Used price: $19.99
Buy one from zShops for: $18.85
Collectible price: $28.92
I have audiotapes for learning Cantonese from 4 different "systems". The audiotapes with this textbook are the best by far. The actual methodology for teaching Cantonese is fairly clear. Cantonese is a tonal language with as many as 7 "tones" for a given syllable. This text is the only one of the four which gives a clear explination of the varous tones.
There are several different "printings" of this book. Be warned that the spiral bound volume 1 looks like a photocopy, and may be harder to read than the smaller sized paperback. The spiral bound version is also priced higher than the paperback version. I rate this textbook as a 3 out of 5 as the print job is horrible (for ALL the versions I have seen.) The text has been used for many years and is considered to be one of the best to learn Cantonese - so don't judge this book by my review.
Two negatives: First, the book should be sold with tapes. There are other courses on the market which have audio support, so if you also have one of these, you can learn Cantonese pronunciation from them while using this course. "Colloquial Cantonese" (from Routledge) is a particularly good fit because it uses basically the same system of transcription found in "Cantonese Basic Course". Otherwise, the help of a native speaker will be needed, and from my own experience, many native speakers will be baffled by the transcription (which was originally developed at Yale). Second, the original State Department Course from which this was taken had thirty lessons, but this edition includes only the first fifteen. I would certainly give this book more stars if it contained the full course of thirty lessons.
Used price: $14.95
Used price: $4.60
Collectible price: $10.00
Used price: $9.50
Collectible price: $11.53
Buy one from zShops for: $21.90
Used price: $3.50
Buy one from zShops for: $6.70
The only other gap I will point to in the story is the absense of the other characters toward the end of the book. I think Lowell could have done a better job of developing some of the other adult characters and making them a part of the story. What about Jan? She is such a great person but she does not have a line past the first chapter. And Dane. Give us some of the conversation between he and his brother at the end. Okay, one more gap... how does Chase know how to drum for Tahitian dance? I thought he was from Hawaii but later it seems he is not. Oh well. It is not a mystery novel, it is a romance. Boy gets girl - boy loses girl - boy gets girl back. I just wish Lowell had ended the book with Nicole's clothes on. Nicole said she did not want to be a man's "thing" yet in the last scene she is naked in the lap of a fully clothed man. Duh?
Used price: $8.40
Used price: $11.98
Buy one from zShops for: $11.95
Used price: $12.71
Collectible price: $19.06
Buy one from zShops for: $12.75
On the positive side the guide explains things in detail (a little too much detail if you know what I mean *plot spoilers*).
Sure, its nice that Prima gets down to business and doesn't joke around but because they get down to business they miss points in the game that could be important.
The guide has a good walkthrough and the maps are pretty good if you could deal with the soliton radar. Boss strategies aren't as in-depth as VERSUS BOOKS and they don't tell you everthing you can do.
Also, the guide is full of plot spoilers. You thought BradyGAMES was bad? Try this! They spoil the ending! After going through the game the ending is what we strive for! And if they spoil it I don't know about you but it kinda takes the fun out of the ending.
OVERALL:
Positive
+Map are good
+Gets down to business
Negative
-Spoils plot
-spoils endings
-not many secrets
-not quite as in depth as most other guides