Used price: $0.01
Collectible price: $0.99
Buy one from zShops for: $0.99
This is a highly entertaining historical novel, in which Vidal weaves Catherine and Blaise's stories into the wider themes of an emergent, radically different America, one with a world role. The technique Vidal uses is similar to those used in his earlier "American Saga" novels, but what fascinates Vidal is the change in the nature of politics and the rise of what would now be termed media moguls, such as WR Hearst. A conflict seemed to be going on for control of domestic politics and politicians, in which the old systems of patronage were being challenged by the influence of big industry, both of which were in turn challenged by those in control of the mass media (and who could therefore "shape" public opinion).
Such themes are, of course, relevant today - for example, the US has just won another war in which it would like to be seen as a liberating force rather than an imperial one. It was interesting to contrast today's debate with what Vidal saw as the post 1898 debate. More than that, however, it seemed to me that there was a deep regret throughout "Empire", in that Vidal saw the ideals upon which the early Republic had been founded as having been finally destroyed. I suppose that Vidal would question whether or not those ideals were ever anything other than aspirations, but the new world reality in which America found itself seemed to have brought with it a regrettable loss of innocence - Caroline Sanford's loss of her own virginity could perhaps be seen as a metaphor for that greater loss of innocence?
G Rodgers
Used price: $2.20
Collectible price: $12.71
Buy one from zShops for: $17.95
Anyways, Vidal could write more of this good stuff, but his grumblin' needs to get the TRUTH out prevents it. That's fine, but that just requires his reading public to savor every word, if ya ask a true fan.
Read Vidal, and then remember that being who you are is more important than succumbing to who other people try to convince you to be.
Used price: $0.75
"Messiah" is told in the first person by Eugene Luther, a key figure in the rise of the Cavite movement. This new religion is founded by John Cave, who preaches the simple message that "it is good to die." Vidal uses a very effective narrative device: Luther is an older man who alternates between narrating his current life in exile and the birth if the Cavite movement 50 years previously. Thus, the reader essentially gets two parallel stories of the same man at different stages in his life.
"Messiah" could be read as a sort of science fiction novel: one based not in the physical sciences, but rather in a flight of fancy derived from concepts from the social sciences. Vidal's novel is flawed in that the Cavite movement is not fleshed out enough to be wholly convincing. But what's here is indeed intriguing. Vidal looks at the creation of the new religion's scriptures, infighting among the new faith's inner circle, etc. He ultimately considers some big questions, such as the plasticity of history in the service of dogma. And the book is very much a reflection on religion in the United States; one character notes that "America is particularly known for religious maniacs."
I think of "Messiah" as one of a group of literary works that look at the creation of imaginary new religions. As companion texts, I recommend Kurt Vonnegut's "Cat's Cradle" and Tony Kushner's 2-part play "Angels in America."
This is a great novelization of ideas best expressed by Eric Hoffer, THE TRUE BELIEVER, who tried to account for the rise of Hitler, Stalin, and others. The catalyst for mass movements are groups who are bored and frustrated by the mechanized societies that spawn them. The character Clarissa remarks, "boredom, finally, is the one monster the race will never conquer-the monster which will devour us in time." Cave's message was to "minds corseted and constricted by familiar ways of thinking, often the opposite of what they truly believed." Vidal wasn't writing to those who thoughtlessly accept life as it is and was dished out. I consider this book great literature.
List price: $19.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $1.74
Buy one from zShops for: $1.75
However, the authors state their positions passionately and persuasively. Like one of the reviewers stated previously, if you have a conservative bent, the articles will make you really think about your position. If, on the other hand, you are more liberally inclined, these articles won't say anything that you haven't already heard.
TheNation is a magazine it is good to have discovered. I found it when some soul regularly put big piles of free issues on a table in the English building at my college. A subversive act, no? If you consider progress subversive. It was kind of strange to read at first. Who were all these people mentioned? What were these groups? But once you get in synch with the vibe, the magazine becomes truly exciting and audacious. I don't know how some of these writers became so intellectually powerful, so incisive at tearing apart the fabric of the consensus trance and revealing the bloody insides of what a DeLillo character called The Festival of Death. Which world is this? This book will help you know, with respect to whether you can be helped.
Is TheNation provincial? Some say so, but I think not. What about its coverage of Russia? Latin America? Africa? The Middle East? Asia? Europe? America is the focus, of course, but would we want it different? How can we influence lands far away if we don't yet know the secrets of our own land? Isn't the most powerful machine a good one to examine if we'd like to twist the world history vector? And if you want to get into the foreign more than the magazine itself gives you, there are lots of book recommendations to be had--books that will take you wherever you want to go, and what's more, books that will explore the world in ways you may not have even dreamed of.
