Used price: $58.24
List price: $17.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $7.29
Collectible price: $8.99
Buy one from zShops for: $8.95
It is amusing to read disagreements of the Objectivist theory of concepts which are addressed and cleared up in the appendix. The appendix of the second edition of I to OE really is amazing. It is simply transcripts of round table discussions of professors who had read the original text presenting their questions and objections on finer points of epistemology. Rand was, apparently, at her intellectual pinnacle at this point, and any potentially hazy points are clarified beyond question.
The criticism that this is not presented in as scholarly a way as an epistemological monograph should be has its merits. The preface clearly states that main work is a reprint of a series of articles in which Rand presented her theory of concept formation. I certainly would have preferred a more scholastic presentation and a deeper exploration of the background of certain ideas, but this was Rand's style. She did not "write down" to her readers and her writing requires objective truth seekers to do their own research. I have, on multiple occasions, encountered the criticism that a reader was left wondering what Bertrand Russell was attempting to "perpetrate" in his theory of numbers. After encountering this passage I went to a philosophy text and read a passage describing Russell's theory of numbers as an attempt to create a purely logical language which would allow one to understand numbers without relating them to their perceptual referents. Since Rand demonstrates that concepts are valid within the context of the totality of human consciousness, and that abstractions must be derived primarily from their perceptual referents (numbers, specifically, are covered) which form their fundamental context, the dismissal of Russell stands.
For those who are familiar with Rand only from Atlas Shrugged and The Fountainhead, this is a fascinating opportunity to understand the underlying support of a novelist's reasoning process, rarely made this explicit.
The criticisms about this book are shoddy, to say the least. I usually don't comment on what others say, but this is too silly to pass up. "Scott Ryan" says that Rand's ideas hold the theory of a priori knowledge, but that is patently false. He also says that negation and necessity would be hard to deal with, but that is not obvious at all. Negation, for example, is part of logical operations on concepts, and its differentia is reversing (negating) said concept.
"A reader" says that we cannot use measurement-omission unless we know the concepts of length, colour, etc. But that is akin to saying that a baby needs to know what "identity" means before he acquires such. They are all perceptual characteristics which can be used implicitly.
Used price: $6.30
Collectible price: $4.75
As the title of my review suggests, the book is an excellent reference guide to Objectivist writings. However, the material provided is made up of quotes from other sources, rather than being an actual summary of Objectivist thought on the particular subject at hand. I mostly use my copy for quickly finding pithy quotes to use in papers or articles, or as a way to find where the original full-length essays are located if I can't immediately recall. Thus, it's my opinon that it is best used as an index to your pre-existing library of Objectivist books.
The book also suffers a little from its age, as it is limited almost exclusively to Ayn Rand's own writings. A second edition including material from newer Objectivist thinkers, such as Tibor Machan, would be both a benefit to Objectivists and serve to diffuse those critics who claim that the philosophy is the exclusive toy of Ayn Rand.
Used price: $17.49
Collectible price: $31.76
Used price: $2.23
Buy one from zShops for: $9.52
Each story seems to have this ever-present nerdy college guy theme to it. Between you and me dear reader, I haven't had much thought about my GPA or major or any other sort of thing a college student thinks about in nearly two decades, so I found the book to be a bit juvenile.
The author's highlighted short story, 'The Pianist Who Liked Ayn Rand' is reasonably entertaining. The character compares the novelist's writings in the story, 'The Fountainhead' to his dealings with the complex emotional need of the typical collegiate female. The main character takes lessons in manhood from reading Rand's interpretation of what the ideal man should be like.
In addition to this somewhat satirical look at young relationships, the author has a couple of vaguely entertaining essays included in the overall book. Of honorable mention was one that discussed the consequences of one man sporting a new mustache.
Unfortunately, the better stories are overshadowed by the inclusion of some tasteless or absurd creations. But again, it takes a certain type of wit to appreciate this type of writing and mine isn't one of them.
Although the book comes across as a fairly loose collection of unrelated stories and satirical essays, a unifying theme becomes clear as one reaches the last page. The common impulse towards the careless, oftentimes hapless, adoption of the seemingly new or sophisticated, and the resulting descent from what was initially mere self-delusion towards self-made hells is my view of the author's dark vision. It's a journey from a young boy's energetic innocence in the Dickey stories, of the first half of the book, towards the final description of an island society that has become too sophisticated to have any use whatsoever for human speech.
I feel grateful to the author for, what is for me, an auspicious introduction to Latino literature. Now I feel inspired to give Marquez a whirl.
Used price: $35.96
Collectible price: $42.35
Buy one from zShops for: $35.96
Used price: $10.51
Buy one from zShops for: $13.50
While for me, the great attraction was the beautiful quality of the reproductions which replicated the pure pure colours, the text is mostly in an interview format, and one gets to hear Hundertwasser's 'voice' - and from that his spirit. I found myself wondering at times, if it was solely his work, or his passion which made the legend of Hundertwasser. The artist has strong opinions about everything, from garden gnomes to his hatred for conventional and boring buildings. I found his concepts of 'tree tenents' (trees should live with us in apartments) and houses that should be indistinguishable from above (by growing grass roofs) fascinating. However, at the end of the day, it is his bold use of colour - vivid, vibrant, confrontational colour coupled with his enigmatic yet child-like imagery, which glows in my memory.