Used price: $11.99
Collectible price: $25.00
Buy one from zShops for: $3.49
Used price: $4.50
Collectible price: $34.40
Buy one from zShops for: $17.98
Yet it's a masterpiece on a multiplicity of levels, and as Mahler once said of *his* more "difficult" work, "[Its] time will yet come."
I wouldn't recommend this to someone who has naver read Murdoch--but, if you've read and enjoyed *The Black Prince* or *The Sea, The Sea*, for instance, make this your next selection.
Used price: $1.95
Buy one from zShops for: $13.98
If you can keep yourself from shuddering while Pinn speaks to Monty in his bedroom, then you need serious mental attention.
Used price: $7.15
Collectible price: $8.47
List price: $13.95 (that's 20% off!)
Used price: $2.75
Collectible price: $5.29
Buy one from zShops for: $9.21
Some may find this approach a bit artificial and intellectual, but I felt that although the situations might be somewhat contrived, the character's responses and actions rang true. I found the book very readable, and it met my main criterion for a novel - it taught me something new about why people act the way they do.
List price: $13.00 (that's 20% off!)
Used price: $4.72
Collectible price: $6.87
Buy one from zShops for: $4.99
With the film (also starring Dame Judi Dench in the title role, and "Titanic" star Kate Winslet playing a younger version) now available for rental, it's a good time to also check out the book upon which the movie is based.
"Elegy for Iris" is Bayley's heart-rending memoir of his wife, celebrated novelist Iris Murdoch ("A Severed Head" and "The Bell" among them). It is the story of Bayley and Murdoch's romance, from their first meeting and the bookish Bayley's instant attraction to the girl on a bicycle.
Love seemed to bloom almost immediately, despite Bayley's lack of experience and Murdoch's plethora of suitors. In fact, Bayley tells us that years later he happened upon Murdoch's note for their first date: "St. Antony's Dance. Fell down the steps, and seem to have fallen in love with J. We didn't dance much."
At the same time, "Elegy" is also a tale of the modern John and Iris, as the celebrated novelist suffers from Alzheimer's disease, and her husband watches as her once brilliant mind falters.
But while the book will bring tears, it isn't really a tearjerker.
Bayley shares some of the personal, silly little jokes he tells Iris that at one time would not really have amused either of them, but which draw a favorable reaction from her now. And the way that one of his exasperated temper tantrums settles her nerves now more than coddling will.
While Bayley is at times frustrated, understandably so, he seems more enamored of his wife then ever. He marvels at the things she does, reflects on their shared past, they way her mind worked then contrasted with the way it worked as he wrote "Elegy" (Murdoch died in February).
At no time does Bayley seem to resent being saddled with his wife. In fact, he expresses distaste for the wife of another Alzheimer's patient when she comments that it is "like being chained to a corpse, isn't it?"
No, declares Bayley, and he goes to bat for his wife.
"I was repelled by the suggestion that Iris' affliction could have anything in common with that of this jolly woman's husband. She was a heroine, no doubt, but let her be a heroine in her own style. How could our cases be compared? Iris was Iris."
So says a testament to quiet strength, bravery and love.
Four years ago before this book was published, Alzheimer's began to chip away at acclaimed novelist Iris Murdoch and she started to lose memories, associations and connection with herself. Her husband of forty years, English critic John Bayley, has written a memoir about this escalating series of losses that is imbued with admiration, love, and gentle humor. Bayley compellingly interweaves descriptions of his wife's sad deterioration with stories of their courtship and long, contented marriage. What is remarkable about this narrative (which needed better editing, however), is that despite the very real tragedy of Alzheimer's, he is not bitter or self-pitying, and what links him and his wife now is anything but a chain.
Murdoch and Bayley seem to have given each other the freedom to live complete lives, however they needed to, and that freedom was a profound tie. "We were together because we were comforted and reassured by the solitariness each saw and was aware of in the other," he observes. And tracing their growing love for one another, he makes one envy the balance they found between separateness and companionship (which counterpoints their domestic squalor). From the earliest days onward, marriage and solitude were not contradictions for them. They could "be closely and physically entwined, and yet feel solitude's friendly presence, as warm and undesolating as contiguity itself."
