Used price: $24.95
Buy one from zShops for: $24.95
Used price: $46.95
Buy one from zShops for: $53.00
Used price: $1.93
For broad historical research purposes, the price of the book may be worthwhile. For someone doing genealogical reseach looking for a single person, the price may be a bit high as you may be able to get the individual listing from other sources.
List price: $34.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $2.86
Collectible price: $10.59
Buy one from zShops for: $2.95
The ultimate accolade is when one's enemy admits to your greatness. In this "Georgie" was fortuanete. The German Army High Command thought him dangerous, Stalin was impressed, Eisenhower and Marshall repeatedly "saved" him for greater things, but Professor Hirshon is not impressed.
Prior to D-Day, his presence in pretended planning tied up German divisions that could have been used in D-Day. His breakout and pursuit post D-Day was beyond compare. Turning the Third Army around and getting onto the offensive during the Battle of the Bulge even today is considered the ultimate in handling and Army at War. But that doesn't cut ice with Professor Hirshon either.
One presumes that the decision to install his statue at west Point was made by a committee of morons.
We are indeed luck that Patton's nanny and her closest blood relations to whom some form of oral history could have been passed on are long dead or not accessible to Professor Hirshon, or else he might have raked up something about how Patton didn't eat his food when he was three or maybe wet his bed.
Whether Professor Hirshon likes it or not, George Smith Patton Jr., General, USA was and will remain a military icon, one of the best combat generals that the world has ever seen. A master in exploiting and executing the expanding torrent theory.
The only reason this bok gets one star is because of it's subject. PATTON
Another disturbing part of the book is Hirshson's claim that Patton's war speeches were responsible for American atrocities. This is just inane. Any serious reader of Patton's own works understands that Patton more than anyone else realized the difficulty of converting democratic citizenry into fighting men against an experienced Wehrmacht. Even more disturbing is Hirshson's focus on Patton's anti-Semitic views. While his views were deplorable and unjustifiable, they're hardly unrepresentative of his social peers (namely top American military generals). Considerable amount of this focus is present in his concluding chapter without really connecting how his views impacted his military conduct. He attempts to connect this to Patton's military governorship of Bavaria, but most Patton biographers and military historians would agree that it was Patton's political naivete and ignorance (after all, his political views were conservative to say the least) situated in a position where he was least suited.
His work sheds some new light on John Wood, a Patton friend and his first 4th Armored commander. However, in the overall Patton historiography (despite Wood's accomplishments), Wood's importance is a minor one. Overall, a disappointing work that does not come close to superceding Blumenson's annotated Patton Papers or D'Este's monumental biography. However, I do believe there are plenty of Montgomery admirers in UK who would love to scoop up this book.
Like many who are drawn to the character of Patton, I think most would give credit to the movie in which Patton was wonderfully portrayed by the late George C. Scott. I can not intelligently say whether this book uncovers any new ground-breaking information on Patton, but the book is still worth reading.
Patton believed he was destined to play some integral part in a major war. You get that sense from the book and the movie. It is hard to comprehend that someone could actually wish for war, but Patton probably more than anyone fits this description.
Reading from letters written by Patton are all very informative as they would be about any figure in history. I especially was interested in what he thought of other generals. I knew he had some disdain for Gen. Montgomery, but he apparently was not too impressed with Eisenhower either. He even considered Gen. Bradley of the higher caliber of mediocrity.
While this book likes to deal with Patton's faults and controversies, as any good book should, even Hirshson admits Patton was probably the greatest tactician of the allied commanders.
Patton was clearly not a beloved general like a Washington or a Lee, but he was feared and respected. Patton had attributes that are worthy of rebuke, but he knew how to fight and strike fear into the hearts of the enemy.
Used price: $160.58
Collectible price: $138.71
Used price: $64.82
Buy one from zShops for: $58.00