Used price: $3.99
Collectible price: $7.50
Buy one from zShops for: $7.00
Used price: $6.63
The jacket description continues: "...coupling case histories with the latest findings in the field of psychopharmacology and psychobiology..." But on page 191 this assertion is contradicted: "Obviously, none of what has been reported so far is meant to suggest that there is a brave new world of psychotherapy right around the corner where we can simply optimistic new pathways into patients' heads via electrical stimulation or other utopian methods. What? Translation: "We really don't have anything new to report." So why the book? What we really have is an admission of unoriginality. "On Mood Swings" is also highly presumptuous. Further on page 191, we read "'Getting it' is not stress-induced divine revelation." What does that mean, exactly? All we have are annoying statements of the obvious which was not even prefaced, such as one on page 131: "Genetically we are programmed to mate, and most of us, to procreate." Duh! I also looked for "...particular attention to the relative merits of the 'talking cure',..." Okay, if it is meritable, why are there no entries in the index for "talking cure"? The word "elation" is part of the subtitle, and again, there is no index entry. We know what elation means, we want to know what the author is implying. The author lost the art of explaining simply, perhaps out of fear of looking uneducated to her colleagues--clearly not how the public would perceive clear, concise writing. I found many occurrences of the phrase, "In other words..." Why not say it in these "other" words in the first place? Stating simply and oversimplifying are not the same. Our author even admits to not even knowing her conclusion on page 257, or even why she wrote the book: "...the treatment of mood disorders is purely speculative on my part, my admittedly unsystematic survey among colleagues working in these specialties, asking them as to whether or not these speculations are biologically possible or impossible, has not yielded a single definitive answer..." Translation: "After informally checking with my peers, I cannot prove or disprove anything." Really? Then why even bother writing it?
Sorry, author, that's not good enough. The critical mistake of admission by the author not knowing her subject was made, and it comes off the pages as a lack of enthusiasm and specifics. It is even more unacceptable when coming from someone with a Ph.D. At least Dr. Schad-Somers, however, listed her references and I appreciate that--a saving grace. Perhaps when the book came out (1990) it seemed more orignal. This book would shine if it were rewritten and reedited; that is, when the author clearly knows what she wants to say, and also when she DOES have more confidence in her subject. Readers are more savvy than ever, and authors always need to be one step ahead. But because the author TRIED, and also had the only title specifically on mood swings, I can't give her less than three stars. I hope to see a follow-up, either for the same book or the same subject.
List price: $29.95 (that's 30% off!)
List price: $27.00 (that's 30% off!)
List price: $17.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $6.18
Buy one from zShops for: $12.13