Related Subjects: Author Index Reviews Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
Book reviews for "Schaarwaechter,_Georg" sorted by average review score:

The Mystery of the Aleph: Mathematics, the Kabbalah, and the Human Mind
Published in Hardcover by Four Walls Eight Windows (15 January, 2000)
Author: Amir D. Aczel
Amazon base price: $17.47
List price: $24.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $5.25
Collectible price: $15.88
Buy one from zShops for: $15.29
Average review score:

A delightful guide to the foothills of a huge subject
This delightful little book is a Cook's Tour of some very important personalities in mathematics and their work on the concept of Infinity (actually various magnitudes of infinities, I guess), the Continuum Hypothesis, and the Axiom of Choice. While the author takes us back to the ancient Pythagoreans and their determination to keep irrational numbers secret knowledge, the story really centers around Georg Cantor and his struggles in founding the study of mathematics in this field. Cantor was a mystic as well and there is also more than one appearance of the Kabbalah.

Certainly, you can't learn the subject from this book. However, like visiting some vast architectural wonder that you can only take in as a big view, this book places lots of Post It notes on important points if you want to begin reading more deeply about these profound ideas. And if you don't, it is certainly a fund way to spend a few hours.

The author provides four pages of references for further reading, but if, like me, you don't know the field you will likely have to do preliminary studies to just get to the foothills of really taking on the subjects studied in this book. If you already understand the math then this book is likely too light for you unless you somehow missed out on the history of your field.

I enjoyed the book and if you are interested in how serious thinkers learned to think about Infinity and what it actually means, then this book is a fine initial guide.

Aczel writes another winner
Mr. Aczel's new volume on Cantor artfully weaves mathematics, history, religion, and psychology into a coherent narrative. The organizing theme is the historical development of the concept of infinity. Aczel traces infinity's history from the Pythagoreans of Classical Greece through the work of modern logicians and mathematicians such as Godel and Cohen, focusing on the contributions of Georg Cantor.

Aczel gives admirably pithy biographical summaries of the main players in this drama, including Galileo, Bolzano, Weierstrass, Kronecker, and Dedekind, and he brings to life the evolution of the key ideas. Particularly striking is the intellectual battle between Cantor and his teacher Kronecker, whose fundamental philosophical differences concerning the nature of infinity degenerated into a bitter personal feud.

Aczel sensitively draws parallels between Cantor's investigations of infinity and the Kabbalistic explorations of the Jewish mystics. He notes the importance of Cantor's and Godel's work on Turing's formal description and investigation of computation in the 1930s, but could have given more detail on how Turing used Cantor's diagonalization argument to show that uncomputable functions exist and that such problems as the Halting Problem are undecidable. This is a minor quibble. Overall, Aczel has pulled off a real coup by giving an engaging account of a fascinating story combining intellectual history, spiritual exploration, and human drama.

A great book about mathematics
I thoroughly enjoyed this well-written account of the life of Georg Cantor, the first mathematician to understand and develop the concept of infinity. Amir D. Aczel does a wonderful job explaining the mathematics as well as telling the stories of the figures involved, including Kurt Goedel, Ernst Zermello, and other mathematicians. This is one of the best books on the history of mathematics. I recommend it with no hesitation.


Vertigo
Published in Paperback by New Directions Publishing (2001)
Authors: Winfried Georg Sebald, W. G. Sebald, and Michael Hulse
Amazon base price: $10.47
List price: $14.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $5.58
Collectible price: $37.06
Buy one from zShops for: $9.50
Average review score:

Excitement in low-voltage
If you're not familiar with Sebald's work, you should read his 'Rings of Saturn' or 'The Emigrants' first. This book, although similar in reflective style, is a bit more introspective than the other two. 'Vertigo' is a kind of a travelogue of the author, and I use the term 'travelogue' loosely. His memories of various places intersect with the travels and events of other people in different periods of time, namely Stendhal, Kafka and Cassanova. This novel is really hard to summarize, and I don't think one should. The most rewarding part of reading this intellectually kinky little book is trying to make heads and tails of it in the end. If you want fast-paced storyline, or exotic occurrences, look elsewhere. But this man's slow, hypnotic prose alone was enough to captivate me til the end. I believe Sebald is a pioneer of contemporary fiction. He bends forms, defies categorization. He subverts fictional truths with real truths and vice-versa, and if it takes putting a picture of his real passport in the book for the sake of documentation, he will do that. (Which he does.) I can't wait to read more of his stuff.

