Related Subjects: Author Index Reviews Page 1 2 3
Book reviews for "Smiley,_Jane" sorted by average review score:

The Age of Grief
Published in Paperback by Anchor Books (11 June, 2002)
Author: Jane Smiley
Amazon base price: $9.60
List price: $12.00 (that's 20% off!)
Used price: $2.49
Buy one from zShops for: $6.00
Average review score:

Grief can also console... read when heartbroken
I picked this up after the end of a relationship in the same spirit that I listen to sad songs-- to amplify my own emotions, remember that others have been there too, and gain some release. "The Age of Grief" was good therapy!

The most wonderful story, in my opinion, was a heartbreaker called "Long Distance," in which a man released from a visit from a girl he no longer loves by circumstances realizes how her grief will be something he never gets over. This story is short and clean and unforgettable.

The title novella is powerful on so many levels-- told from the pov of a man who realizes his wife has fallen for someone else and is desperate not to let her tell him about it, it is such a convincing portrait of a marriage, of family, of the layers of fear and forgiveness that intimacy brings. One of the children gets a dangerously high fever and the terror and the bonds of love remind us that infidelity is sometimes part of a relationship, not its definition.

The only reason I didn't give this five stars is because while all of the stories are quick reads, well-written-- as is all of Smiley's work-- and occasionally even very funny, not all of them seem as grounded in the poignancy of emotional turning points. I was rather bored with "Dynamite," in which an aging underground movement protester from the sixties decides to reconnect with her family. That is to say, I didn't really think we needed that bit of plot-- I was far more interested in the family dynamics than the dynamite.

"Jeffrey, Believe Me" is a bit lightweight, doesn't seem to be a part of this volume really, though perhaps it provides some comic relief. "The Pleasure of Her Company" though is right up there with "Long Distance"-- friendship has its own jealousies and betrayals, and no happy couple can ever really be known except by themselves, as the lonely nurse who falls in love with her neighbors discovers.
"Lily" also lays out the issues of friendship and marriage-- friendship within marriage-- and how marriage is both more and less than romance.

Ultimately, read the book just for "Long Distance" alone. It's a masterpiece-- and it will haunt me.

The Inner Lives of Ordinary People
I think Jane Smiley is similar to Anne Tyler in her ability to understand ordinary people and the significance of home and family. Her characters have exceptional (sometime unbelievable) abilities of introspection and self-examination. They also seem to live somewhat muffled lives. Emotion is there, but it is observed rather than felt.

These stories move slowly, building up layers of character and atmosphere through observations and spare dialogue. The last story, "The Age of Grief", made me think of Henry James novels like "Portrait of a Lady." Here we are looking very closely at daily behavior, signals and symbols that pass between people, the subdued drama of everyday life.

Don't miss The Age of Grief!
I first read this book ten years ago and loved it. Rereading it was just as rewarding. Now I am married and a mother and I find the story "The Age of Grief" captures aspects of marriage not usually described. What is it like to be knocked down by illness as a family, parents needing to muster up energy to care for sick children when they are wracked with aches and exhaustion themselves? Jane Smiley delineates such moments and portrays marriage with great insight.


At Paradise Gate
Published in Paperback by Touchstone Books (1993)
Author: Jane Smiley
Amazon base price: $11.00
Used price: $0.01
Collectible price: $2.00
Buy one from zShops for: $1.25
Average review score:

(3.5 stars) Complexities of family life
Jane Smiley is at her literary best when dealing with intergenerational family issues. Three daughters and a granddaughter gather at their parent's home, concerned with Ike Robison's declining health, solicitous of their mother, Anna. After 36 seminal hours, we find that the daughters could not be more different, yet complementary in ways only close families recognize.

Each of the daughters view their parents from a personal perspective, especially their mother, Anna, projecting their own disillusionment onto her. Meanwhile Anna, mostly silent, muses about the grown daughters who surround her, wondering how they all came to live so close, gather so readily like a flock of restless birds, when she had meant to teach them to fly. Two daughters already widowed, one divorced, the women have all outlived the men, save Ike, and have lost their balance.

