List price: $15.00 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $10.42
Collectible price: $19.58
Buy one from zShops for: $10.42
Used price: $2.25
Buy one from zShops for: $3.95
Used price: $7.92
Collectible price: $20.12
List price: $12.95 (that's 20% off!)
Used price: $2.50
Buy one from zShops for: $3.99
List price: $11.95 (that's 20% off!)
Used price: $4.00
Collectible price: $11.95
Buy one from zShops for: $6.00
List price: $16.15 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $12.25
Buy one from zShops for: $12.25
First, a lop-sided opinion of the soldiers involved. Specifically Paul Howe's assessment of the Ranger's abilities. The prevading theme I got was the Rangers were lucky to be alive, much less able to accomplish the mission. It seemed that parts of the book became a platform to bash the Rangers.
Second, I think he (Bowden) slighted the efforts of the 10th Mountain Division QRF Relief Column. 2-14 Infantry did an OUTSTANDING job getting a multi-national relief column moving on such short notice. Again, the tone of the book suggests that 2-14 Infantry were a bunch of stooges not worthy of such operations.
Due to the budget cuts, every combat arms unit in the Army is an 'elite' unit. What I mean is we don't have excess resources; therefore every unit has a specific task to perform without any overhead. The National leadership made a bad call by not allowing armor into Somalia; instead the UNOSOM forces got a Light Infantry Batallion with a good commander at its helm.
I served in Somalia for 9 months with an Army Special Forces unit attached to UNOSOM; so if I'm arm-chair quarterbacking, it's from the front edge of the chair.
Writes Bowden, "(Somolia) stands as an enduring symbol of Third World ingratitude and intractability, of the futility of trying to resolve local animosity with international muscle." One can't help but think of later events such as the growth and proliferation of terror networks unafraid to confront the US, which of course led to 9-11 and the war in Afganistan. This book is an absolute watershed in that it is already studied at all the major war colleges, service academies, and Security agencies as THE definitive study of the battle that set the stage for American miltiary strategy in the early 21st century.
The book provides the reader a chilling view of battle as it reports sequences of scenes through the eyes of those who fought it. In a description of a medic's efforts to save a young Ranger, Bowden writes:
"Give me some morphine for the pain! Smith demanded.... I can't, Schmid told him. In his state, morphine could kill him.... The young Ranger bellowed as the medic reached with both hands and tore open the entrance wound. Schmid tried to shut out the fact that there were live nerve endings beneath his fingers.... He continued to root for the artery. Every time he reached into the wound Smith lost more blood. Schmid and Perino were covered with it. Blood was everywhere. It was hard to believe Smith had anymore to lose....
"We need medevac NOW. We have [ ] critical who is not going to make it....
"Roger, understand. We are pressing the QRF to get there as quickly as they can. I doubt that we can get a Hawk in there to get anybody out, over....
"We are going to have to hold on the best we can with those casualties and hope the ground reaction force gets there on time."
By interviewing the soldiers for their recollection of the events and juxtaposing it with transcriptions of radio tapes of the desperate calls for help, Bowden succeeds in conveying the sense of the horror of war in a manner that is more unsettling than most authors are able to do in their fictional or non-fictional books about war. In that regard, Black Hawk Down is similar to "We Were Soldiers Once...and Young," a book about infantry combat in Ia Drang, Vietnam, written by Lt. Gen. Harold G. Moore (Ret.) and Joseph L. Galloway (Random House, 1992).
Bowden provides such an in-depth account of the battle and so vividly relates the memories and opinions of the soldiers that it's hard to believe that he, himself, was not at the battle. The author's skill in piecing together important sequences of events, his addition of ordinary details (for example, the soldier who wished he had made a restroom stop before the mission) and his description of the surrealism experienced by the soldiers ("this cannot be real!") give the reader a sense of the realism of war. This is an impressive achievement given Bowden's lack of any military background.
One criticism I have of the book is the author's failure to follow up on President Clinton's abrupt cancellation of the mission within days of the battle. While Bowden briefly touches on this issue in the Epilogue, he could have elaborated on this stage of events by addressing the soldiers' feelings and opinions concerning this issue. There must have been a tremendous sense of frustration and a sense of "all this for nothing" for those who fought in the mission. Perhaps there was no easy way to address this issue given that the soldiers were still active members of the military and their comments would have been too circumscribed.
Another criticism I have of the book is the author's reluctance to address the wisdom of the policymakers who authorized the mission. To the extent he addresses it, he, personally, does not appear to find as much fault as one would think his book warrants. He acknowledges, however, that the rest of the country may be of a different view, especially with respect to the President's role. Bowden reported:
"At the Medal of Honor ceremony for the two Delta soldiers killed in action, [the author] read that the father of posthumous honoree Sergeant Randy Shughart insulted the president, telling him he was not fit to be Commander-in-Chief."
Despite these minor shortcomings, I found the book to be a raw, gut-wrenching account that vividly captures the ferociousness of urban warfare. Black Hawk Down is written like an action novel; it's gripping and very easy to read.