A Tour de Force of History, Memory, Dream and Imagination
"Vertigo," the third of W. G. Sebald's works to appear in English translation, is a disorienting narrative that conflates history, memory, dream, and imagination. The result is another literary tour de force from the author of "The Emigrants" and "The Rings of Saturn," a remarkable work that is difficult to classify, but reinforces Sebald's deserved reputation as one of Europe's most original and preeminent contemporary writers.

"Vertigo" begins with an historical figure, in this case Marie Henri Beyle, better known to literary history as Stendhal. In the opening section ("Beyle, or Love is a Madness Most Discreet"), our third person narrator relates certain of the amorous adventures of Beyle during his travels in Italy, beginning with his first arrival in that country at the age of seventeen as a soldier in Napoleon's army. The year is 1800 and the historical record is drawn from Beyle's own notes of his experience, written more than three decades later at the age of 53. As if foreshadowing the vertiginous unreliability of the narrative to follow, the narrator (Sebald?) relates as follows: "The notes in which the 53-year-old Beyle, writing during a sojourn at Civitavecchia, attempted to relive the tribulations of those days afford eloquent proof of the various difficulties entailed in the act of recollection."

The third person narrative shifts, in the second section, to a first person relation of travels in Austria and Italy by our narrator beginning in the year 1980. It is an unreliable narrative, confounding dream and reality, past and present, in a text that seems to have a mysterious, underlying hermeticism. Thus, while aimlessly wandering the dark streets of Vienna, the narrator often thought he saw someone he knew walking ahead of me. "On one occasion, in Gonzagagasse, I even thought I recognized the poet Dante, banished from his hometown on pain of being burned at the stake." Similarly, in the dark, misty, maze-like streets of Venice, "there sat, and in fact very nearly lay, a man in a worn green loden coat whom I immediately recognized as King Ludwig II of Bavaria."

In a remarkable, resonant passage that writes another layer on the palimpsest of literary renderings of Venice, Sebald writes: "As you enter into the heart of that city, you cannot tell what you will see next or indeed who will see you the very next moment. Scarcely has someone made an appearance than he has quit the stage by another exit. These brief exhibitions are of an almost theatrical obscenity and at the same time have an air of conspiracy about them, into which one is drawn against one's will. If you walk behind someone in a deserted alleyway, you have only to quicken your step slightly to instill a little fear into the person you are following. And equally, you can feel like a quarry yourself. Confusion and ice-cold terror alternate."

In Venice, too, the narrator muses on the dark history of the Doge's Palace, reflecting, in particular on the early nineteenth century writings of the German Franz Grillparzer and on one of the victims of the harsh justice carried out in that palace, Giacomo Casanova. Grillparzer, a lawyer, ponders that "the resolutions passed here by the Council of State must be mysterious, immutable and harsh." It is a thought that brings to mind Kafka's "The Trial", among other things, and it is not surprising that, in the next breath, the reader learns that Casanova's memoir of his imprisonment in the Doge's Palace was first published in, of all places, Prague.

From here, the narrative shifts once again to the third person, this time in a section entitled "Dr. K Takes the Waters at Riva." It is, again, a purportedly historical narrative of Franz Kafka's trip in 1913 from Prague to Vienna and then on to Italy, where he visits Venice, Verona and Riva, a city on the shores of Lake Garda. Kafka's journeys mirror those of the narrator in the second section of the book and the dreamlike repetitions, doublings, doppelgangers which re-occur throughout "Vertigo" provide a deeply entwined narrative for the careful reader. Thus, in a passage that, in some sense, is a trope for the entire text, Kafka stands on the porch of the Pellegrini Chapel in Verona, a place where the narrator himself related he had stood in 1980 in the previous section of the book: "When Doctor K. stood in the porch once again, on the threshold between the dark interior and the brightness outside, he felt for a moment as if the selfsame church were replicated before him, its entrance fitting directly with that of the church he had just left, a mirroring effect he was familiar with from his dreams, in which everything was forever splitting and multiplying, over and again, in the most terrifying manner."

From Kafka's 1913 experiences, the final section of Vertigo relates the narrator's return in November, 1987, to his childhood home in the Tyrol. It is the most introspective and personal section of "Vertigo," but still remains tied to the text that has gone before, resonating with themes, enigmas and uncertainties that make "Vertigo" a puzzle-palace of literary and historical renderings.

