Used price: $11.00
List price: $13.00 (that's 20% off!)
Used price: $1.85
Collectible price: $7.41
Buy one from zShops for: $3.99
But, setting aside the lack of historical credibility, the book never evokes the feelings of the war or its human impact in a way that Charles Frazier did (I only bring up the comparision b/c of the quote on the paper edition). Bill, our main man here, never develops as a character- he just sort of lurches from phase to phase.
I wouldn't bother with this book- there are so many other novels of the Civil War worth your time.
Used price: $29.95
Buy one from zShops for: $29.95
List price: $18.00 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $2.97
Buy one from zShops for: $8.59
but it's fantastic anyway blake is not The Lamb and not The Tyger
tirzah los orc urizen enitharmon vala rahab urthona, all divided and united in the cruelties of holiness...jerusalem the four zoas the book of urizen the song of los...echoing our cries.
Blake is the poet of true revolution, true Romanticism and true spirit. This is the definitive volume of his life-work, without, it is true, the illustrations that augmented his genius. Yet there is no real necessity for etchings here, as the genius of his poetry will etch its own image in your mind if you are receptive to his universal symbolism. Blake was the first truly modern poet, prefiguring Mallarme, D.H. Lawrence, Baudelaire, in particular. He was also a great mythologyzer, the precursor of Campbell, Frazier, and even Alan Watts in many respects. The Penguin Edition is not illustrated, it's true, but there is so much to be mined here that one can easily lose oneself in the labyrinth of Blake's excavations.
Used price: $3.94
This book, BLAKE AND SWEDENBORG/ OPPOSITION IS TRUE FRIENDSHIP, edited by Harvey F. Bellin and Darrell Ruhl, is a collection. Many of the articles and lectures are short. Most compare the writings of William Blake with the doctrines of Emanuel Swedenborg. Many of the people mentioned in the book were known to Blake, either at the formation of a church in 1789 in London, where Blake spent most of his life, or later, and where, much earlier, Swedenborg's books were printed due to religious restrictions imposed by the government of Sweden. Prior to reaching the age of 50, Swedenborg had been accepted as a leading member of society, who co-edited Sweden's first scientific journal in 1716, but his religious books were published anonymously. It should be noted that both Blake and Swedenborg "Self-published" (p. 6) the books for which they are known today, without commercial recognition in their own time, and that each saw instances in which society condemned people for believing more than was fashionable or proper. Much of this book is devoted to the doctrine of predestination, or however God might determine who could be considered saved, one way or another, society then being less inclined to take a comic view concerning that theological question than we are currently used to.
There are two engravings by Blake in color on the cover of BLAKE AND SWEDENBORG. The illustrations scattered throughout the remainder of the book are in black and white. On page 42 is a stark "Anatomical reference from Swedenborg's THE CEREBRUM," possibly one of the volumes referred to in the text: "In 1743-44, Swedenborg compiled a staggering four-volume treatise, THE BRAIN. In it, he was the first to discover the functions of the cerebellum, pituitary gland and spinal fluid, the localization of thinking and memory in the cerebral cortex, and the integrative action of the nervous system." (p. 42). It was then that "a new muse began to emerge, sending seismic shock waves to the very core of this objective man of the Age of Reason. The process started with a series of disturbing dreams, which he carefully recorded in a private journal." (p. 42).
The early short sections of BLAKE AND SWEDENBORG offer a lot of comparisons, with Swedenborg much more familiar "with leading scientists and scholars in Sweden, England, Holland, France, Germany, Italy, and Bohemia" than Blake, who was apprenticed to an engraver after studying at Pars School of Drawing (1767-1772), but was then a "student at Royal Academy Schools (1779)." (p. 5). The discoveries of Blake were of states of mind, now considered "mythology, personifying aspects of consciousness" or in the area of printing. Blake also "Discovered an acid-etching process for creating relief-type, copper printing plates." (p. 6).