No relevent aspect of reality goes unnoticed in the textuality of The Nation, the books, the readers. The perceptual net is tight--the neurotic denial of perspectives is fully minimized here. How much is going on? Can you help people? What about armchair radicals? I have nothing against sitting in chairs. I find myself reading this book, and thinking, I'm totally unable to participate in struggle for justice X, yet--in a certain way, reading about it is enough. If we can't save the victims, we can at least know of them. There is infinite Pain going on, and it's hard to influence an infinity, but any decrease in pain is meaningful. Everything is meaningful.
List price: $13.95 (that's 20% off!)
Used price: $10.58
Collectible price: $13.00
Buy one from zShops for: $10.58
List price: $15.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $9.95
Buy one from zShops for: $9.97
Katz does a fine job of skewering Foucault for "his highly abstract level of discourse, his elusive prose, and his unwillingness to clarify his meaning with sufficient concrete examples." As a historian of sexuality who is a bit tired of our late French friend, Katz's words elicited a hearty "amen" from me!
All things considered, a worthy (and brief) contribution to the field, with a daring new angle.
Used price: $34.52
For readers used to Vidal's later, witty style, you may be disappointed. There is no 'Duluth' or 'Myra' here. All of these stories were written between 1948-56, at a time when Vidal was writing a bunch of diverse novels, before finding his voice with 'The Judgement of Paris' and 'Messiah'.
Several of these stories were published in the 'New World Writing' journal of the early fifties. I believe Vidal helped establish that periodical, which is notable for publishing Chapter 1 of 'Catch-22' by Joseph Heller in 1955 (called 'Catch-18').
My favourite stories in this collection are 'Erlinda and Mr. Coffin', darkly funny and written through the voice of "a gentlewoman in middle life" & 'A Moment of Green Laurel', where a man meets himself as a boy, a la 'The Twilight Zone'. 'Laurel' is haunting and seemingly autobiographical (from a writer who calls himself "the least autobiographical of authors").
The other stories are a mixed bunch - 'Three Strategems' is an interesting but rather cold depiction of Key West in the late 40s; 'The Robin' is a very brief reminiscence; 'The Zenner Trophy' tries a little too hard to preach its agenda - that it is perfectly normal for healthy young men to want to sleep with each other - no matter how perfectly right Vidal is in his opinion; 'Notes From An Abandoned Journal'; 'Ladies in the Library'.
From the mid-1950s (when this book was first published), until the publication of 'Julian' in 1964, Vidal was unable to financially support himself from his novels (he cites the New York Times' blanket refusal to review his books after 'The City and the Pillar'). He worked in Hollywood ('Ben-Hur'), television, the theatre (two hits - 'Visit from a Small Planet' and 'The Best Man'), and wrote pulp detective fiction under the pen name Edgar Box. Surprising, then, that he didn't pen any short stories in that era for the many magazines. Our loss.
This is a great collection, and a gay classic from when homosexuality was still called "sexual inversion."
List price: $18.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $12.35
Collectible price: $25.00
I think that the world would be great if all Jews were as virtuous as Shahak is, and there would be much less antisemitism. Another good book by a Jewish author is Prof. Lindemann's Esau's Tears : Modern Anti-Semitism and the Rise of the Jews. I can also recommend the books by Kevin B. MacDonald and Michael Hoffman's Judaism's Strange Gods.
Used price: $1.95
Collectible price: $10.50
Buy one from zShops for: $19.98
Keep this in mind when you read this book and you won't put it down, I guarantee it.
Through the eyes of Schuyler, Vidal takes the reader through the political high society of the day, painting a picture of an elite, and indeed a society, so devoted to the capture of wealth that principles have been wantonly (indeed, proudly) discarded. The culmination is the corrupt election of 1876, the result of which is disputed until March 1877 (ring any bells?).
Democracy is seen not to be working for the benefit of all - Vidal paints a frightening picture of the New York underworld, replete with beggars, violence and prostitution, the latter of which the hypocritical male upper classes frequent regularly.