I could say much more about "Vertigo," tie many more passages and themes together, make a plethora of textual allusions and connections. This would do nothing more, however, than demonstrate the richness of Sebald's imagination, the density of his writing, the dream-like dislocations and uncertainties of his original and unclassifiable literary enterprise. If you read no other book this year, read "Vertigo" or "The Emigrants" or "The Rings of Saturn"; just be sure to read at least one of W. G. Sebald's books because you will not be disappointed.

Sebald in Italy and the Alps
Although it as only now come out in English, "Vertigo" preceded "The Emigrants" and "Rings of Saturn", and was the first book in which Sebald developed his unique prose style. There are four sections of varying length. The first is devoted to the French writer Stendhal crossing the Alps with Napoleon; the following one shows us the familiar Sebald persona in Italy; the third is about Kafka's trip to the same country; the last and most moving one has the narrator return to his native Bavaria. To those who know Sebald, no more needs to be said. To the others, one might try to give an idea by saying that Sebald's style could perhaps be explained as a kind of civilized interior monologue; it always implies the awareness that writing cannot imitate the way we really think, yet it uses the associations that come to the narrator's mind to make the texutre of the narrative immensely satisfying and touching.


Open Geometry: Opengl + Advanced Geometry
Published in Paperback by Springer Verlag (1999)
Authors: Georg Glaeser and Hellmuth Stachel
Amazon base price: $44.95
Used price: $29.99
Buy one from zShops for: $36.95
Average review score:

Bookware - be aware before you buy
The book is actually a manual for the authors' geometry library, which is provided in full as source. The example programs are excellent.

Unfortunately I bought the book with the intention of using it as a reference for implementing such features as CSG and kinematics. The book itself is not a particularly good text on the subjects, partly due to the weak English used, and partly due to the majority of the book being devoted to describing the use of the library. The two subjects I was looking for were among the better described in the book.

If you're looking for a completely written "bookware" geometry library you'll probably be completely happy. However, be aware the if you're looking to implement the effects described yourself, the best way to learn is by reading the source (which there is plenty of).

There are plenty of good graphics programming sites with better explanations than here on the web for free. However there are few libraries as complete. The book's price is also reasonable, considering the ammount charged by some bookware authors.

A good book on computational geometry & visualization
This book provides a computational geometry visualization library, covering topics that I had a hard time finding good resources for. Solid modeling, swept/extruded surfaces, and boolean operations are all explained. Overall, I liked the presentation; my only complaints are that the book reads a little like a translation (the authors are apparently Austrian) and that the sample programs on the CD(and there are a lot of them!) could be a little better documented.

Advanced Geometry for Instant Usage
This book is for people who need to learn about advanced geometry, and are not scared to look at some code in the process (not all is explained in detail in the book). The book describes data structures and methods used in the code (which you receive on the accompanying CDROM) to create and manipulate complex geometrical objects. This book is not about OpenGL programming, though the code uses it to display the results.

WARNING: The authors started programming the library in PASCAL. They used the p2c translator to create the C code for some 'older' parts of the code. Also the older parts are written in GERMAN. This is what I find the only flaw in this book, because it makes it harder to read it in some cases.

I'm looking forward to version 2.0 of this book which is probably released somewhere in spring 2001.


Yoga for Dummies
Published in Paperback by For Dummies (1999)
Authors: Georg Feuerstein and Larry Payne
Amazon base price: $13.99
List price: $19.99 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $7.99
Collectible price: $13.22
Buy one from zShops for: $9.95
Average review score:

A great starting point
This book is a great place to start a yoga exercise regimen. By no means is the book comprehensive, but you will get an excellent primer in the concepts of physical fitness behind yoga and make a reasoned judgment as to whether or not it is for you. If you choose to pursue yoga further, the book will give you enough theory, both physical and philosophical, to avoid feeling uncomfortable when you walk into your first class. If not, the book gives a sufficient variety of exercises, as well as two full routines and ideas on how to create your own- plenty to keep you in shape and occupied without any further instruction.

I think it's safe to say that an actual live demonstration of yoga, along with instructions tailored to you personally will always be preferable to an 'instruction manual', but as far as books go, I've yet to see a better guide.

At last, a Yoga book I really like!
I've done yoga off and on my whole life. It does keep you flexible. But I don't want to read about yoga philosophy or metaphysics. I just want to do yoga to keep flexible and fit. And I don't want to get hurt doing it. This book really helps.

Yoga for Dummies lists all kinds of yoga postures, has helpful information on protecting your back (really important.) It also has a lot of clear photos and even a section in the back with many yoga resources such as websites, magazines, teachers, videos and more.