When granddaughter Christine comes home to visit, as well, she brings her own distractions. Twenty-three and newly married, Christine is full of the natural exhuberance of youth. The three daughters shift their attention back and forth, from Ike's worsening health to Christine's surprising announcement.

Occasionally a small voice from upstairs calls to Anna, "Mother! Mother!". Ike wishes only his wife to tend to his few needs. Moving between the two realities, Anna finds time for reflection upon her fifty-some years of marriage. In Anna's ruminations, there is a quiet revelation of her life through the years, as a young girl, as a married woman, years spent washing, cooking, cleaning. Years of service given without a thought to feelings or needs, or to the vagaries of married love. Looking back, her memories are as sharp as thorns and as sweet as new-shelled peas.

The power of the family dynamic seems at first to rest with the daughters, each pushing for her own resolution. They form temporary alliances, based on sibling rivalry, change perspective, shift yet again. Anna finds them engaged in their own busy pursuits; even the granddaughter falls into a deep afternoon slumber. Ultimately, it is Anna who holds our focus in this well crafted novel, her thoughts, her dreams. Never mundane or banal, the dialog is as sharp as the plot.

difficult characters, unlovable, but real
Jane Smiley managed to write a novel with unlikable characters that i enjoyed. That takes some skill!

The older you get, the more assertive you become, the more you know what to say or how to behave yourself in a tough situation. Right? Not really, if one is to look at Anna. She is just as insecure at 72 as she was in her youth. If one is to hope for invaluable wisdom as a payoff for lack of energy, strength, health, looks, etc., we are all screwed. This was my secret hope, and i am now very disappointed. Anna has been feeling weak as long as she can remember, first with her mother, then with her husband and his family, now with her daughters and even her granddaughter. What i find most pathetic is her inability to resolve her resentments towards her husband when she should have. She did not deal with whatever he did to her at its right time, and now that he is sick and almost an invalid is not the time to bring things up, yet Anna can't help herself. As a character, she infuriates me. If you don't do the right thing at the right time (in this case, deal with your husband), then let it go. Don't store it up and let it fester for decades. The rest of the family is sad and well portrayed. Ike is a sick man angry at the world for whatever obscure reason. Helen is pretentious. Claire is envious. Susanna is on the same path Anna is right now. Christine is the perfect example of why marriage and reproduction should not be allowed for anyone under 30. What's with her sense of entitlement and arrogance? At one point, her own mother calls her a 'dope'. Well put!

My two objections are Dolores, who is referred to time and time again and is never developed as a character (by comparison, Abel is very well described and understood), and Christine's final decision. It doesn't make sense, after spending half the book defending her arguments to now change her mind so quickly.

In this novel, which takes place in 36 hours, we get to know a family with generational problems and character problems. The imperfections of these characters make them real, and although none of them is lovable, they form a beautiful book. The detail and thoroughness that Jane Smiley goes through is remarkable.

The surprises of a mother's love.
In the midst of life's uncertainties, one has always been sure of a mother's love. It's one of life's givens, or is it? The startling perspective of the aging, female narrator in this superbly written novel is certain to give you new insights on the dynamics of family relationships, particularly the intricacies of mother-daughter and sibling relationships. Like a rich and original tapestry, the novel weaves the past, present and future of its characters into a beautiful blend of sadness and joy, always affirming the value of life, but life that is never predictable or obvious. Reading At Paradise Gate reminds us that while the gate may be in view, our feet remain firmly planted on earth


Jane Smiley's A Thousand Acres: A Reader's Guide (Continuum Contemporaries)
Published in Paperback by Continuum Pub Group (2001)
Authors: Susan Elizabeth Farrell and Susan Farrall
Amazon base price: $9.95
Used price: $8.25
Buy one from zShops for: $8.58
Average review score:

Jinxed
I want to re-title this book, Jinxed, as that's how I feel each time I read it. I threw this book across the room after finishing it, but after a few days realize perhaps Jane was trying to tell us how important a mother is in our lives. I grew up on a farm, my mother had a grave illness, but survived and lived as a disabled person all her life. My father brought her home from hospital and he and extended family (but mostly my dad) dedicated theirselves to making a normal successful life for us. I want to write an answer to Jane's novel that tells the story of how adversity can bring out the best --not the worst -- in people.

