Related Subjects: Author Index Reviews Page 1 2
Book reviews for "Sorel,_Georges" sorted by average review score:

Sorel: Reflections on Violence
Published in Hardcover by Cambridge University Press (1999)
Authors: Georges Sorel and Jeremy Jennings
Amazon base price: $70.00
Used price: $45.00
Buy one from zShops for: $61.69
Average review score:

Fascinating Museum Piece
Sorel's most famous work is an interesting conflation of Marxism and XIXth century Romanticism. Like most socialist literature it idealizes the "worker" as an heroic figure standing astride history.

The book advocates syndicalism (a system in which industrial workers' unions are the vehicles of political power), but it eschews the pseudoscientific rhetoric favored by Marx and Lenin. Sorel is not particularly strong on economics, and he knows it.

What he does know is cultural history and he advocates political rebellion through violence and mythmaking. The book is essentially a broadside against Jaures and the calculative, creeping parliamentary socialism of fin de siecle France. He finds Jaures and his methods to be too meek and compromising. He characterizes parliamentarism (accurately) as a system of endless debate, dealmaking and "selling out". Sorel advocates revolutionary violence as a means to both power and the creation of a new mythic order. He correctly observes that the Jacobins were violent and bloody, yet they managed to create a mythology for the French Revolution which still held a strong cultural resonance in his day.

Direct action, mythmaking and ruthless bloodshed were the means Sorel recommended for revolution. His ideas went largely unacted upon in France, but the anarchosyndicalists of Spain took him quite seriously.

His greatest disciple however, was a young socialist named Benito Mussolini. Mussolini's Fascist movement was based upon direct action and inspired by a myth of a resurgent Roman Empire. Mussolini made explicit reference, again and again, to the importance of myth in revolutionary struggle.

Sorel inadvertently became the prophet of revolutionary Fascism.

Two asides: (a) there is no reason for corporate executives to keep this book by their bedsides - it contains nothing of economic value, and its ideology is thoroughly exhausted and devoid of contemporary relevance; (b) Sorel is one of the few French intellectuals besides Tocqueville who seemed to have a healthy respect for America and the American economic miracle.

The power of myths, the importance of choosing wisely
"Reflections on violence" was written in 1908 by Georges Sorel, and gives us a good idea of what revolutionary syndicalism was like to him. Even if this book isn't widely read, it is quite important in the history of political ideas. It is a little difficult to read sometimes, because it was the result of many articles that the author had written regarding many subjects. When he finally put them together he didn't rewrite them, because he believed that to be good, reading must be an exercise that implies a certain amount of work. Well, he achieved his aim, but all the same the book is well worth the effort.

In "Reflections on violence" Sorel gives great importance to the idea of social myth, because according to him, myths can lead everybody's energy towards a given aim. In his opinion, there is an enormous difference between myths and utopias, because myths don't only describe an ideal, but try to reach it. Through utopia you tear yourself from the world, with a myth you transform it (and transforming it you find yourself, because man is creative activity).

Sorel thinks that myths are not rational, and because of that they cannot be judged intellectually. One of those myths is the myth of the general strike. He believed that particular myth could give the proletariat (through syndicalism) enough strenght to fight against the bourgeoisie. Sorel also affirms that violence is positive, because while force gives the workers chains, the violence directed at that force frees them.

In conclusion, I must say I liked this book. When he highlights the importance of myth, I guess he also somehow stresses the tendency human beings have to dedicate their life to an ideal, a cause. And that ideal is likely to be of the utmost importance to us, because our beliefs make us. That is the reason why it is so important to choose the right ideal, the right cause. The problem is that Sorel doesn't measure the truth of each myth, but merely its efficacy, and by doing so opens the way for all kind of disasters. How can we expect even a little bit of rationality from social life if the ultimate end of that life cannot be evaluated rationally?. And if we cannot understand intellectually our aim (the myth), how can we realise if it is legitimate?. If you can, read this book... It'll make you think !!!

Acceptable Violence - ?
This book, should be studies in conjunction with books on violence. It illuminates that despite today's pacifity within the labour movement, circumstances (as exist in these modern times), justify resorting to 'activism'. A reading of Sorel's expose of the machinations of Socialists, the Middle Classes, et al clearly show that in these years of 'Neo-Liberalist' ideology and the guises of Capitalism under the new cloak of 'Globalisation' ..... nothing has changed for the great swaith of working poor, dumbing down or buying off Trade Unions etc etc.

This book should be required reading of anyone who aspires to a pro-active approach to conditions surrounding work and Labour.

It would be useful for corporate executives and polticians to keep this book permanently by their bedsides.


Commitment and change : Georges Sorel and the idea of revolution
Published in Unknown Binding by University of Toronto Press ()
Author: Richard Vernon
Amazon base price: $
Used price: $8.00
Average review score:
No reviews found.

The Cult of Violence: Sorel and the Sorelians Jack J. Roth.
Published in Hardcover by University of California Press (1980)
Author: Jack Joseph, Roth
Amazon base price: $64.37
Used price: $21.95
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Die imaginäre Revolte : Untersuchungen zur faschistischen Ideologie und ihrer theoretischen Vorbereitung bei Georges Sorel, Carl Schmitt und Ernst Jünger
Published in Unknown Binding by Verlag Arbeiterbewegung und Gesellschaftswissenschaft ()
Author: Armin Steil
Amazon base price: $
Average review score:
No reviews found.

From Georges Sorel 1/E
Published in Paperback by Oxford University Press (1985)
Authors: Charlotte Stanley, John L. Stanley, and Georges Sorel
Amazon base price: $11.95
Used price: $9.92
Average review score:
No reviews found.

From Georges Sorel : essays in socialism and philosophy
Published in Unknown Binding by Oxford University Press ()
Author: Georges Sorel
Amazon base price: $
Used price: $37.06
Average review score:
No reviews found.

From Georges Sorel: Essays in Socialism and Philosophy
Published in Paperback by Transaction Pub (1987)
Author: Stanley L. Sorel
Amazon base price: $29.95
Used price: $8.90
Average review score:
No reviews found.

From Georges Sorel: Hermeneutics and the Sciences
Published in Hardcover by Transaction Pub (1990)
Authors: Georges Sorel and John L. Stanley
Amazon base price: $49.95
Used price: $40.75
Average review score:
No reviews found.

The Genesis of Georges Sorel: An Account of his Formative Period Followed by a Study of his Influence
Published in Hardcover by Greenwood Publishing Group (1982)
Author: James Hans Meisel
Amazon base price: $78.00
Used price: $58.00
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Georges Sorel
Published in Unknown Binding by Editions de l'Herne ()
Amazon base price: $
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Related Subjects: Author Index Reviews Page 1 2

Reviews are from readers at Amazon.com. To add a review, follow the Amazon buy link above.