Used price: $5.60
Buy one from zShops for: $12.00
List price: $24.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $14.76
Buy one from zShops for: $17.29
List price: $14.00 (that's 20% off!)
Used price: $8.99
Buy one from zShops for: $9.73
Buy one from zShops for: $14.85
List price: $29.95 (that's 30% off!)
List price: $24.00 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $4.00
Collectible price: $20.00
Buy one from zShops for: $5.99
author did an excellent job of creating a real person with very human faults and weaknesses, but also incredible strengh. It
was a story and a character that I kept thinking of long after I had finished reading the book. I highly recommend it.
from childhood to old age-- the choices she made and the problems she had-- the effects of chance and fate.
She is the wild woman who drinks in bars, the suffering laborer and servant. She is a spiritualist right under the nose of the Virgin. She occupies a Mexico few tourists have ever seen, a terrain of wonder and terror and the shocks and blows of the unexpected events that make up her life.
Used price: $14.99
Buy one from zShops for: $21.70
The essays that are with these photographs are interesting and strangely poetic. At first I found the writing somewhat peculiar, then realized it's translated from the Spanish (by Aurora Camacho de Schmidt) in an almost literal manner...but once you get into the rhythm of it, is excellent.
This hardback edition seems bigger than 160 pages because of its weight, with good quality thick pages, it's a sturdy volume. This book is much more about color than it is about Mexico, and for those of us who love color, it's a satisfying volume.
Modotti was Edward Weston's most beautiful model. For a few years in the late 1920s, until she lost her nerve (or maybe her artistic sensibility), she was herself a photographer of note. Later she labored in the vineyard of the Communist revolution, first in Moscow and later in Spain during the Spanish Civil War.
Yet if Modotti -- if, indeed, anyone -- is a fitting subject for an imagined biography, it is not because she was a larger-than-life character. As Poniatowska tells it, throughout her brief 45 years Modotti, the daughter of poor immigrants to Northern California from Northern Italy's poorest region, held unwaveringly to anarcho-syndicalist views, empathized with the poor and the victims of war, and searched for love in all the wrong places. So far, nothing exceptional. What makes her life interesting, of course, was her involvement, albeit at the edges, of sea changes in photography and painting, politics, totalitarianism, and war.
The writing style veers from accomplished dialogue to flat narrative, with little insight to the characters' motivation, to magic views of the cosmos, to cinematic stream of consciousness, as during Tina's death scene. This is a decent vacation read, full of local color, but you may come away from "Tinisima" wondering what justifies the superlative in the title.
But it is dangerous. There is a rapture here that might exceed the small frame of the tormented subject. Perhaps the almost religious raptures with which Poniatowska paints the prose story are better suited for hagiography than the life of a mere mortal.
For me, the aching emptiness in the middle of Tina's life is precisely mortal. She was a pilgrem on a very earthbound path, who had lost sight of any supernatural calling early in her childhood, if in fact it ever was a motive. Tina took care of everyone, and still managed to be brilliantly selfish. She found a place for every ambition and passion she felt, except for the desire for a family of her own.
It is difficult to tell her story right now. The true extent of Stalin's monstrosity has been overshadowed for fifty years by Hitler and the holocaust. It is only within the last few years that the enormity of betrayal underlying the outcome of the Spanish Civil War has begun to be understood and discussed in fair proportion. In the context of over-politicizing the external circumstances of women in the century, and the failure to understand Stalinism, the true story of Modotti can barely be heard above the clamor of militant mythologies.
Even if Poniatowska errors on the side of a romantic, impossibly representative 20th century woman at the expense of the true, earth bound person, it is worth the trouble trying to keep things in perspective. This is wonderful writing, and wonderful writing always threatens to obscure its subject. Caveat Lector, but if you have any interest in any aspect of this story, read the book.
Once I began to read "TINISIMA", I became utterly captivated with the life of Tina Modotti. Elena Poniatowska has a way of making the narrative read as if Tina Modotti herself were relating various happenings from her life to the reader, while the author adds her own commentaries as a supplement.
The more I read of this novel, the more I found myself curious about this woman and her life. It got to the point that I could hardly tear myself away from finishing this novel, though it pained me to see how Miss Modotti was manipulated and abused both by some of her friends/compatriots and the Stalinist system she once served so faithfully. I believe it was a mistaken faith, but I respect Miss Modotti for the courage of her convictions. She had good intentions, a big heart, but was prone to blind herself to the evils of Stalinism. Therein lies the ultimate tragedy of her life.
Tina Modotti could have gone on to become one of the greatest photographers of the last century had she not threw herself wholly into Marxist/Stalinist politics. Perhaps it is for that reason that she is not widely known today.
I wish I could have known Tina Modotti. I would have loved to have had lots of conversations with her in some café or small restaurant. While I'm sure we would not agree on a number of issues, I like to think we would have become close friends.
Thank you, Elena Poniatowska, for a beautiful book.
List price: $19.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $9.75
Buy one from zShops for: $13.00
List price: $25.98 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $116.94
Buy one from zShops for: $103.96
What happened next? Poniatowska resigned her seat in NEXOS magazine -where González de Alba writes- and threatened to do the same thing to La Jornada, Mexico City's main leftist paper, unless they sacked him on the spot, which they promptly did.
So, all that talk about freedom and liberty and tolerance and stuff you read in the book has to be taken with a big grain of salt, since it seems the author can't even take one single comment, not to mention a critic!
OK, now for the content. Women, we will certainly identify with this book more than our male counterparts. Not because this is a "woman's book" which it is not. I always thought that was an ignorant term to begin with, but because most of the characters (both antagonist and protagonist) are female. This book deals with very strong themes of erotic love, evil, loss of innocence, and religious hypocrisy. All of that may sound 'juicy' but Arredondo has a way with words. Her writing is halfway between poetic prose and contains an eloquency beyond anything I have ever read in my short, yet hopefully long and fufilling life. Worth every penny.