Good for teachers and students
I teach this novel at a local college, and this book has given me a lot of new angles to take, for which I'm grateful. It's particularly good on the ecological aspects of the novel. The author packs a lot of material into a short space. And I recommend it to my students with the proviso that they don't copy it for their essays.


Uncle Tom's Cabin: Or Life Among the Lowly (Modern Library Classics)
Published in Paperback by Modern Library (09 January, 2001)
Authors: Harriet Beecher Stowe and Jane Smiley
Amazon base price: $8.95
Used price: $3.45
Buy one from zShops for: $6.13
Average review score:

Putting light on the darkness
"Uncle Tom's Cabin" is not an uplifting book to read; however, it is very interesting. The book is an historically accurate look of what conditions could have been like for the slaves during the 1850's. The characters are not embellished and the plot is somewhat believeable. The slaves are portyared as people, unlike what they could have been described as during this time period. The story also describes how the South and the North had some different ways of treating people whether they were slaves or not.
The points I found not enjoyable took me out of my comfort zone and showed me a darker side of how slavery could have been. Stories of families being broken up and seeing a person beat another for little reason did not give me pleasure in reading. The book gives both sides in just about everything: good slave owner vs. bad slave owner, North vs. South, black girl vs. white girl, black family vs. white family. The whole story has a deeper, darker meaning of American history.

"Uncle Tom's Cabin" is a very good book because of its examination of America's dark secret of pain and suffering. When it was first published, this book was a wake up call for the country. By reading it at the millennium, we are helping keep the memory alive, so that slavery does not happen again in the U.S. I highly recomend this book to anyone who hasn't read it, and if you have the chance, study it.


Family: American Writers Remember Their Own
Published in Paperback by Vintage Books (1997)
Authors: Sharon Fiffer Sloan, Sharon Sloan Fiffer, Jane Smiley, and Steve Fiffer
Amazon base price: $13.00
Used price: $1.77
Buy one from zShops for: $2.58
Average review score:

Family: American Writers Remember Their Own
Different from any college textbook I have ever read, Family: American Writers Remember Their Own, is at a personal level to the reader. The individual stories about the writers' family members are written to be familiar to oneself. My favorite story was Happy Blue Crabs by Jose Raul Bernardo. Jose Raul's grandfather, Maximillo, is a chef and since his family ate meat everyday, he would only cook seafood at his restaurant. One special evening, Maximillo invited Jose Raul into the kitchen with him. As a rule, Maximillo would only cook for men, as he himself was a man's man who had a "large passionate appetite for everything important in a man's life: caiman hunting, deep-sea fishing, great sex, and, of course, great food" (p 57). As a bonding experience, Jose Raul and his grandfather prepare a meal for the men. While in the kitchen, Grandpa Maximillo tries to explain to Jose Rail about the "ahhh moment" in one's life and how it can change your entire view of the world. "sometimes a sentence goes beyond just being clear. It becomes radiant. It illuminates your life. It may even change your life for good. And when that happens, that is poetry. That experience. That moment in your life" (p 61). This story is at a personal level for readers because it describes an event in every person's life: the point where both yourself and your parents recognize you as an adult. The reader will enjoy this book not only for the interesting and humorous stories, but also because he will be able to relate to the stories.

