Buy one from zShops for: $15.00
Larry Niven's take on Green Lantern's mythos is really astounding, and it fits well for me, being a Green Lanter fan too. John Byrne's dialogues and layouts are really good, and his art is at his normal level. Byrne's not an astounding penciller, but he manages to get the work done, and by writing and drawing most of his work. he gets a cohesion that no writer-artist team can get.
The only setback to this story for me is that it's to compressed, I feel they should have dedicated a full 10 issues mini-series or something like that. It's a bit crammed in the prestige edition book.
Used price: $32.48
Used price: $9.99
Buy one from zShops for: $33.97
List price: $14.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $10.39
Buy one from zShops for: $9.85
Used price: $5.67
Collectible price: $4.50
Buy one from zShops for: $6.90
Yes, the art is flashy and large, but there is no story and very little dialogue. There are more one- and two-page panels than you can count with both hands -- fifteen panels. Large art and no dialogue steal from story space. When there is dialogue, Byrne resorts to a small portrait of the speaker's head, and the art becomes boring. It's as if Byrne thinks story development through words is boring. Not all comic book readers think this way. There is simply not a healthy balance between art and story as I believe there should be in a comic book.
Development of supporting characters is lackluster, as well. Helena Sandsmark (mother of Cassie, the new Wonder Girl) never truly behaves like a mother. When Cassie spontaneously rushes off to help Wonder Woman in battle, the only thing Helena can do is shout for her to return. She doesn't attempt to follow. She seems more concerned with the wounded man by her side. Cassie, herself, is quite annoying. Mike Schorr? Have no clue who he is, although the book states that he is a character of some import.
This is not the way that Wonder Woman was meant to be written. John Byrne's interpretation of her is at worst THE worst interpretation of Diana. The interpretation is at best confused (I don't think he knows how to write about a heroine, or any female for that matter).
So, in my opinion, buy this book only if you are a die-hard Wonder Woman fan. If the comics are missing from your collection, don't worry. You're not missing much.
Used price: $5.00
Collectible price: $9.95
Buy one from zShops for: $6.92
I won't even get into how he later screwed up the whole Donna Troy history. Maybe he can do Hawkman next. At least that character is so screwed up with so many revisions that Byrne can't possibly do it any more harm!
Used price: $12.00
Halfway through my full year course I am searching for more options as this book fails to help me in those desperate moments when lecture notes just don't seem to make sense. This book goes into lengthy detail with mediocre summaries, such that the reader gets lost in details (and the neverending sentences) long before any understanding of the topic occurs. The lack of diagrams leaves no other option other than finding another source.
Any students out there?? Find another book! Any GOOD text will get you through, with all the essential information you need for both personal interest and for exams.
Buy one from zShops for: $10.85