Used price: $2.05
Collectible price: $9.95
Buy one from zShops for: $14.50
In terms of evaluating the persuasiveness of the book, I should say that although in the beginning of the book, she raises the question about to what extent the information that Indians confessed under torture was exaggerated or true at all, toward the end of the book she seems to have accepted the assumption that there was at least some truth in the confessions - that human sacrifice and crucifixions did happen, and were not just a product of Landa's imagination, as she had previously suggested. So she never really proves that human sacrifice and crucifixions did happen, but kind of explores the possibilities of "what if they did" and "what if they didn't." Also, in the epilogue, the author makes a quick conclusion that the events of 1562 were significant because it was only after these events that the Maya finally accepted Christianity, or some Mayan version of it. It does make sense that the events of 1562 and the general intrusion of friars into the Maya spiritual domain would demonstrate to the natives that Spanish presence would not be temporary, that the Spanish were there to stay, and must be taken seriously. But this is in the political realm. As for the spiritual realm, it is unclear why the violence, the sufferings inflicted by the friars, and the destruction of Mayan idols would result in the Maya acceptance that "the time of the old Gods was over", and that Christian deities and the Christian God would now rule. The events of 1562 do not demonstrate the superiority of the Christian faith relative to the Mayan beliefs. Why didn't the violence the friars inflict on the natives make the natives reject Christianity and to revolt against the Spaniards, instead of accepting the Christian faith?
This raises the further question of why some populations abandon their religion and accept the faith of the group that conquers them (after all, this is not the only time this scenario came up - Islam spread with the Muslim conquests, for example), while other populations or groups hold on to their own religions and religious practices for very long periods of time while living in exile (Jews in Christian and Muslim countries for example). What factors does the likelihood of accepting the religion of the dominant group depend on - on n the political coercion and missionary offensive of the conqueror, or perhaps on the ability of conquered peoples to resist this offensive by shielding behind the strength of their own religious beliefs and practices? What influences what form the acceptance of the religion of the dominant group take - absorption of new religion into the old religion, absorption of old religion into the new religion, or perhaps complete abandonment of former religious beliefs and practices in favor of the new ones. How unique is the Maya case? Or perhaps the acceptance of the new faith isn't something that abruptly takes place at conversion, but a lengthy, gradual process that takes generations, whereupon the old faith gradually fades away? If so, do elements from the pre-conquest period still survive in the religion of the Yucatan Maya? All these questions deal with the larger implications of Clendinnen's book: implications for the understanding of the domination of the conqueror (both military and religious) and the resistance of the conquered peoples, not only in Yucatan, but throughout the world. Do true conquests happen, or are all conquests to some extent ambivalent?
List price: $26.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $18.82
Buy one from zShops for: $17.77
I highly recommend it -- forms change all the time, it is always important to check copyright dates on any book when using the forms. Plus check on-line resources to make sure the forms are accurate.
The information and advice in this book is far superor than any of the other titles in the catagory.
Plus, the review was posted in 1999. The new edition of this book came out in 2001.
This is an excellent book and if used right can save a lot of money.
List price: $75.00 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $49.00
Buy one from zShops for: $44.50
List price: $24.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $13.99
Buy one from zShops for: $17.34
In discussing the transformation of the Western God-image, Edinger implies that "animism"--experiencing the divinity of nature--is a less advanced psychological stage than realizing that a God-image organizes the psyche. The animism argument is an outdated one and has been pummeled both by ecopsychology and by the aboriginal feeling for the sacredness of place. Edinger was an excellent Jungian analyst, but he was obviously no ecologist. Nor do his descriptions of traditional spirituality as less developed than, say, individuative methods do him or Jung much credit. Why do Jungians so often forget that Jung was a theist?
Given this, his dream (p. 74) is informative: finding himself in an alien-feeling world, he sees that the people listening to him are afraid of catching an infection from him--upon which he dances a jig, no longer afraid of them, and says, "Jumping Jehosephat"--an able description of the missionary enthusiasm with which a former Jehovah's (Jehosephat) Witness goes about acting his part in a kind of exteriorized play in which the world's a dangerous stage of "conflict and intrigue."
A plus is that this book is free of all the alchemical, etc. imagery originally reproduced to good expository purpose by Jung but wearyingly repeated by so many of his followers in their explanations of his thought; even the mandatory photo of Jung is absent. Another plus is that the selections from Jung's letters were well thought out and provide fascinating insights to readers who haven't read what's been published and translated so far of Jung's voluminous correspondence.
Used price: $3.95
The preliminary chapter (Chapter 0) is most valuable as it provides a concise overview of FORTRAN 66 in about 40 pages. Later chapters instruct on some of the long forgotten FORTRAN 66 tricks that sometimes cause the eyebrows of modern programmers to furrow when trying to understand inherited code. I also found this book to be very helpful in understanding the use of characters variables in FORTRAN 66, which may be foreign to the FORTRAN 77/90+ programmer use to explicitly declared characters variables. I regret that the book did not acknowledge some of the antiquated non-standard features such as ENCODE and DECODE commonly seen in old source code.
Understandably, the actual presentation of FORTRAN 77 is less than complete, and the book is a self-proclaimed "advanced" book, so this is certainly not the best book from which to learn modern FORTRAN. And while there are other older books that can help one's understanding of FORTRAN 66, this hardback just also happens to be a fine tutorial on the subject on programming. Apparently, this title was quite popular and in print for many years.
Used price: $20.00
Buy one from zShops for: $23.88
Used price: $2.50