Family; American Writers Remember Their Own book review
This book portrays a lot about life through different writers perspectives. Containing sixteen different stories all by different authors, this book helps inspire young writers to dig into their own lives. After reading the book I have gained knowledge on how to write a more interesting and descriptive non-fiction paper. Each individual story is written from a different viewpoint: Grandpa's, mother;s, Sons, even the cats. It is amazing to see all the different types of viewpoints their really are.
My favorite two stories were Happy Blue Crabs by Jose Raul Bernardo, and Sympathy by Stuart Dybek. I liked Sympathy because it shows that many people can be misunderstood. Sometimes it takes the youngest relative to get in touch with a persons emotions to find out the real mystery behind them. Happy Blue Crabs was a great story because it brings back the importance of family traditions and secrets. It was really cute that very strict Maximilano let his grandson in on something that everyone always wonders about.
This book is great to share with your family or friends and I would highly recommend it to anyone. It will help writers to get inspired but can also be a great path down memory lane to some others.

For Inspiring Writers
When I first began to read this book, I thought of all the sweet memories these authors were having for their family. However, as I delved into the book, I realized it contained a more valuable resource. Each of these authors has a different writing style that conveys their thoughts in the best of ways. This is especially true with Alice Hoffman's "Advice from my Mother." She does not write in complete sentences, but instead, she writes whatever pops out of her mind at the time. It is unique, yet understandable. It is a very effective way to tell a story. Another story that I found very interesting was Jose Raul Bernardo's "Happy Blue Crabs." This author remembers the first time he cooked with his grandfather. The family is Cuban, and therefore Jose writes a few words in Spanish and informs his audience of how to pronounce them. This fond memory makes the reader feel exactly how Jose felt at the time, yet does not confuse them with the different language. These are just a few stories in the book that have a creative touch to them. Through this book, I have discovered new ways to write stories, but still sound interesting. I suggest this book to anyone interested in seeing different writing techniques, or even if you are just in the mood for touching family stories.


Horse Heaven
Published in Paperback by Thorndike Pr (Largeprint) (2001)
Author: Jane Smiley
Amazon base price: $29.95
Used price: $16.81
Buy one from zShops for: $36.87
Average review score:

Justa book? No -- an epic!
I can't remember the last time I read a book that began with a two-page list of characters! But, at 561 pages of prose, in small type, some readers might feel the need to refer back to that list, from time to time. I admit to being intimidated, at first, but as I got deeper into the multiple story lines, I just decided to relax and enjoy the delightful atmosphere Jane Smiley was creating.

Eileen is a dog that loves her mistress and deliberately makes life hellish for her master (urinating in his best shoes is only one of Eileen's little tricks). But the best characters in the book, I think, are the horses. From the viewpoint of Justa Bob, Froney's Sis, Limitless, Epic Steam, and the other Thoroughbreds, humans exist to keep them supplied with hay & oats. Many of the horses have genuine affection for their trainers and handlers, and some, like Mr. T., reward those humans they like best by passing on racing tips much more valuable than those found in the Daily Racing Form. By the end of the book, I was praying that Justa Bob would be rescued from the glue factory and Residual would recover and be put out to pasture. You'll fall in love with these animals, believe me.

Smiley's central human characters will hold your interest, too. For example, she made me genuinely care whether Al and Rozzy's marriage would recover from the strain of the separate lives they were leading. However, some of the peripheral ones could have been edited out with no loss to the book's coherence. Overall, this book gave me enormous pleasure.

Finally -- a horse book for adults!
This book was a great "read" and I had trouble putting it down -- I frequently found myself tempted to ride the subway past my stop, just so I could keep reading!

Books with a list of characters at the beginning usually worry me -- I hate stories with so many poorly-defined characters that such a list becomes necessary. Even with Horse Heaven's impressive length, however, I think I only referred to the list of characters once or twice. It was great to be able to follow the story from the points of view of the many characters, not the least of which were the horses, whom the author imbued with a wonderful mixture of self-determination, insight and even humor. Smiley's equine characters also exercised a surprising amount of control over their own destiny in an industry in which what's best for the horse often can be overlooked.

