The book itself is a good, easy read, featuring lots of color photos and drawings by Daryl that hasn't had too many cartoonists looking over their shoulders.
This item is currently out-of-print, but it would do well for the author to update "Dangerous Dances" since a lot has happened since 1984 and Daryl & John have had a rennaisance of sorts with the success of their "Do It For Love" album which has already scored a number one A/C song and the duo has also had a recent (February, 2003) Billboard Magazine issue done as a tribute to their 30+ years as artists.
List price: $24.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $12.50
Buy one from zShops for: $5.49
However, he goes off the deep end, as usual for Tosches. Too many Ezra Pound discursions, for starters. If you're trying to impress us with your deep knowledge of foreign languages, you'd best not quote extensively from that old fraud, who "translated" buttloads of poetry from languages he couldn't read (with "help"); this taints Tosches with the suspicion of similar overreaching. It's great that he has read up on Greek word roots, but these links are too tenuous; it's a little bit of showing off and doesn't really illuminate anything. If he wants to write another book carrying his musical history ideas back from English ballads to ancient Greece, go for it, but here it just looks like dressing-up time. Stick to the blues.
And though Tosches is a great critic of the pop music of his time, like all of his contemporaries in that game (Meltzer, Marcus, ad infinitum) he's every bit as stuck in a particular rut as those he would criticize. He's quoting Iggy Pop and Patti Smith again, folks.
But while those complaints are serious, they don't detract from the fundamental brilliance of the story. It's a terrific, if languid, detective story, as well as an opening into a new world of understanding popular music. Tosches is the only "rock" critic ever who could have written it, which is a pity. I don't see how you can understand where our music came from without this book. Read it.
Over those twenty years Tosches found out about Miller and records a lot of that information in this book. This is great selfless work by Tosches and by other scholars who were inspired by his work and by Miller's music.
Well, this is not fiction, this is what we know about him, about minstrelry, about his life. You can't blame Nick for the fact that the truth is a bit less colorful and still less filled in than fiction.
Also, Tosches is no academic and does not pretend to be. He's music's best and most literary representative of the new journalism.
Miller is important. He was good. His music sounds great today. If you don't think so, you need your ears adjusted, your sense of life, love, and joy revived. He may not have been a financial success, but critical trend setters, particularly in Country Music, have styled themselves after him to this day.
Bob Wills--another former blackface perform-- combined Emmett Miller, the blues of the MIssissippi Sheiks, La Musica Ranchera, and ranch dance music into Western Swing. Wills auditioned his singers throughout his career by asking them to sing Miller's hits and comparing them to Miller. Wills recorded songs identified with Miller throughout his career.
Hank William's biggest success was essentially an imitation of an imitation of Miller. Merle Haggard has acknowledged his heritage by recording a Miller tribute album and usually does a Miller-Wills number during every concert. Leon Redbone gets a very large amount of his singing style and personna from Miller.
The problem of minstrelry can't be discussed without discussing race and culture in America in a way most people can't discuss it, like it is a real problem that is really there and part of the discoursde, win or lose. I don't exactly agree with Tosches' take on the problem, but, at least, he approaches the issue honestly and put it in the center of the discourse where it
belongs.
Perhaps, unlike Tosches' Country Music and Hellfire, this is not a book that belongs in every home, every school, every library, every bookstore, but it belongs on every bookshelf of anyone interest in American popular music, especially country music and Western Swing.
Never say never. Miller's legend refused to be left alone, and the long-deceased minstrel man from a vanished era so haunted Tosches in the ensuing years that he, with the help of other researchers, finally began fleshing out the actual details of Emmett Miller's life and times. This book, a worthy companion and in many ways a sequel to 'Country,' is the result.
In 'Where Dead Voices Gather,' Tosches uses Emmett Miller's life as the foundation and starting point to an all-encompassing essay on the subject of race, music, and America. Along this 299-page journey we encounter minstrel men and shamen, Delta bluesmen and drag queens, gospel quartets and Mafioso, New York City society and "Georgia Crackers." If Papa Charlie Jackson shares a paragraph with Ezra Pound, if Ragtime Henry Thomas and Homer are discussed in similar terms, and if Bob Dylan, the Dorsey Brothers, William Faulkner, Scatman Crothers, Friedrich Nietzsche, Stephen Foster, Bob Wills, and Samuel Beckett all make guest appearances throughout, in Tosches's hands it all begins to make sense. Everything relates, nothing has essentially changed much -- "Primordium and continuum." Again and again, Tosches returns to this theme, illuminating his point with arguments and logic that would sound improbable or insane in a lesser writer's hands. The minstrel show never went away, he writes, it just took on new forms, new styles, some more covert than others.
