Used price: $3.95
Used price: $2.89
Collectible price: $5.29
Used price: $33.87
Used price: $2.00
_Little Big Man_ is an impossible book to read if you take it seriously - it has to be read as a joke. The adventures of Jack Crabb, known by the Cheyenne as Little Big Man, are ridiculously oversized and exaggerated. Told by the 111-year-old Crabb, who claims he lived both as a white and a Cheyenne, married into both cultures, did every possible Old-West job you could do (including being a drunk), out-dueled Wild Bill Hickok, both swore to kill General George Armstrong Custer and fought beside him, and was the sole survivor of the Battle of Little Bighorn, Thomas Berger tries -far- too hard to make the ultimate American novel. If you read it as if it's funny, the book is funny.
But even if you do, it's very likely that you're going to hate it. Jack Crabb is not a character that is easily liked - and considering he's the only character who stays around for very long, it makes the book hard to stomach. The film version, directed by Arthur Penn, makes Dustin Hoffman's Jack Crabb much more bumbling and perhaps even lovable.
It covers some thirty-five years, perhaps more, and squashes in every possible bit of the American West you can imagine, and -somehow- it all feeds into Jack's life. When the book was all said and done, I found that there had been no plot, no continuous main thread of anything save Jack's dilemma between being Indian or white (which he never solves nor admits that he can, perhaps, be both). The story could have kept on going forever had it not ended where it did after the Battle of Little Bighorn. In that sense it was a true biography in its style, but it left something to be desired in terms of dramatic interest.
What I -did- like about _Little Big Man_ was its unsentimental portrayal of the Indian culture. It didn't paint the whites as bad guys and the Indians as saints. It didn't do the opposite, either. It showed that whites have their cultural good points and bad points, and Indians have their cultural good points and bad points. It was true, and didn't pander to one side or the other - the film, however, completely changes it to be sympathetic to the Cheyenne, which was highly disappointing.
All in all, _Little Big Man_ is pretentious and overambitious, only worth reading if you have to read it. I don't believe that it deserves to be called "a singular literary achievement that, like its ancient hero, only gets better with the years" (back of book), or "the very best novel ever about the American West" (New York Times). It's pretentious praise for a pretentious novel that is extremely hard to muddle through, and even harder to really enjoy - and this is coming from someone who loves to read and can always find something worthwhile in almost any book. It does have good points, like I said, but otherwise . . . it was not at all to my tastes and does not come recommended at all.
Used price: $10.59
Buy one from zShops for: $10.00
Used price: $150.00
Used price: $0.93
Collectible price: $2.96
Buy one from zShops for: $11.99
Used price: $1.00
Collectible price: $0.98