That said, I agree with another reviewer's comment that a bolder editor might have tightened Horse Heaven up. Occasionally while reading, I found myself wondering whether I would be turning the pages so quickly if the backdrop for the stories had been, say, stock car racing instead of horse racing. (I say this because I am a shameless "plot-hound," so long passages of description -- however well-written -- without a reasonable amount of plot development tend to bore me.) Without the inclusion of horses, I believe I would have been enjoyed reading the book somewhat less. For this reason, I am having a hard time recommending this book to my friends and family members who aren't as nutty about horses as I am.

All in all, though, I thoroughly enjoyed this book, and was sorry to reach the last page.

heaven for a horse lover
admittedly, before i read this book, i was both a jane smiley fan AND a life-long horse owner/lover, so this book came out of the gate with pretty good odds. because of the numerous characters, human, equine, and canine, the start was a little tough, but once i'd found my rhythm and figured out who all the characters were, i didn't want to get to the finish line. the horses were far better developed as characters than were the people (--justa bob was my favourite!--), but i think even a non-horse lover could find this book to be quite entertaining. as it's making the rounds of barns in my "neigh"borhood, we're all applauding smiley's ability to capture a world that only those who live in it seem to know. i'd enthusiastically recommend this to horse lovers and to others who are interested in that world.


A Thousand Acres
Published in Paperback by Ivy Books (1992)
Author: Jane Smiley
Amazon base price: $5.99
Used price: $1.06
Collectible price: $5.81
Average review score:

Enjoyable but Flawed
The Beautiful way Jane Smiley describes a midwestern farm was excellent and in my opinion the best part of the book. There are a few flaws with the plot and characters, but if you can overlook them this is an enjoyable read.

The main plot involving Larry Cook giving the land to his daughters and later fighting them in court to get it back was intriguing, however I felt the sexual abuse turned this into a bad TV movie of the week. It would have been more interesting if Ms. Smiley would have the more with the issue of the well water causing Rose's cancer and Ginny's miscarriages, which would have tied right in with the main plot of the land tearing this family apart and explained why Jess was always there.

The problem with the characters is that you can never figure any of them out. Ginny didn't seem like the type to commit adultry or attempt murder, yet she did both. I never understood how Rose could help with her father's care and still carry such hatred for him. And why Ty became so cold to Ginny after the problems with her father started is still baffling me.

I recommend this book to anyone who can forgive some flaws because it is enjoyable especially if you love to read descrptions written well.

A Thousand Acres By Jane Smiley
I highly recommend this book to anyone who is up for a twisted story jam packed with disturbing conflicts and emotionally distraught characters. This tale is about a well-known farmer, Larry Cook, who hands his 1000-acre farm down to his two daughters Ginny and Rose. In his original arrangement he was planning on distributing his land to all three of his daughters, but the youngest of the three was cut from the deal because of her lack of enthusiasm towards this generous offer. While the two oldest daughters and their husbands suffered through the trials and tribulations of the farming life, Larry Cook was deteriorating into a pathetic drunk. Throughout this novel Jane Smiley does a superb job of realistically describing the tragic incidents and past family problems that were stirred up during Ginny and Roses ownership of this land.
There are some minor flaws included in this book, such as the unnecessary reference to the past at the beginning of each chapter, but if you can look past them this a great read for anyone who can relate to family problems. I also want to notify anyone who is thinking about reading this book that there are many disturbing conflicts and harsh words used in each confrontation to add realism to the story. This complex book has enlightened me and helped me realize that any thing is possible, and I'm sure if you choose to read this novel it will have an impact on you also.

