The alternative to Mao was the 'Generalissimo' Chiang Kai Shek. Seagrave does a good job of underlining the fact that almost anyone would have been preferable to Chiang. He also clearly shows that Mao was the only leader capable of mobilising and motivating the peasants into an army capable of defeating the Japanese. It truly is a shame how Mao allowed absolute power to subsequently corrupt him into the vile creature he was to become. Chiang's long history of needless brutal murder and his seedy connections with the Shanghai Triads is also quite well covered.
What this book is really about though is the remarkable influence 3 sisters had on the history of the sleeping giant which was China. The book also presents the striking contrast between the motivations of each sister. One lusting for power, the other lusting for money and the third who was a true chinese patriot.
One does develop a strong connection with the third sister's strength of character. It's difficult to imagine anyone being able to maintain such honest, good intentions when surrounded by such ugly greed. While Chinese people were being slaughtered by the invading hordes of Japanese the 'Generalissimo'& Co. were busy lining their pockets with money which they solicited from the US. Many US citzens would be interested to know just how much US money for the war effort was funelled via TV Soong into various investments throughout the world.
This is one of many books which depict the tragic story of China for much of the twentieth century. By concentrating on the lives of these sisters Seagrave makes the history of China come alive. A super read, very difficult to put down and very difficult to forget.
Sterling Seagrave rightly comes by his ability to dig behind the scenes on the subject matter of the book. He is an investigative journalist and was raised in the Orient. All of his books deal with oriental subjects and are written in an attractive manner which keeps the reader anxious to read more.
Used price: $22.00
After reading this, I had this strange period of looking at the world from the point of view of a castaway... "what is useful to me in this situation? What can be salvaged here?", which was interesting, to say the least. Any book that gives you a new way to think deserves 5 stars!
Used price: $2.99
Collectible price: $3.90
Buy one from zShops for: $9.95
You can tell that the author is an investigative journalist because of the straightforward, detailed account he gives. This book comes at you almost like the author had an ax to grind. I would have liked a bit more on the end - what happened after they left? Overall the book was enjoyable and worth the effort.
Used price: $5.85
Buy one from zShops for: $13.98
Unfortunately, the second part purports to analyze the overseas Chinese themselves in a contemporary context, and proceeds to do nothing of the sort. Seagrave instead selects a series of Southeast Asian countries and fries up steamy helpings of tabloidesque gossip about a wealthy or powerful figure who has lived there. Entertaining to be sure, but singularly unhelpful for those of us who naively believed the book might deliver what its subtitle promised. The chapter on Indonesia is particularly miffing, because it focuses on the events surrounding the fall of Sukarno and the rise of Suharto, neither of whom are even ethnic Chinese. The chapter on Taiwan is a lazy regurgitation of the author's previous "Soong Dynasty," which roots out various scandals of Chiang Kai-shek and his family. There is a bountiful load of fertilizer in this topic, but it is entirely unrelated to the issue of Taiwan's role as member of the overseas Chinese community or the immigrant character of its population.
When all the dirty laundry has been aired, Seagrave apparently runs out of space and dispenses with addressing his chosen subject altogether. Ultimately, no clear picture of the overseas Chinese emerges at all. This is a pity, because the book jumps out of the gate with a good deal of promise.
Brent Heinrich, Taipei
Used price: $5.50
Collectible price: $8.47
Used price: $9.95
That said, the Seagraves do not read Japanese and rely heavily on sources that do not either (e.g. books such as "Sheathing the Sword" and "Soldiers of the Sun"). So much of what they rely on is filtered. So, as serious scholarship goes, its all rubbish. But readable, tantalizing and entertaining rubbish. If even 20% of what they assert is true then the assertions are worth keeping in the back of one`s mind when looking at more traditional historical works.
Used price: $4.69
Collectible price: $7.41
Buy one from zShops for: $6.99
Used price: $9.00
Collectible price: $9.00
If this book sparks your interest, definitely try out an even better read--George Kerr's Formosa Betrayed. Kerr's book focuses on the early history of the Taiwan-China conflict: the turnover from Japanese Imperial rule, the subsequent and tumultuous Nationalist/KMT government, the 2-28 Incident and March Massacre, and the U.S.'s part throughout it all. Kerr's book is all-encompassing, but as regards the Soongs, it reminds you that beneath the glamour and wealth of people like the Soongs was the unscrupulous trading that bankrupted millions while feeding personal family fortunes. (Specifically look for allusions to T.V. Soong's influence on the then-impending economic collapse of Taiwan, and you'll never again be dazzled by the Soongs' bright lights and propaganda show.) Read it, not because you dare, but because you CAN.