My high opinion of Blake is due to MILTON : A POEM, BLAKE'S ILLUMINATED BOOKS : VOLUME 5, whose hero is famous for the great poem, "Paradise Lost," describing Satan more fully than most people know themselves. MILTON is mentioned occasionally in BLAKE AND SWEDENBORG, and, most importantly, for mentioning Swedenborg on pages 16, 29 and 153, where MILTON A POEM is quoted:
O Swedenborg! strongest of men, the Samson
shorn by the Churches,
Shewing the Transgressors in Hell, the proud
Warriors in Heaven,
Heaven as a punisher, & Hell as One under Punishment.
The cosmic scheme in which Blake seems to be describing the spirit world he might have adopted from Swedenborg seems most complete in "Opposition Is True Friendship" (1985) by Harvey F. Bellin, which spends pages 39-43 on Swedenborg's life and pages 43-48 on ` "A Theatre Representative of the Lord's Kingdom" Swedenborg's Theology.' "The Swedenborgian Songs" (1968) by Kathleen Raine discusses the themes of Blake's SONGS OF INNOCENCE AND OF EXPERIENCE, with attention to the poem "For Mercy, Pity, Peace and Love" which I found mentioned on pages 78, 88 (in "The Human Face of God" (1985) by Kathleen Raine), 111 (in "New Light on C. A. Tulk" by Raymond H. Deck, Jr.), 149 (in "Blake and Swedenborg" (undated, from THE NEW CHURCH HERALD XXX, London) by H.N. Morris). The Contents are divided into "Analyses of Blake's Connections to Swedenborg," "Historical Contexts," and "Swedenborgian Postscripts," but much of the material seems to be covered from the same point of view. For excitement, reading Blake alone might be better, but this view offers a deeper understanding, and the opposition which Blake expressed in his satire of Swedenborg, THE MARRIAGE OF HEAVEN AND HELL, (c. 1790-93) might free some people from doctrines which seemed necessary, or previously conformed to their idea of sanity.
Used price: $36.75
Buy one from zShops for: $26.95
Used price: $49.95
Buy one from zShops for: $100.00
List price: $12.50 (that's 20% off!)
Used price: $4.42
Collectible price: $151.41
Buy one from zShops for: $8.30
I found the writing format, the telling through other's eyes, less engaging and certainly less tasty than Blake's current style.
List price: $26.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $9.95
Collectible price: $21.95
Buy one from zShops for: $18.68
"beneath this `reptile of the mind,' partially obscured by Blake's thick patina of watercolor pigments in several copies of this hand-painted book, is Blake's final comment on his battle with Swedenborg's angelic alter ego:
Opposition is true Friendship." (Harvey F. Bellin, BLAKE AND SWEDENBORG, p. 38).
The detail which is shown on page 38 of BLAKE AND SWEDENBORG looks more like "Opposition is True !"
Page 117 of Erdman's THE ILLUMINATED BLAKE has a copy of Plate 20, copy I, which hardly even shows the T of True, and a small detail from Copy E with the words "you whose works" just before the last line "are only Analytics," so the little extra squiggle that it provides might be a subliminal comment by Blake on those who think we have the power to explain anything. The drawing of the serpent is ambiguous enough that Erdman's comment, "In I the artist has carelessly colored the angular wave seen through the first loop as though it were part of the serpent's body," (p. 117) might be an indication that Blake intended to show a bit of the tail of the serpent close to the serpent's head, symbolic of logic biting its own tail, or arguments which are circular in nature. As a wave, it looks more like the serpent than the other waves, though the black and white illustrations in both books are not entirely clear, Erdman's book has better shades of gray.
Comparing plates of "The Divine Image," SONGS 18g on page 59 in Erdman's book, with the copy on page 88 of BLAKE AND SWEDENBORG, Erdman's is clearer, but page 88 of BLAKE AND SWEDENBORG also prints the words ("To Mercy, Pity, Peace and Love") alongside the illustration, so it is easier to read. Erdman's attempts to explain the figures make this plate more interesting, mentioning Lazarus? Adam? Eve? and Jacob's ladder.
There is a "Holy Thursday" from Innocence, SONGS 19I on page 60, and a "Holy Thursday" from Experience, SONGS 33I on page 75. The big disappointment is that "The Tyger," SONGS 42I on page 84 is so difficult to read. I thought that I might remember that poem, but hardly well enough to read it in this book.