List price: $14.95 (that's 30% off!)
Collectible price: $14.96
Edward J. Duffel, Past Commander
TN. Sons of Union Vet. of Civil War
Used price: $14.82
Collectible price: $22.24
Used price: $14.35
Buy one from zShops for: $14.30
Used price: $2.04
Collectible price: $2.50
Used price: $0.95
Collectible price: $2.95
Buy one from zShops for: $3.49
Are you still hesitant on whether or not to read "The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes?" Well, I personally am not much of a mystery fan. In fact, some of my favorite books are "Watership Down," "The Hobbit," "A Wrinkle in Time" series, and "The Lost Years of Merlin" books. I also know that mystery books are either awful, by. But Sherlock Holmes and his cases have set the highest of standards for mysteries, which very few others have even come close to surpassing.
Through this great collection, I have come to greatly admire both Holmes's and Doyle's brilliance over and over again. No matter what genre you enjoy reading, this is a book for you!
Used price: $3.18
Collectible price: $3.97
Buy one from zShops for: $2.99
Many pastiches try to parody or reinvent the originals, but theses stories affectionately recapture the flavor and tone of the canon.
Adrian Conan Doyle is represented here as well, the adventure of "Arnsworth Castle" being simply a republication of "The Red Widow" from _Exploits_. (I disagree with the reviewer who thought the story was a "complete failure," but I also disagree with anthologist Green that it is the strongest of the younger Doyle's Holmes pastiches.)
The highlight of the collection is undoubtedly Denis O. Smith's "The Purple Hand." This is the first of Smith's Holmes tales (of which another -- "The Silver Buckle" -- appears in _The Mammoth Book of New Sherlock Holmes Adventures_); in general they are among the best pastiches in the short-story genre. (Smith has published them in three volumes under the title _The Chronicles of Sherlock Holmes_.)
Other high points include "The Tired Captain" and "The Green Empress," based on two unrecorded cases mentioned by Watson in the first paragraph of "The Naval Treaty." The latter of the two cases requires a brief explanation.
"The Green Empress" is the new title of the tale mentioned in a review below under the name "The Second Stain." Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, of course, wrote a story of that title as well, but the version he published does not match the description in "The Naval Treaty." Some Sherlockians (according to Green) also claim to find a reference to another "Second Stain" case in "The Yellow Face," though I do not happen to know the foundation of this claim. There would thus appear to have been at least two and perhaps three Holmes cases catalogued by Watson under the same name.
F.P. Cellie's tale fills in the details of the one mentioned in "The Naval Treaty." In 1967 it won a contest in South Africa under its original title of "The Second Stain," and its title has been altered for publication in the present volume. End of explanation.
Another highlight: this volume is the only one currently in print -- so far as I know -- in which Vincent Starrett's classic "The Unique _Hamlet_" is collected. In my own view this pastiche is somewhat overrated (being among other things ludicrously easy to solve), but at any rate it's a good one to have; at least it was one of the first, having been privately published in 1920.
And another point which may be of interest to Amazon shoppers: the larger and more recent collection _The Mammoth Book of New Sherlock Holmes Adventures_, edited by Michael Ashley (and with a foreword by Green), does not include _any_ overlap with the present volume. Owners of one may therefore feel safe in purchasing the other.
Used price: $28.00
Buy one from zShops for: $27.99
Used price: $5.90
Buy one from zShops for: $8.99
Every third story is an adaptation of a Conan Doyle story, so the quality of those stories is superb. When Meiser is left to her own devices in writing, she can produce very uneven work. "The Case of the Well Staged Murder" makes for satisfying listening, but "Professor Moriarty and the Diamond Jubilee" is quite contrived, and "New Years Eve in the Scilly Isles" is downright silly. A firebug is seen deserting a ship as it sails out of harbor. The Captain is radioed that the ship will probably go up in smoke at the stroke of twelve on New Years Eve. The lives of 2,000 passengers and crew hang in the balance. So does the Captain turn around and go back to port to unload the passengers and search for the time bombe? Nope. He sails on for 18 hours until he is far at sea and there is only an hour left until midnight. But Holmes arrives in a yacht just in the nick of time. This has my vote for the most contrived Holmes radio pastiche of all times.
John Stanley sounds more like Rathbone than Rathbone, and doesn't muff his lines as often. Alfred Shirley tries manfully, but he cannot quite convey the warmth of Bruce's Watson. The organ music is more subdued and not quite as annoying, but Meiser makes Holmes far too disagreeable. He is the rudest Holmes I have encountered, and very nearly the most conceited. I'm sure that on several occasions, the only thing that prevented Watson from inviting Holmes outside for fisticuffs was the fact that Holmes was an expert amateur boxer.
The 60 page booklet that comes with the collection is a gold mine of information for Holmes afficionados.
In 'The Adventure of the Sussex Vampire', Holmes says: "This Agency stands flat-footed upon the ground, and there it must remain. This world is big enough for us. No ghosts need apply." His willingness to accept supernatural possibilities in this book is solidly against this view.
The story itself, even ignoring these non-Holmesian views, is fairly simple and has some ludicrous aspects that were not well appreciated by me.
I also didn't like he sudden Christian homily added at the end of the story. While I have no doubt that Holmes and Watson are Christians, their religion has never been in focus in the stories, and it seemed grafted on - presumably either reflecting the faith of the author, or because of some endeavour to counterbalance the supernatural elements for some imagined religious group who might object to the supernatural tone.
I get the impression that this book was written for a younger audience (although it is not stated so anywhere I can see), but even so I don't think it is a good introduction to Holmes for young readers.
Holmes is called in to investigate the sighting a the ghost of a headless monk on an island, one of a pair of islands, the other of which contains a lighthouse, its keeper and his family. While legends of the ghost have been heard for some time, the effect of sighting the ghost on the lighthouse keeper's wife is extreme. Once they are there, Homes and Watson discover that there are a number of other events which must be understood to correctly resolve the mystery.
This story is an attempt to tell the tale of the politician, the lighthouse and the trained cormorant, mentioned in Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's 'The Adventure of the Veiled Lodger'. It fails to do so successfully as Kel Richards fails to address the fact that, in that story, Watson threatens to reveal that story due to attempts made to destroy his case papers, and that at least one reader would understand. I can't explain why not without detailing the story completely, but suffice to say it does not.