List price: $12.95 (that's 20% off!)
This book is a beautiful way to learn about the Navajo culture. The retelling of traditional legends are such an important part of preserving any culture, and this series has made us all participants in a wider American culture. I would recommend the whole series as well as the books from the "Legends of the World" series.
List price: $28.00 (that's 75% off!)
In 1997, Wilkinson suggested that legal recourse would be sought for Boyden's "devious conduct" against the Hopi, but seven years later, Wilkinson's claims have not been substantiated at any significant level. Why is this? I was very unimpressed to learn that after writing with such conviction and certainty, Wilkinson's "shocking revelation" about Boyden's "misconduct" as a focal point of the novel is and will most likely remain a hollow witch-hunt. I would not recommend that anyone read this novel because of it's poorly executed investigation of John Boyden's service to the Hopi Indian Tribe.
Critics on this site claim that it never happened; that is, Mormon attorney John Boyden never created a conflict of interest by represented Peabody Coal Company and Native America concurrently. (Read: "a Mormon simply wouldn't do it"). Mormons might think themselves irreproachable but greed and the need for glory know no boundaries. The veracity of Boyden's conflict of interest is archived at the University of Utah Marriott Library Special Collections. Anyone can read Boyden's own documents and come to their own conclusion. I have.
Conflict with Peabody or not, the critics have not disputed and cannot dispute the fact that Boyden represented both Hopi and Navajo horrendously over decades, advising them to accept legislation, water and mineral contracts that favored Anglo government and industry -- not the Indian or his land. (I use both "Native American" and "Indian" because some of my Native acquaintances prefer "Indian.") The contracts were so obviously bad and so far below market rate, they were successfully renegotiated many years later.
Wilkinson does a great job of explaining the cultural roots of both Mormons and Native Americans on the plateau that led to such travesties. The ultimate tragedy is that the Hopi and Navajo will never get back any of the plateau land that defines -- or rather defined them culturally.
Wilkinson's extensive historical background and personal narratives makes for a powerful combination that is critical to understanding the conflict that has dominated the Plateau. Issues such as greed, ignorance and long drawn out legal battles prove to the reader that this 'wasteland' is being pulled at from all sides by all types of corporations. Especially good are Wilkinson's discussions of the Mormon influence on the region, and the dubious dealings of John Boyden, a questionable lawyer who is said to have gone behind the backs of the Hopi people to benefit himself financially.
Fire on the Plateau is a book that needed to be written. Misdeeds, betrayal and environmental chaos are all subjects that have been brought up and dealt with on the Colorado Plateau. These are issues that no human should have to deal with, no matter if the people are "just Indians" or not. The book addresses not only the people of the Four Corners area, but anyone who lives, or has lived, in the Southwest. The facts cannot be ignored and doing so only eludes one from the truth of what has happened, and what will continue to happen in the Southwest if people such as Charles Wilkinson do not speak up for the land.
Wilkinson is a rare mix of a writer who demonstrates an expansive knowledge of the subject matter and who also exhibits a fiery passion for his subject. A major strength of the book was the audacity that Wilkinson possessed as he crusaded for justice, peace and equality for the Native American people. Although Wilkinson can play hardball with the toughest lawyers in the West he portrays a man who is very down to earth and appreciates the beauty of the land.
Overall, I would be lying if I said the book did not captivate my attention. I have lived in the Southwest all of my twenty-two years and did not know injustices such as these were going on right under my nose. Wilkinson has enlightened me and woken me from what I thought was a peaceful and undisturbed land. Fire on the Plateau has kept me up well throughout the night and as I turned each page of the book, I was just as engrossed as the last page. Wilkinson does a fantastic job creating such an informative narrative and to say the least, I was not disappointed.
Charles Dodgson's Oxford writings are full of items that the average person, having not been to Oxford in the 1800's, might despair to understand, if it were not for the helpful explanations supplied by the editors of this collection. These explanations make these writings accessable, allowing us to explore a microcosm of collegiate life. Dodgson expresses massive displeasure with the architectural and staff changes going on at the college, often with satire so biting that you wonder how many friends he must have lost with these little publications.
There are also a couple more serious papers about doings at the college, followed by a tremendous amount of circulars about the common room at the college, which Dodgson was curator of. These circulars are very dry, sometimes amounting to no more than lists of wines in the cellars. These papers take up almost half the book, and present a problem: Surely every Lewis Carroll fan wants a complete collection of his writings, but is this simply too much? However, if they weren't included, the readers would be left wondering if there was anything worthwhile in these papers, and the answer is that yes, about 5% of these papers are worth reading.
Once again, this book is for the truly hard-core Carroll nut. If you enjoyed all the writings in, say, the Modern Library "Works of" Lewis Carroll, then you might enjoy this. But it is not for casual fans, especially at the gold-plated price of [money].