
Used price: $2.18
Collectible price: $15.00
Buy one from zShops for: $4.46





Used price: $5.87
Buy one from zShops for: $6.86



I was surprised to find that the book has almost no religious profanity. This seems strange, given that Poland is about 95% Catholic, and the author doesn't indicate if it's an omission or if there simply aren't any such curses. I also would have liked a scale of some sort to indicate which phrases were obscene and which were merely naughty. Still, it's a fun book, and if you've ever been ripped off by a Warsaw cab driver it's a useful one too.

List price: $11.00 (that's 20% off!)
Used price: $4.65
Buy one from zShops for: $11.00


The guy is a heavy thinker, and come from a European tradition of taking science fiction seriously as a literature of ideas (Lem wrote the classic Solaris, which was made into a Russian movie). He is quite readable, however, and is obviously passionate about his subject. This book is essential for any academic study of science fiction, and for any reader who takes the genre's potential seriously.


List price: $10.95 (that's 20% off!)
Used price: $6.57
Buy one from zShops for: $7.56



Used price: $76.94
Buy one from zShops for: $97.52



Used price: $3.24
Collectible price: $35.00
Buy one from zShops for: $12.19


The spirit of the novel is best contained in the statistician's remarks on gravity. The word "Gravity" doesn't really explain anything, rather it gives a name to the tendency of objects to fall toward the center of the earth. If something like that happens every day, we give it a name of some sort and accept it as normal. If something like that seldom happens, then it's exceptional and warrants investigation.
Although I was dissatisfied with the ending, the reasoning employed along the way there is pretty engrossing. The story is also strange enough in places to be bleakly humorous. Maybe an extra half-star, for being different.

Correlated facts are suggestive, but when the number of facts does not amount to a meaningful statistical sample the correlation may be an artifact, and then sound inductive reasoning often gives way to wild speculation. In "The Investigation", lieutenant Gregory of Scotland Yard desperately tries to puzzle out a consistent explanation for a bizarre series of disappearing corpses while receiving input from a scientist, a doctor, and fellow detectives --- each with his own ideas. The problem is that there doesn't seem to be enough solid evidence to decide whether the facts of the case have causal structure or whether they simply form "fortuitous patterns". Hmmm.
The category of "science fiction" is usually reserved for whimsical flights of fancy, but here we have a book that breathes fictional life into part of the intellectual apparatus that is at the very heart of science --- the empirical, or scientific, method. No pedantic statement is made about the empirical method, it's darker corners simply serve as a compelling thematic backdrop for a detective story. "The Investigation" is not a detective novel in the traditional sense though, and the ending will throw Agatha Christie enthusiasts for a disconcerting loop...but, an enjoyable one.
The narrative style is pleasingly "cinematic" in that, with few exceptions, only things that can be seen and heard are described --- it reads something like a well-written screenplay. This narrative approach is nothing new, though, and its lack of originality kept me from getting too excited; but, my fetish for stylistic originality is probably not shared by most readers. The book is also intellectually provocative without being didactic in that the story conjures up a small whirlwind of intriguing questions, not a parade of dubious and facile answers. Most importantly, it's a fun and engaging story. I really liked this one.


Buy one from zShops for: $24.95


Sosabowski starts his memoir with a brief chapter on his early years in which he recounts how he served in the Austro-Hungarian army in the First World War. Although he notes that he was drafted in 1914, fought in a number of actions and finished the war as a Second Lieutenant, there is very little detail here. While he states that he helped to form the new Polish army in 1918, he gives no information on what role he played in the critical Russo-Polish War of 1919-1920. Was he a staff officer or a unit commander? Unknown. Nor does Sosabowski tell the reader much of anything about the period 1920-1939, other than to say he was an instructor at the military academy for a period of years.
The best chapter in the book covers the German Blitzkrieg in Poland in 1939. When the invasion started, Sosabowski was commander of the 21st Infantry Regiment in the 8th Division, located north of Warsaw. Although Sosabowski's regiment repulsed one initial German attack, his division fell apart and he was forced to withdraw into the Warsaw perimeter. When Warsaw surrendered, Sosabowski marched into captivity with his troops but soon escaped occupied Poland. Sosabowski was in France for six months, as deputy commander of the 4th Polish Division, but fled to England with his troops when Paris was overrun. The middle part of the book covers the formation of these remnants into the 1st Polish Parachute Brigade and the final part covers the unit's employment in Operation Market-Garden.
Sosabowski is not the most sympathetic character due to an unfortunate tendency to ignore the achievements of others. He claims that when he arrived in France in December 1939 that he was the "first senior officer to come straight out of occupied Poland..", which ignores the fact that Colonel Stanislaw Maczek had arrived in France in October 1939. Maczek had also commanded a brigade in the Polish campaign, and unlike Sosabowski, he commanded a Polish brigade in the French campaign as well. Maczek went on to command the only other major Polish ground unit stationed in the United Kingdom, the 1st Armored Division, but he is never mentioned in this account. According to Sosabowski, many of the other Polish officers in the West were overweight, overage cronies who had missed the fight in the homeland. This is a tremendous slight to his 100,000 countrymen who escaped Poland to continue the war against the Nazis. As a matter of fact, Sosabowski only mentions the names of a few of his subordinates. Although he twice tells us the name of his English landlady, he only tells the reader the name of one of this three battalion commanders and one or two other company-grade officers.
There is very little real detail in this account. I had to check Martin Middlebrook's excellent Arnhem: The Airborne Battle to ascertain the Polish brigade's composition at Arnhem. Sosabowski tells the reader a great deal about how the colors for the unit were covertly made in Poland and smuggled out to England, but he does not even tell the reader that 1,689 Polish paratroopers went into Holland and 203 were killed or captured (12% casualties). Although this was the highlight of his career, the author spends only 40 fairly uninformative pages on the Arnhem battle. The book ends when Sosabowski was relieved two months later due to friction with his British commanders; there is no mention of what happened to the brigade or its men after he left or even what he did for the next 23 years.
One would expect a great deal of recrimination here by Sosabowski about the poor planning of Market-Garden or the poor manner in which he was treated by the British command, but there is little of that here. He must have mellowed out by the time he wrote this over fifteen years later. Indeed, it is surprising to see the author support the notion that Field Marshal Montgomery's "single thrust" strategy into Germany was superior to Eisenhower's "broad front" strategy. Evidently, logistics was not Sosabowski's strong point. In the end, he blames the intelligence community and the air planners for the majority of the Arnhem disaster. The reader does have to sympathize with Sosabowski about the piece-meal and disastrous manner in which his brigade was committed into its one and only action, but the author does little commiseration. In short, this account adds no new insights into the Battle of Arnhem.



Buy one from zShops for: $81.00

List price: $15.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $7.95
Collectible price: $9.99
Buy one from zShops for: $10.52