Related Subjects: Author Index Reviews Page 1 2
Book reviews for "Somerville,_Edith" sorted by average review score:

The Real Charlotte
Published in Hardcover by A. & A. Farmar (1999)
Author: Edith O. Somerville
Amazon base price: $
Average review score:

Will the real Charlotte please stand up?
This book presents an interesting tale and lesson for those who do not adhere to the concept of "to thine own self be true." The novel is set in late Victorian-era (1890s) Ireland, alternating between Dublin and the countryside. The main characters are Anglo-Irish, ruling class, aristocracy and gentry, and the novel focuses upon their relationships to eachother, both real and perceived. The title character, Charlotte, is an unmarried, middle-aged woman who behaves differently with each person with whom she interacts. She is romantically interested in Mr Lambert, an old (and married) friend, and does much for him, including lending him money. She behaves another way with Sir and Lady Dysart, and with their son and heir Christopher (respectful, accommodating). She has far less patience and love for young, beautiful Francie Fitzpatrick, a distant relative who is sent to live with her when Francie's family falls upon hard times financially. She (quite rightly) perceives Francie as a threat, and treats her poorly from the moment Francie arrives at Charlotte's home. Charlotte is outright mean and cruel to servants, Lambert's wife (who is supposed to be a good friend), tenants, and anyone she ranks as below her socially.
Charlotte is not the only one who hides her true nature. Mr. Lambert married for the income his wife brought to the marriage, but pays no attention to her, obviously does not love her, and openly courts Francie and displays jealousy and anger when he notices the mutual attraction between Francie and a young British army officer. He acts respectful to Christopher Dysart's face, but privately despises him and talks about him behind his back. He uses Charlotte--borrowing money from her, being friendly with her (which Charlotte interprets to mean something more than mere friendship), yet privately acknowledges to himself and others that he is not attracted to Charlotte. He also embezzles money from his employer's estate to pay for his horses, drinking, and gifts to Francie, without so much as a single thought that what he is doing is not only morally wrong but is a crime!
Francie is perhaps the most honest of all of the characters in this Irish tragedy, but even she is not entirely honest, not to others nor to herself. I find it easier to excuse her because she is a teenager in a difficult situation, has extremely limited options, and acts accordingly. She is honest about her growing feelings of love for Gerald Hawkins, the British officer, but he does not reciprocate that honesty--he is engaged to another woman (who will bring money to the marriage) but does not tell Francie. When she learns about his fiancee and realizes that the love between them is not enough, she breaks off her relationship with Gerald. Francie also receives the attentions of the socially-challenged (shy) Christopher Dysart, but she turns down his marriage proposal. A huge fight with Charlotte ensues, and she returns to her family in Dublin.

After Lambert's wife (conveniently) dies, Lambert follows Francie to Dublin, and makes an offer for her (in marriage), even though she has no money. He is physically attracted to her youth and beauty, and she, seeking to escape the hopeless poverty she faced with her family in Dublin, marries him even though she does not love him. It is this marriage, which set Charlotte over the edge, and she seeks her revenge upon him in a manner true to the saying "hell hath no fury like a woman scorned."
This Irish tragedy could have been averted had all of the characters displayed greater moral turpitude and honesty with both themselves and with others in their lives. The novel presents an interesting glimpse into a society which places a value upon people relative to the class into which they are born, and illustrates how unhappy people are when they marry for money instead of love. The characters are dishonest because the society in which they live values and rewards dishonest behavior and superficial values. Physical appearance (beauty) is valued above integrity, love, kindness, etc. One of the reasons Lambert is so taken with Francie is because she is young and beautiful, even though they are not a good match. Francie receives most, if not all, of the male attention because of her physical appearance, and has a greater chance of marriage than Charlotte, who is not physically attractive.
The novel is well-written, the characters well-developed, and, even though I found none of them to have any redeeming characteristics, the story was compelling to the end. Highly recommended.

real charlotte
everything you hope for in a classic. complex characters, interesting plot, the story pulls you along and it makes you think. when you are finished you feel you have gained something.


Some Experiences of an Irish R.M.
Published in Paperback by J S Sanders & Co ()
Authors: Martin Ross, E.Ce Somerville, and Edith O. Somerville
Amazon base price: $11.17
List price: $15.95 (that's 30% off!)
Average review score:

A cracking good read!
When Major Sinclair Yeates leaves the British army, and opts to become a Resident Magistrate in late-Nineteenth century Ireland, he has no idea what adventures await him. As he plods on, trying to do his job, he finds himself outthought and outmaneuvered at every step.

These wonderful stories, first published in the 1920s, were the basis for the hit British Television show, The Irish R.M., staring Peter Bowles. For those of you familiar with that show, the stories contained here cover the first six episodes, plus some. I must say that they did a wonderful job of capturing the story!

For those who have not seen the show, have no fear. This book is charming and terribly witty, and makes a cracking good read. I highly recommend this book to anyone interested in Ireland, and to anyone who likes a good book!

Hilarious reading written with art & wit
I first found out about "Some experiences of an Irish R.M." when I watched the whole series "The Irish R.M." on PBS a few years back. After the show ended I bought the book, and found that even though the t.v. series was wonderfully funny, the book was knock-down, drag-out HILARIOUS! Not a book to take to bed with you, while your spouse is attempting to sleep!

Each chapter is complete in every way, a perfect humorous short story and could stand alone by itself. So it makes the perfect daily read, as long as you can resist going on to the next chapter!

I have now read it 5 times and will be going on my 6th soon. I usually save the book for Fall reading.

I gave it to one of my friends, whose husband is a literature professor, and she loves it. HE, "who must be obeyed", hasn't read it, HATES it since it makes her laugh, and has almost shamed her into not rereading it, by calling it "vacuous". Well, that inspired me to give her another vacuous book right away!


All on the Irish Shore (Short Story Index Reprint Series)
Published in Hardcover by Ayer Co Pub (1940)
Authors: Edith A. Somerville and Martin Violet F.
Amazon base price: $20.95
Average review score:
No reviews found.

The Big House of Inver
Published in Paperback by Arrow (A Division of Random House Group) (07 February, 1991)
Authors: Edith Somerville and Martin Ross
Amazon base price: $
Average review score:
No reviews found.

The complete experiences of an Irish R.M.
Published in Unknown Binding by Sphere ()
Authors: Edith Somerville and Martin Ross
Amazon base price: $
Average review score:
No reviews found.

The Edith ¦none Somerville Archive, in Drishane : a catalogue and an evaluative essay
Published in Unknown Binding by Irish Manuscripts Commission ()
Amazon base price: $
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Further Experiences of an Irish R.M. (Isis Large Print Fiction)
Published in Hardcover by ISIS Publishing (1986)
Authors: Edith O. Somerville and Martin Ross
Amazon base price: $16.50
Average review score:
No reviews found.

In Mr. Knox's Country
Published in Hardcover by ISIS Publishing (1987)
Authors: Martin Ross and Edith O. Somerville
Amazon base price: $14.95
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Not Only in Stone
Published in Paperback by Rainbow Publishing (1991)
Authors: Phyllis Somerville and Edith O. Somerville
Amazon base price: $17.95
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Some Experiences of an Irish R.M. ; And, Further Experiences of an Irish R.m (Everyman's Library)
Published in Paperback by J M Dent & Sons Ltd (1994)
Author: Edith; Ross, Martin Somerville
Amazon base price: $8.95
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Related Subjects: Author Index Reviews Page 1 2

Reviews are from readers at Amazon.com. To add a review, follow the Amazon buy link above.