I think that the propective reader needs to be aware that (surprise, surprise given that this is Vidal) this is an intensely political novel. Vidal both loves and detests the US political scene, is fascinated and yet repelled by its faults and hypocrisy: Vidal seems to say that countries get the governments they deserve, and if you've got a corrupt government then a plague on the electors for being stupid enough to elect it in the first place. Vidal may, due to the fact that he's lived in Europe for so many years (even at the time of writing "1876" if I'm not mistaken), have become more European than the Europeans - read Schuyler's views on Mark Twain for example.
Although it's fiction I enjoyed "1876" as it's part of American history I am utterly ignorant of, and Vidal carries off the novel with style.
"1876" brings back character Charles Schuyler, who had previously appeared in "Burr". After a self-exile of forty years, Schuyler is back to his native country and begins to write his impressions for New York newspapers. 1876 is election year in USA. It is also the final year of the Grant 8-year administration, which is notorious for its corruption and scandals related to large amounts of money.
Schuyler describes the race for the seat in the Oval office and his struggles to earn money in a country totally defferent from the one he left behind almost half a century before.
After the ridiculous voting and election problems during the Bush-Gore dispute, the reader can see that, after 125+ years, some things (specially related to power and money) are difficult to get changed, no matter where.
"1876" is about a nebulous (at least for me) period of the US history and, as always, Vidal, with his sarcasm, good prose and refined research, delivers another accurately historic fiction. The problem is, Vidal doesn't have complete respect for things he doesn't fully understand or know, so some passages of the book feature a bad taste that I don't like.
This book is not so dense and enjoyable as some of Vidal's other works, like "Lincoln" or "Creation" or Burr, but still one is able to learn about the period, society, people, etc featured in the story.
As part of the trilogy "Burr", "1876", "Washington D.C.", a necessary read for Vidal fans.
Grade 8.6/10
Used price: $5.25
Collectible price: $10.55
Buy one from zShops for: $7.50
There was ample gossip and name dropping, so if you're into dirt on the Kennedy's, Capote or Gore himself, you won't be disappointed. But if you're seeking a serious or even semi-critical examination of Gore, flaws and all, you won't find it here.
It's a shame, because few men of any generation have had the brains, wit and talent of Gore Vidal, but he has proven elusive to the picklocks of biographers.
But as a biography it is flawed, essentially because Kaplan views everything through Vidal's perspective. Little critical analysis is given to significant events in Vidal's life, except to the extent Vidal provides some himself and articulates it to the biographer. By excusing, defending and/or justifying the many poses, positions, and actions this larger-than-life figure has taken, the book reads less like a biography and more like an apologia. Hey, maybe Gore's entitled to one.
The main characters are extremely good. There is McKinley (a political master about whom I knew virtually nothing and hence learned a good deal), Teddy Roosevelt (a buffoon in Vidal's hands who is also a political juggernaut), WR Hearst (a devourer of anything he desires and self-appointed "creator" of history), and John Hay (Lincoln's secretary, TR's secretary of state, and an imperialist). There are also the fictional Sanford half-brother and -sister, who appear in his other American novels, who are very funny as they struggle ruthlessly against eachother for the family fortune as well as for the same man. The peccadilloes of finely drawn characters were the stuff that made empires fall and created war, in particular in the Philippines. There are also the Vanderbilts, the Whitneys, and many other giants from the Gilded Age. Finally, Henry James has two brief appearances and goes into long monologues that read exactly like his stuffy prose.
In addition to the theme of the rise of the modern media with Hearst's active creation of news - perhaps literally provoking the war with Spain by manufacturing a crisis to sell newspapers - the reader is treated to the technological changes that are going on as a backdrop (electricity and horseless carriages). It is marvelously evocative, particularly as it occurred at the beginning of the last century and inspired a sense of wonder, which is the greatest achievement an historical novel can aspire to.
Because he grew up in this milieu (his Grandfather, as one of the first appointed Senators from the new state of Oklahoma, makes a sly cameo appearance) Vidal is most convincing as he dissects the casual vanity of people in power: they are just going into the family business of politics, to which they feel entitled, and are apparently not filled with the ideals that we were taught in school, or so Vidal would have us believe. As a subtle and wholly jaundiced take on America, his is a truly original comic voice and the prose is as luminous as ever. While I disagreed with a lot of it, I laughed at least once on every page and I felt like learning more about most of the characters. That to me is another sign of the novel's success. Nonetheless, now that I have read almost all of the series, I am beginning to tire of Vidal's cynicism. There is something so relentless, even facile, about it that it makes me wonder if Vidal is playing with the reader or if the deficiency of vision is in fact his and not the subjects' he chooses to accuse of hypocrisy and demagogy.
Warmly recommended.