This is by far my favorite yoga book!

Brilliant for beginners, reasonable for the adept
Buying a yoga book is a very tricky and haphazard endeavour with an astonishingly number of yoga titles out there. I should know I injured myself by trying to follow a sivananda yoga book. So choosing the wrong book can be quite damaging.

Luckily for me, I was not put off yoga by that experience and instead of giving up I bought this book. I know you may have been told its best to go to class but I see nothing wrong with following a book if its clearly written and gradually increases in difficulty. This is what this book does.

It gives you a varied number of postures. Although I had to read through chapter 15 to get to yoga routine. But this is a minor disagreement and is more a sign of the cautious approach to yoga.
It helps to vanquish all the myths and preconceptions people have of yoga such as twisting your body into the shape of a pretzel or yoga only being for wimps.

Perhaps the "for dummies..." label gets gives people cause to be cautious. But as someone who has studied yoga for a number of years their knowledge and so are the credentials of the authors.

This book is not the be all and end all for yoga with everything you need to know. And any book that does have such a monolithic claim should be avoided.

Rather it's the first step on the long journey towards the mastery of yoga (too deep?!) And the bibliography at the end of the book can help you deepen your knowledge.

It would make a great gift for someone who wants to try yoga and needs a little nudge to go and do it.


Hegel
Published in Paperback by Oxford University Press (1983)
Author: Peter Singer
Amazon base price: $9.95
Used price: $3.75
Collectible price: $5.29
Buy one from zShops for: $5.50
Average review score:

Why do you play with Hegel, master?
I was really surprised to see my Singer cheri having written a book about Hegel. Why Hegel? Why the vulgarisation of philosophy? Who is supposed to read it? I did, 'cause I said to myself that this might be a kind of joke, but unfortunatelly it was not. But I will never understand why do we committ this kind of "litterature". Do not judge Singer using this book. He has much more to say.

Excellent overview
Perhaps some readers do not like Hegel nor Hegelian philosophy. However, it was through reading this brief but informative book, that I came to a much better general understanding of Hegel's intriguing views. Singer really does an outstanding job of explaining complex and frustrating texts to the non-philosopher. Singer's writing is very clear and concise.

Excellent introduction to Hegel
This little volume is a surprisingly good introduction to the thought of a very difficult philosopher, well deserving of inclusion in the fine _Past Masters_ series. I say 'surprising' because people who know Singer only from his own contentious views in favour of abortion, infanticide, and 'animal rights' may not realise that he actually *is* capable of holding responsible opinions when he tries. In fact this carefully planned little work is extremely lucid and thoughtful, well worth the attention even of people who disagree with Singer's own egregious and absurd ethical outlook.


Hegel's Logic
Published in Paperback by Thames & Hudson (1987)
Authors: Georg Wilhelm Friedri Hegel and William Wallace
Amazon base price: $4.95
Average review score:

Buy the Newer Translation
Wallace's translation of Hegel's "Encyclopaedia Logic" is terrible. Buy the newer--and much more faithful--translation by Gereats, Suchting and Harris, available through Hackett Publishing Company.

Buy the other edition
Anyone interested in buying a copy of the so-called 'Lesser Logic" would be better off getting a copy of the newer translation by Harris etc.

Do what thou wilt shall be the whole of the Law.
This is the book Aleister Crowley mentions to be studied in " Liber OS ABYSMI vel DAATH." Via the reason, this man has gathered all systems of philosophy together into one gigantic fulfilment of bewilderment: if one actually contemplates what he means, one will just cause a destruction of the precepts which had accumulated to the point of fervour, thus causing one to feel worse after experiencing this annihilating tragedy of a text-book. Still, there must be some sort of sufficient synthesis inherent in the reading, as to cause a fantastic foam of brewing thoughts in the reflection mode of the Memory phase of the Mind, utterly beyond mere positive thinking.


Phenomenology of Spirit
Published in Paperback by Oxford University Press (1979)
Authors: A.V. Miller, Georg Wilhelm Friedri Hegel, A. V. Miller, and J. N. Findlay
Amazon base price: $13.27
List price: $18.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $7.30
Buy one from zShops for: $12.46
Average review score:

A challenging book.
I was very unimpressed when I first encountered Hegel in my history of philosophy courses. I had been very impressed in my studies of Hume and Kant and the problems they were adressing, but then I found Hegel to be completely impossible to comprehend. I sat through my Hegel lectures, rather unhappily, and then moved on with my other courses. But Hegel's notions apparently kept stirring about in my mind, because later I came back to read the Phenomenology in detail, and some of Hegel's other works as well. Hegel's notions have become a significant part of my outlook and have helped me to comprehend other philosophies and events. Many of his notions are full of depth and meaning, but this meaning requires serious work for extraction. I have no doubt that his work could easily be misused, but one can always find ways to misuse any work, so I don't see this as a serious argument against Hegel.

