Used price: $35.00
Collectible price: $30.00
Used price: $7.50
Used price: $7.00
Collectible price: $15.88
Buy one from zShops for: $6.98
Used price: $5.11
Collectible price: $15.94
Nevertheless, it can still be read with benefit... if nothing else it's an inspiring and thought provoking account of the mind without the limitations (but also the structural framework) of modern psychology.
Paul N. Anderson
Visiting Associate Professor of New Testament, Yale Divinity School
Miguel Llora
Used price: $2.24
Collectible price: $5.29
Buy one from zShops for: $19.11
Used price: $5.00
Collectible price: $8.93
Buy one from zShops for: $6.90
I found this book, which covers the span from the beginning of this religion over 150 years ago to the present day church, to be very readable and informative. The author writes about the theology, the scripture, the rules, the sacred ceremonies, and the lifestyles of Mormons today. It is obvious that the authors did a tremendous amount of research and tried to present an unbiased account.
I found myself seeing a church that changes with the prevailing winds and discourages its members from looking too hard at its origins, as needed to control (maybe that is too strong a word) its membership. I also saw a religion that promotes wonderful family and social values, one that takes care of its own.
I am not sure about the high moral ground that the authors claim for most Mormons. I think that Mormons are just like anyone else in business or personal dealings. In fact, I know this to be true.
This book also raised many questions in my mind about some of the Mormon practices, like eternal marriage and the secret wedding ceremony. I do not think there is another religion that has so many secretive things going on, hidden from the outside world. Yet the LDS church seems to want to preserve its cultish secrecy, as if that makes it more appealing.
I also wonder how the Mormon faithful, many of whom are intelligent and well-educated, accept all that they are asked to accept, seemingly without question....especially since so many of the founding beliefs and precepts have been changed as needed. I also was left wondering about the very odd beginnings of this religion. I guess this is what is meant by "faith", but to me,it seems like blind faith.
My doubts aside, I think that the author has done a marvelous job of allowing the reader to draw his/her own conclusions by presenting the information contained in the book in a fair way.
There are a number of minor errors, but overall I was pleasantly surprised at the accuracy of this work. The Ostlings have obviously dedicated countless hours to research and interviews, and constructed their book with meticulous care. I would recommend it to anyone unacquainted with the LDS faith that wishes to know more about us.
Naturally, the Ostlings do not shy away from controversial topics, the inclusion of which in this book will no doubt upset some Church members. They also seem to feel an obligation to present both the positive and negative aspects of the faith as they see them. They are, after all, both non-LDS and journalists. I am convinced that their book represents their honest attempt at a neutral assesment of the Latter-day Saint religion and its importance in the modern world. There is much here for readers to appreciate, whether or not they share the authors' attitudes toward the Church.
In any work of such broad scope, most readers will question the emphasis given some material and the omission of other pertinent information (for myself, I wonder why S-F writer Orson Scott Card's name does not appear in the chapter on LDS celebrities). Nevertheless, Mormon America is most remarkable, in my opinion, for all that it does cover. Readers from outside the LDS Church, in particular, will find many, if not most, of their basic questions about the faith answered in this volume.
A glance at the religion shelves of the local bookstore tends to show a few how-to-witness-to- the-Mormons books, a couple of specialized volumes on Mormon history, and maybe a few by LDS leaders and scholars. A general book on the Church by non-LDS authors, one that neither attempts to promote nor denigrate the faith, has been sorely wanting. Mormon America fills this niche admirably. It is considerably better than I would have expected for the first major work of this kind, and will be welcome reading for those beginning a study of the Mormon religion.
As I grew up, I learned quite a lot about theology. Though I've never felt the desire to leave my own church, my experience as a boy got me quite interested in Mormonism as a religious system. I've always wondered how people who were so strongly ethical could rationalize a theology that is often strange and inconsistent. Reading this book was a great help in clarifying some of my thoughts and experiences.
The reason this book is so well done for a person with an intellectual bent towards religion is that it is balanced. The Ostlings are do not come across as either pro- or anti-Mormon. They present the information they have gathered and judge certain things about the Mormons positive and certain things negative.
Many of their judgements mesh well with my own experiences with Mormonism. For example, they point out the strong family values that Mormons have as well as their incredible willingness to help others, particularly, though not exclusively, other Mormons. In fact, they have well-organized systems of relief for those who are suffering. Better, perhaps, than almost any other religion. In addition, they have a culture of service to their church that outstrips many others.
On the other hand, despite the protests of many Mormon scholars, Mormon theology is clearly a break from any traditional understanding of Christianity. They have a system of revelation which, though not a problem in principle, makes for inconsistent theological development with which it can be difficult to deal. (I've never understood why people would believe that God spoke to prophets thousands of years ago but wouldn't now. Still, any prophet, I think, would have to meet a certain muster to be accepted by a large population.) Additionally, Mormons are clearly secretive and very conservative which causes a lot of tension not only with other religions but also with disenfranchised groups within their church.
All of these aspects and more are clearly and deeply covered by the Ostlings in their book. Anyone with any interest in Mormons or Mormonism would be well-advised to read this book. It is a fair account not influenced too deeply by either side.