This novel makes me grateful that Jane Smiley exists
Jane Smiley's greatest gift, in my opinion, is her ability to create characters that we've all met. In her short story, "The Pleasure of Her Company," the protagonist is an over-eager and slightly annoying woman who does things that make the reader cringe, not in disgust, but in sympathy. In her novella "Good Will," Smiley carefully describes an idyllic life that the protagonists holds so dear, and does away with it almost thoughtlessly. Smiley gets inside tragedy like nobody I've ever read. At the precise moment when I begin to care about a character or place, she destroys that character or place. A THOUSAND ACRES is no exception. None of her main characters are "character," overly colorful archetypes. They're real, and we don't get to know them in a few glib chapters. It's a slow and almost painful process. This book isn't extraordinary because of Jane Smiley's faultless grasp on incest, or on sisters, or on illness. Those are reasons to read it, but not to love it. This is a brilliant novel because asoon as you realize how much her characters and all of their quirks mean to you, Jane Smiley devastates them. She has the courage to ruin such beauty, and creates a greater beauty in doing so


Moo
Published in Paperback by Ballantine Books (Trd Pap) (1996)
Author: Jane Smiley
Amazon base price: $11.20
List price: $14.00 (that's 20% off!)
Used price: $0.01
Collectible price: $0.99
Buy one from zShops for: $1.48
Average review score:

Good but not great
Smiley has written a good but not great academic novel. Moo bears some disturbing parallels to David Lodge's much better academic trilogy (Changing Places, Small World and Nice Work)---Lodge's work was written earlier and is frankly much better.
The characters, setting and plot should be familiar to anyone who has spent time in a university (the newly minted professor struggling to get a grip, the jaded older faculty, the endless and pointless committee meetings, the tensions between administrators and faculty and so on). The one fairly original aspect of Moo is Smiley's inclusion of undergraduate characters who are usually completely ignored in academic novels. Mary, an 18 yr old urban African American freshman put down in the middle of the cornfields is one of Smiley's best characters and I read the novel looking for her (alas, she is not a central character).
For Smiley fans (and I am one), the book is a disappointment (it can't compare to her fantastic epic, The Greenlanders) and for those who love academic novels, the book is only mildly good.

A true-to-life college campus

Don't be fooled by the title of the book; a pig named Earl Butz (ring any bells?)--is the literal and physical focus of this book. Earl is stowed away in the geographic center of the campus, Moo University, and those moving around him (students, faculty, etc), oblivious to his existence, nevertheless move in rhythm to him. When Earl escapes during the demolition of his home and dies, the campus is so affected that his picture on the front page of the newspaper affects everyone's life.

Everyone will recognize some familiar characters in this book. There are the four freshman girls living together--Mary, Keri, Sherri and Dianne--each of whom is drastically different, but borrows the others' clothes anyway. Then there's Bob Carlson, who doesn't know how to socialize with anyone but Earl Butz. Gary has a crush on his roommate's girlfriend and eavesdrops whenever they fight. English professor Tim can't keep his attention focused on any one woman long enough to establish a real relationship. The secretary to the Provost doesn't hide the fact that she controls EVERYTHING on campus and off, including her girlfriend Martha. Economics professor Lionel Gift believes he's God's gift to Costa Rica, as well as the rest of the world, often dropping the fact that he's in "some Rolodex" at the New York Times to impress people. One farmer, a frequent visitor to the provost, believes the FBI, the CIA and the big ag companies are out to get him, so he wears a bulletproof vest to protect himself.

These characters, weaved in and out of each other's lives, bring a rural campus to life with scandal, betrayal, but most of all, humor. Though Moo's huge cast can be confusing at times, it's a must-read for anyone in or graduated from college that never fails to bring a smile to your face.

Hilarious and satirical
How can the same author who wrote Thousand Acres flip into the voice behind Moo?? What a phenomenal talent...
Moo is a tour de force of satire on life at an agricultural university (known as Moo U., in the parlance) that scathingly leaves no cow pie unkicked. Smiley uses the hypocrisy, prejudice, and self-importance of the characters as a metaphor for our entire society. No one who reads this outrageous novel will ever forget Earl Butz, the Herculean pig that becomes such an obsession for more than one of the quirky characters that sometimes teeter on the edge of caricature. That quality and the fact that the whole charade seemed to go on about 100 pages too long is the only reason for 4 stars instead of 5.
A great book, nontheless.