A Great Work of Philosophy
For over 180 years students have complained that Hegel's best-known book of philosophy, the PHENOMENOLOGY OF MIND (alias PHENOMENOLOGY OF SPIRIT), is too difficult to read. A few have tried to summarize Hegel's book, and often their summaries were longer than the original, and just as difficult to read.

The PHENOMENOLOGY OF MIND is a study of appearances, images and illusions throughout the history of human consciousness. More specifically, Hegel presents the evolution of consciousness. Hegel traces the evolution of consciousness from savage and barbaric forms. Hegel's aim was to set forth a philosophical system so comprehensive that it would encompass the ideas of his predecessors and create a conceptual framework in terms of which both the past and future could be philosophically understood. Such an aim would require nothing short of a full account of reality itself. Thus, Hegel conceived the subject matter of philosophy to be reality as a whole. This reality, or the total developmental process of everything that is, he referred to as the Absolute, or Absolute Spirit. According to Hegel, the task of philosophy is to chart the development of Absolute Spirit. This involves (1) making clear the internal rational structure of the Absolute; (2) demonstrating the manner in which the Absolute manifests itself in nature and human history; and (3) explicating the teleological nature of the Absolute, that is, showing the end or purpose toward which the Absolute is directed. The logic that governs this developmental process is dialectic. The dialectical method involves the notion that movement, or process, or progress, is the result of the conflict of opposites. Traditionally, this dimension of Hegel's thought has been analyzed in terms of the categories of thesis, antithesis, and synthesis. The goal of the dialectical cosmic process can be most clearly understood at the level of reason. As finite reason progresses in understanding, the Absolute progresses toward full self-knowledge. Indeed, the Absolute comes to know itself through the human mind's increased understanding of reality, or the Absolute. Hegel analyzed this human progression in understanding in terms of three levels: art, religion, and philosophy.

At the time of Hegel's death, he was the most prominent philosopher in Germany. His views were widely taught, and his students were highly regarded. His followers soon divided into right-wing and left-wing Hegelians. The extensive and diverse impact of Hegel's ideas on subsequent philosophy is evidence of the remarkable range and the extraordinary depth of his thought, this book is a masterpiece!

A Masterpiece
Many will agree with me in saying that this is the most difficult text in the canon to read. But the profundity of Hegel's insights and the sheer range of topics he treats in this book are astounding. Whether he is discussing the famous master/slave relationship, epistemology, natural science, law, or religion, Hegel's views are always provocative. As other reviewers have mentioned, this book can be examined historically both backwards to Hume and Kant, and forwards toward phenomenology. But for me, this text is so valuable because I find so much that stands on its own. Hegel need not be seen "in context" to be appreciated. Though now almost 200 years old, Hegel's thesis that he had completed the progress of philosophy by recognizing the necessary development of the universal self-consciousness is still relevant, and not entirely untenable despite its grandiose appearance. This is a book that, in the broad view, does come together as a whole, despite scholars' focus on some parts over others. Even if you don't agree with Hegel, his influence on philosophy was immense, and many of the ideas expanded upon in his other works are given a preliminary treatment here. This is probably not a good book for beginners; unfortunately, Hegel never gave us anything like a primer. But for those with a bit of experience and the sensitivity to understand the subtleties of Hegel's sometimes confusing vocabulary, this is an endlessly rewarding book, Western philosophy at its very finest.


Cichlids: Purchase, Care, Feeding, Diseases, Behavior, and Breeding
Published in Paperback by Barrons Educational Series (1991)
Author: Georg Zurlo
Amazon base price: $7.95
Used price: $2.39
Average review score:

Not a bad read for beginners
Not a bad book but is not extensive enough to become knowledgeable for cichlids has all the basics in set up different types of cichlids where they are etc, and is a definate read for the novice but needs a more detailed account for a person who already knows the basics

Helpful with a lack of pics
I thought that this book was very helpful in giving me information that I needed to breed my convinct cichlids, and set up the tank accordingly. Though the pictures were appropriate for the subject and well chosen, they were few and far between. I would have much preferred a color photo for every cichlid mentioned, but of course that's just too much to ask for in a book at the price that it was. All in all, it was well written, but needed visual aids of better quality to make it a 5-star book.