The Battle of the Black Sea was the worst firefight since Vietnam, and is a battle that America has preferred to forget. But, so long as America engages in police action missions and OOTW, we must not forget October 13. In an article in the New York Times (11/2/01), Somalia's president pleaded for America to re-establish relations with his country. He urged American officials to end the cold shoulder treatment "and to realize that Somalia, although not perfect, could be much worse." I would highly recommend that everyone reads Black Hawk Down before America allows its leaders to re-engage with Somalia or to expand its peacekeeping role in places like Bosnia. After reading Black Hawk Down, this reviewer has an indelible image of young Americans going to a distant country to feed starving stangers and returning home in body bags.
List price: $11.95 (that's 20% off!)
Used price: $7.36
Collectible price: $9.99
Buy one from zShops for: $6.95
List price: $22.65 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $15.74
Buy one from zShops for: $15.74
Anne Franks Diary is a remarkable book. Written by a young girl in a time of trouble and terror, she writes what she feels, and what is happening around her, in first person. Anne Franks Diary, is an autobiography of her short life. This book takes readers back to the time of power, greed and expresses what life was like. Also known as the Great Depression.
This book is what the world lived through and how this war impacted human beings, of all sorts. I enjoyed this book because of the high intensity of how this young girl felt. She suffered day on end to survive, with family and friends holding on with her.
" Leave me in peace, let me sleep one night at least without my pillow being wet with my tears, my eyes burning and my head throbbing. Let me get away from it all, preferably away from the world." This quote explains the suffering Anne Frank went threw to survive in this hard time.
The reason why I liked this book is because of the honest opinions honest thoughts and feelings. For people that enjoy historical events and the detail be hide them you will enjoy this book like me. The quotes that really come from the inner sprit of Anne Frank, can get to you, with a few powerful feelings, and words. "A voice sobs within me: There you are, That's what's become of you: you're uncharitable, you look
supercilious and peevish, people dislike you and all because you won't listen to the advice given to you by your own better half." I personally like this quote because it explains how Anne changes she becomes more grown up and more marcher.
I found that I really endured this book because of the reality to her life and thoughts. I also found that the sad times or the touching moments really are what put the book together.
Some other quotes that make this book what it is, are these, "I hope I shall be able to confide in you completely, as I have never been able to do before, and I hope that you will be a great support and comfort to me." "I started by being snappy, than unhappy, and finally I twist my heart round again, so that the bad is on the outside and the good is on the inside and keep on trying to find a way of becoming what I would so like to be, and what I could be, If ...... there weren't any other people living in the world."
I think you should read the book, Anne Frank: the Diary of a Young Girl. Enjoy reading.
The usual view of this book is that it's about WW II and how evil Nazis are. Some crazy neo-Nazi revisionists have even attacked the book and questioned its authenticity.
I think most people are missing the boat. Nazis hardly appear at all in the story. The diary is mostly about the relationships amoungst the unfortunate people hiding out with Anne. Most of Anne's fellow hideaways come off looking pretty bad; she naturally discusses (and criticizes) the people she's cooped up with much more than she mentions Nazis, whom she basically never sees.
The Diary of a Young Girl is a good book, but it's not a war story--it's a book about relationships and growing of age.
Used price: $2.20
Collectible price: $6.00
The film adaptation of the book is interesting. It is very low budget but I think that is what adds to the films charm. The film is the opposite of a slick hollywood production. Instead the film is very down to earth and wonderful.
Salzman changes some names around and adds a bit more of the romance aspect. The girl was a small part at the end of the book but a major part of the film.
Bottom line is that like the book, the film is a great glimpse at China, Chinese culture, and the differences between the US and China.
My best suggestion is this: read the book and then watch the film. If you do both you will come out ahead and knowing a lot more about China.
Used price: $10.79
Buy one from zShops for: $3.99
The characters are all people you find during your own lifetime: your friends, your aunt, your sweetheart, that woman you love but you can't stand, etc. Copperfield is the story of a good man in his learning through difficulties and setbacks.
No wonder it is still read and probably will stay alive through the decades: Copperfield has something to tell us all.
"David Copperfield" as his "greatest" novel. The strains of autobiography and the rich array of comic and tragicomic characters give the reader the best of Dickens' wit and social outrage. As the years go by, though, people begin to speak of David Copperfield as a "set piece", a bit of Victoriana different in format but not in importance from a very natty
but a bit days-gone-by bit of antique furniture. This view misjudges the novel. This book presents a rich set of characters in a complex novel, deeply satisfying and in many ways still a very modern work. It's very hard to write about "good" and "evil" without descending into morality play, but this novel succeeds. The story is broken into three
"threads": a young boy, orphaned early, endures an unhappy childhood refreshed by periods of happiness (and comedy);
that same boy goes through late adolescence, and comes "into his own"; and finally, the narrator, now a man, sees the resolution of the various plot threads built through the early parts of the novel. Many Dickens themes are played out here--the superiority of goodness to affluence, the persistence and affrontery of fraud, and the way in which social institutions frequently hinder rather than advance their stated goals. The book does not read like a polemic, though--it reads like a bit of serial fiction (which in fact it was).
If you are hunting a good, solid read about values and
curious characters, David Copperfield stands ready to show you his world.