic treehouse fans. The book had the elements of a fairy tale with the feel of a harlequin romance thrown in. (She only alludes to sex, but it feels forced or restrained - just not right).
I didn't give a poop what happened to the lord and his lady by the end... it was boring and silly, and I am astonished it has received so many good reviews here on amazon. I'd love to read the original story it's based on (and plan to). I have a feeling there might have been a lot more to work with that Osborne didn't bother to bring to the page.
Go read Hans Christian Anderson or a book on sea-lore instead.
The horrible paperback cover says enough in itself. The hardback (which I read, was much spookier looking).
Used price: $0.43
Collectible price: $1.45
Buy one from zShops for: $0.35
Used price: $0.40
Collectible price: $10.00
Buy one from zShops for: $2.40
Bottom Line: Great book, must read!
List price: $16.15 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $3.99
Collectible price: $2.99
Buy one from zShops for: $10.00
Used price: $0.08
Collectible price: $4.00
Buy one from zShops for: $10.95
Oh yeah, the ending... What ending?
No Hard Feelings,
Andrew Nisinson
I found the narrative sometimes overly descriptive, especially in the preoccupation with sunlight and shadow. The brownstones and the streets often seemed like dark and brooding places.
My maternal grandparents were from Bardados, while my paternal grandfather was from St. Eustacia. I also grew up in Brooklyn (in a brownstone). Therefore, the landscape and the characters were very familiar. In fact, Claremont Sealy and Clive Springer are probably my cousins! A most enjoyable and thought provoking book. I look forward to reading more of Ms Marshall's book.
Used price: $1.59
Buy one from zShops for: $8.99
A gentle, relaxing dip into Shakespeare. I'll give two stars.