This book is a good price performer. OK for novice.
This book really tries to lay out what you are going to get into if you want to get into keeping, and possibly breeding, African Cichlids. Though it may leave some wanting more, at $5.56 (USD) it really packs alot of information and is a good summary of what you are in for with this intriguing hobby. Agreed, some of the information might be laid out a little more clearly. But it also presents a great deal more about all aspects of raising Africans that you don't get out of books costing $30, $50, even $100 (list price). I recommend it highly to a beginner. To one who has been involved in the hobby for a while, you may get more from rec.aquaria.freshwater.cichlids. But for the novice, I'd suggest you go for it before you decide to buy fish or a tank. It may help you avoid costly mistakes.


Hegel in 90 Minutes (Philosophers in 90 Minutes)
Published in Paperback by Ivan R Dee, Inc. (01 January, 1990)
Author: Paul Strathern
Amazon base price: $6.95
Used price: $4.53
Buy one from zShops for: $4.54
Average review score:

Dreadful!
Strathern's book simply reproduces the ignorant prejudices against Hegel that have bedevilled Anglo-American philosophy. Who should read this book- anyone who wants to make a few dismissive remarks about Hegel in order to give the appearance of learning at a cocktail party. Who should not read this book- anyone who might want to learn something from Hegel.

A fun and helpful 90-minute course in Hegel
This is a witty account and overview of the life and works of Hegel, a challenge for anyone who thought Kant was difficult. The book keeps its promise to tell you everything it can about Hegel in 90 minutes -- the problem is just that you can't learn all that much about Hegel in just 90 minutes.

Strathern hits the mark again!
Strathern is a master at this kind of work, which mixes biography, critical analysis, historical context and humor all in a concise, informative & entertaining package. He lists a time line for the philosopher, his place in world/philosophic history & a selection of works for furthur reading. This series of books by Strathern is a wonderful course in Philosophy 101 without ever having to go to college, all presented in plain, easy to understand English without being bogged down with philosophy's often confusing vernacular.


The Yoga-Sutra of Patanjali: A New Translation and Commentary
Published in Paperback by Inner Traditions Intl Ltd (1990)
Authors: Georg Feuerstein and Pataanjali
Amazon base price: $10.47
List price: $14.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $8.69
Collectible price: $10.59
Buy one from zShops for: $9.95
Average review score:

Not worth the time
Criticizing other's interpretations of the sutra is not the way to expound your own understanding (or lack of it) of this classic yoga text. Yoga is a practical science, not an academic exposition of your point of view. If you want to gain a working, practical understanding of the sutra to deepen your own personal practice, try a translation by one of the Indian interpreters such as I.K. Taimni.

can't say good or bad, depends on your interest, who you are
what's so opaque about the aphorisms that writers start to pre-interpret them for you, invariably tinted with their own precepts and ideas? It's a little like somebody chewing your food for you. The aphorisms are not that opaque and its an enjoyable and useful excercise to read them in their simple, bare and clear form, until the understanding comes - your own realizations rather then someone elses. You could read a book like this over the weekend, but I'm not sure it's supposed to be read like that. It seems better you should do the mental work yourself, aphorism by aphorism. There is an effect to this, which could be lost if it's all been solved and explained for you. Therefore I prefer authors that appeared to be going to great lengths to avoid adding too much of their own coloring, like William Q. Judge's interpretation from 1914. That is regrettably only available from Kessinger in bound photocopy format. I wish somebody would make a decent new print of it.

Anyways, Patanjali's aphorisms are worth the time in any form and I shall thank any author who spent his time to bring them to more of us, different introductions will appeal to different people.

Among the best - still missing somethings
I have looked at atleast 8 translations of Patanjali. Dr. Feurstein's is among the best. Particularly appealing is his defining Sanskrit roots, however, I wish he would have had the text in Sanskrit as well as transliteration. At times he gets overly pedantic and I believe misses the meaning of the sutra. It is the problem with all the available translations. Some of his translations don't make sense. Once again a common problem. At times he comes forth with very astute observations. It is not easy to get to Kaivalya from here.


Related Subjects: Author Index Reviews Page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

Reviews are from readers at Amazon.com. To add a review, follow the Amazon buy link above.