Good Faith
Published in Audio Cassette by Recorded Books Unabridged (2003)
Author: Jane Smiley
Amazon base price: $24.49
List price: $34.99 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $12.00
Buy one from zShops for: $23.50
Average review score:

No smiles from Smiley
I bought this book based on an enthusiastic review in the Wall Street Journal, a paper I trust, and because I had heard of Smiley's previous well known works. But Good Faith was a huge disappointment. It dragged along for literally hundreds of pages before she brought us to the true dramatic crisis; what led up to that crisis was B-O-R-I-N-G. Even when we finally get to the "crisis," it seems like no big deal, and is resolved undramatically and quickly. The main character, Joe, also has little depth and spends no time contemplating the morality (or lack thereof) of his affair with a married woman. This book only deserves two stars because Smiley's writing ( as opposed to story-telling) is so good. I may try "Moo," but I'll get it from the library this time.

real estate and sex, what a combination!
Good Faith is the new novel by Pulitzer Prize winning author Jane Smiley (A Thousand Acres). Thus far, ever novel I have read by Jane Smiley (four) has been very good. Good Faith is no exception. Good Faith is set in the 1980's during an economic high point. Joe Stratford is a realtor. He is described on the book jacket as the type of guy that everyone likes. He is friendly and good at his job. Stratford spends a lot of time working on putting together a sale of one very big, expensive property. At the same time, he is working with Marcus Burns, an ex-IRS agent who is always searching for a way to get rich quick and not have to pay taxes. Stratford gets involved in a scheme that Burns cooks up about a huge land development deal.

Good Faith is really about two things: real estate and sex. The real estate portion of the book has been mentioned. The sex has not. Stratford gets involved with an old friend, a married woman named Felicity. Even as his real estate career is heating up, so is his relationship with Felicity. She is a free spirit, though they are being very secretive about the relationship. Breaking up the routine of the real estate portions of the book, we are given some of the most well-written sex scenes that I've come across. They aren't lewd or overly graphic and while somewhat idealized they come across as very real. I'm not sure that any author of Smiley's caliber writes sex scenes this good.

After reading Good Faith I am reminded why I enjoy reading Smiley's work. She is a very good writer (Moo is probably my favorite of her books). Good Faith may not be up to the standard of some of her other books, but it is well above the standard of most other authors. Good Faith is worth checking out. I found it very interesting all the way through (despite the fact that it is about real estate) and very well written.

Well Written Story About Dubious People
I've had the pleasure of reading a number of Jane Smiley's novels and have often come away with a common reaction. I think she is a great storyteller and always finds a way to write a story that holds my interest. The one weakness or at least the one thing I don't like about most of Smiley's books is that she always fails to create appealing characters.

This time, our protagonist is a realtor named Joe Stratford. He's well-liked in the community but already has gone through one failed marriage and is sleeping with another man's wife who happens to be the daughter of one of his clients and business partners. Along the way, (perhaps a commentary on the vapid 1980's) our main character manages to snort coke with yet another love interest and be incredibly self-absorbed and gullible.

He happens to be the most likeable character. The most memorable character is Marcus Burns, who claims to be an ex-IRS agent and has a host of hare-brained, get-rich-quick schemes.

While I will refrain from giving away the story and ending, you end up getting a book that moves well, a plot that's interesting, but a story that contains a whole bunch of people that you wouldn't want as your friends.

Given all of the recent attention on accounting, and other business scandals, it's a timely look back on a decade when some of the country lost common sense principles, but it didn't leave me all the warm after reading the book.

In short, Smiley is a great writer who can get your attention and keep it. She is adept at writing about a host of different subjects, but I do hope she creates more positive characters in at least one of her books.


A Thousand Acres
Published in Hardcover by Random House Value Publishing (1994)
Author: Jane Smiley
Amazon base price: $5.99
Used price: $19.77
Buy one from zShops for: $28.72
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Related Subjects: Author Index Reviews Page 1 2 3

Reviews are from readers at Amazon.com. To add a review, follow the Amazon buy link above.