"It went on," he writes, "the strange and gaudy medicine show of American culture: the secrets of its history, its revelations, lost beneath its sound and fury, like the secrets and revelations of an ancient mystery cult, lost to the dust of time, that endure, untelling, where dead voices gather, beneath the endless veils of passing."
Yes, there are some questionable aspects to the book. Relevant photographs and illustrations are inexplicably and inexcusably absent from 'Where Dead Voices Gather.' Occasionally, Tosches launches into personal biography for seemingly no reason at all; it certainly adds nothing to the book, and the ending in particular suffers from this tendency. Similarly, Tosches establishes his patented and tired "machismo" early on by assaulting virtually all academic studies of minstrelsy and, as if to prove that he's no academic sissy, provides no footnotes, bibliography, or anything else befitting a serious piece of historical research.
But the strength of Tosches's prose is such that we must forgive him of his insufferable ego. These flaws are indeed minor in the vast fullness of 'Where Dead Voices Gather.'
Used price: $0.01
Collectible price: $2.33
Buy one from zShops for: $6.50
List price: $24.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $2.25
Collectible price: $4.00
Buy one from zShops for: $5.95
I was expecting a lot from this book--maybe too much. After reading it, my expectations were not met. A much better account of Liston can be found in William Nack's brilliant 1991 article "O Unlucky Man," in Sports Illustrated (perhaps the best sports piece ever written); so is David Remnick's "King of The World." Those two books, though smaller works than Tosches' Liston book, have more detail and probe into further depths of Liston's psyche. Tosches obviously knows about and likes to write about the underworld and Liston's connection with them--unfortunately, that wasn't all Liston was about--Tosches misses on Sonny's human side, seeing him as just a piece of meat passed around from mob boss to mob boss.
Tosches virtually ignores the two fights with Ali--speculating on a fix but offering no hard evidence--and barely touching on his title winning effort and rematch with Floyd Patterson, the stuff of high drama, given the time these fights took place in. He also uses the annoying postmodern glitch of interrupting the flow of the book at times to put his own cute comments in the book (hint to Mr. Tosches--just because you're writing about boxing doesn't mean you have to say the f-word every time you interject the story).
I appreciate the detail Tosches went to in writing the book--he obviously did his homework with interviews and documents---if he had just focused more on Sonny the person instead of Sonny the piece of meat, he would have captured Liston's essence much better.
List price: $24.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $9.95
Collectible price: $15.88
Buy one from zShops for: $14.85
There is more to Tosche's novel than mobsters popping priests for a stolen poem of "incalculable" value (p. 302), and this is precisely where things get interesting. In his first-person narrative, Tosches burns like an inferno, criticizing everything from monotheism, publishers, Oprah's Book Club, mediocrity and even his own editor. In fact, throughout his book, very little escapes the heat of Tosches' impassioned rage. The spectacle of his narrative conflagration, seasoned with profanities, will surely offend some readers, but will attract many others. Does Tosches burn as brightly as Dante? Well, no. But I enjoyed every minute of reading this novel.
G. Merritt
Used price: $2.03
Collectible price: $2.19
The first part of this book is wall to wall confusion, reading like the Italian yellow pages. There are also many quotes in Italian, and these might help aspiring linguists, like me. Otherwise, only a few stalwarts will wade through this first half of the book.
Later, in the second half of the book, the pace picks up some, when Mr. (Signore?) Sidona finally gets caught by the law's so-called long arm. Mr. Tosches originally approached Sidona about a book after his fall from grace, while he was "resting" in an Italian prison. Tosches keeps the ball of Sidona up in the air for a little bit longer, with this book, but maybe Sidona's ball deserves to just fall and come to a final resting point.
I say this because, after all, Sidona wanted to play fast and loose, he took his inherent gifts (he was good with numbers, well educated and an avvocatto, a lawyer, and apparently was a personable sort of fellow with all the contacts he had), but what did he do with these talents? Well, he tried to aggrandize himself, and is this any new story? He ran with the wolves and he paid the price, end of story.
Thanks to Nick Tosches for keeping the ball in the air a little longer. This helps the generations following Sidona and his age cohorts to understand the crazy world which precedes them, like a bad reputation. Diximus.
Used price: $4.00
Collectible price: $4.00
Used price: $2.79
Collectible price: $8.47