Indeed this is a "World's Classic." I would like to see it preserved as the author intended.
Collodi good, abridgement bad.
Perhaps this book's principal contribution, however, is its cool and calm expos of the "art world's" best-kept secret: that, at base, it is a fraud that has less to do with expression than financial gain. Readers get a clear, well-written, and easily believable picture of an artist's life during that time of near-mythical when hard drinkin', butch fightin', and tough paintin' were the mainstays of New York's boy-culture art scene of the 50s and into the 60s. The book provides a much-wanted description of why there's so little "there" there in the articles by the likes of Greenberg and Rosenberg. In light of their various affairs--both amorous and financial-one understands how these critics' and their cronies' small-scale star making paved a sort of on-ramp to the market-driven farce the art world is today.
By all means read Elaine and Bill. It is fascinating reading on many levels and, when all is said and done, provides a window--for some too clean and revealing a window--into the machinery driving the manufacture of art today.
Admittedly, it is interesting to find out about how the market for maps has exploded in the last few decades, and there is a nice profile of an aggressive map trader (Graham Arader). Less interesting is the wealth of detail about Gilbert Bland's life, since (according to the author) by all appearances Bland lives up to his name quite accurately. The author repeatedly compares the exploration in the Age of Discovery with his search for what sent Bland on a multinational map thievery spree, armed with just a razor blade and an inconspicuous face. Frankly, I would have liked to read more about the actual maps and explorers and less about Bland, whose crimes are notable but not worthy of the majority of a book's attention. The author even makes the mistake of letting us know how he tried (and failed) to contact Bland and pump him for information; unless such stories are extremely entertaining, there's no reason for a writer to mar his narrative by injecting himself into it.
I give kudos to this book for getting me excited about cartography and the history of exploration, but slogging through the author's guesswork about the psychology of Gilbert Bland wasn't fun. I'd recommend a real history book instead.
Mr. Harvey was assigned back in 1995 to cover the case of one of the biggest map thieves of all time, an unassuming fellow by the name of Gilbert Bland. This character, was later discovered, had stolen around 250 maps from libraries across the USA and Canada in order to sell them 'for a buck'.
I found the stories about great collectors and dealers, such as the famous Graham Arader III, fascinating. We are invited to an auction in Sotheby's and can follow it along just as Mr. Arader bids on items of his interest for a total of $800,000. We are also introduced to the famous discoverers, such as Ferdinand Magellan and Christopher Columbus, through a very entertaining and detailed history of cartography in chapter 7. What IS NOT interesting in the least, is the story of Gilbert Bland himself. He is too much of a simplistic character that might have been good for an article in a magazine; but is definitely not worth a whole book. I find perhaps, Bland's adventure (to call it something) might have provided a good starter for a fictionalized piece. However, the way it is used here, the way the author tries to psychoanalize him (even himself), is absolutely boring and pointless.
This is, nevertheless, an interesting book for starting collectors of rare books, antique maps and manuscripts. The way rare books rooms are run and what we can expect to find in them, the way dealers conduct their business; and the staggering sums of money some of these pieces are capable of reaching in today's markets will let most people with their mouths wide open.
The Putt at the End of the World is apparently the brainchild of last-listed author Les Standiford, shown as editor and compiler. It also seems to be a salute, at least in part, to recently deceased British writer Douglas Adams, author of the Hitchhikers' Guide to the Galaxy series which includes The Restaurant at the End of the Universe. It is certainly reminiscent of Adam's work, with zany characters interacting amidst nefarious schemes, all centered around a golf tournament. But not just any golf tournament. Computer zillionaire Philip Bates has bought a Scottish castle and cleared original growth timber to construct the ultimate golf course-as well as rehabbing the castle into an exotic hideaway retreat. This infuriates both environmental terrorists and the last of the MacLout clan, who claims that the MacGregor sellers usurped his family's claim to the property and he should have gotten the money. Then Bates (no relation to this reviewer) scheduled a conference and golf tournament inviting all of the world's political leaders and top golf players.
One of the invitees is Billy Sprague, club pro from Squat Possum Golf Club in rural Ohio. Billy is a magnificent golfer, unless there is money involved in which case he can't even get the ball of the tee. Billy's mentor is the old retired family doctor whose life is golf, who build the Squat Possum Club and who dies immediately after giving Billy his invitation and telling him that he has to go to Scotland and play in order to lift the curse and "...save the world as we know it..." Then FBI and British Secret Service refugees from the Keystone Kops get involved because of the terrorist threat, and the rest is-not history, but hilarious.
Each of the nine authors wrote one of the chapters. They did a good job matching styles, and/or Standiford did a great job of editing, because the novel is seamless. It is a farce, but at the same time has a "Bagger Vance" note of paean to the wonder of golf. It reads fast, and it reads great.