All that reverberates strangely with the ways in which Murdoch now is shut off from him far more than she ever was as a creative artist, but seems to need the constant reassurance of his presence. She is like a child hungry for attention, but unable to communicate clearly, and sometimes needs to be gently shooed away so that he can have time to himself. Yet she returns, anxious, needful. Sometimes her confusions drive him into a rage, but she often responds to these outbursts with the same ameliorative calm she always had.
Given their long, happy marriage, Bayley and Murdoch's first meetings were comically inauspicious. In his late twenties and a graduate student teaching at Oxford after World War II, Bailey spied Murdoch bicycling past one day looking grumpy, grim, and not entirely attractive. Yet for Bailey, she was almost an apparition, a woman existing only in the moment--and for him alone. But his instantaneous fantasies were soon crushed when he met her at a party and realized she was merely another teacher. How ordinary! Worse still, she was clearly a popular and magnetic woman with many friends (and not a few lovers, he would learn). Though he tried, he never managed to make conversation with her that night, and when his next opportunity came at a dinner, he was daunted by the seriousness with which this philosophy teacher considered his most casual remarks.
On their first date he was oddly shocked by her brilliant red brocade dress which struck him as inappropriate for her, and she managed to fall down stairs as they entered a ball. But not much later they were laughing and sharing childhood confidences, and it's thanks to their childlike joy that the bonds between them were first knit, lasting even into her Alzheimer's. Rather miraculously, humor survives between them, even now that her memory has faded, leaving her incapable of finishing sentences and often lost in a state of "vacant despair." Bayley can still make Murdoch smile with silly jokes and rhymes. There's so much love (and quiet suffering) in Bayley's observation that a smile "transforms her face, bringing it back to what it was, and with an added glow that seems supernatural."
Murdoch's kindness, her affability, her lack of egotism about her career make for odd continuity with the generally sweet-natured woman she is under the spell of Alzheimer's, and Bayley's deep appreciation of these excellent qualities seems to undergird his current devotion. Time and again, the author makes the best of a bitter situation, and even finds aspects of it enjoyable. He manages, for instance, to find something delightful in regularly watching the British children's show "Teletubbies" with her. But all his fond memories and his loving attention to her in the present cannot veil the especial cruelty of watching a sharp-minded and fertile novelist "sail into the darkness," as Murdoch puts it herself in a moment of lucidity.
Among various literary subjects, Bayley has written about Henry James, and Elegy for Iris richly and warmly demonstrates a truth affirmed by a character in James's The Ambassadors: "The only safe thing is to give--it's what plays you least false."
Lev Raphael, author of LITTLE MISS EVIL, the 4th Nick Hoffman mystery.
List price: $14.00 (that's 20% off!)
Used price: $4.40
Collectible price: $6.50
Buy one from zShops for: $4.99
It was interseting that a female author would have a male protagonist and narrator. The hero, Jake Donahue, is a frustrated author turned interpretter of foreign novels. He is displaced from his residence by his landlady/lover and,in his attempt to find another place to live, he is reunited with an ex-lover and in the process is re-introduced to several other people from his past.
In the midst of Jake's search for his own self worth, he comes into contact with several intersting people in both the world of books and films. In one of the most light hearted episodes, Jake and his cronies, Dave and Finn, manage to kidnap a dog film star and Jake becomes the aging dog's protector. Through his protection of the dog, Jake uncovers in himself a gentler side that he did not know existed.
Whether Jake's misfortunes are due to betrayl by his friends or by his own stubborness and laziness is not quite clear. However at the end the reader has the sense that Jake is truly a better person for all his travails.
Such was the case with "Under the Net". This was my first Iris Murdoch novel, but by no means will it be my last.
She deftly creates empathy for our anti-hero, Jake, while making him less than sympathetic, drawing the reader into the story while at the same time keeping us far enough away that we can comfortably laugh at the proceedings. Murdoch also reveals her story slowly, layer by layer, turning what we believe will be little more than mild humor into a mystery of character assassination.
And it reads very much like a mystery, the kind that you just don't find anymore. But here it is not a dead body that is the victim, but rather a living, breathing one. But is he as much a victim as he likes to think he is? Our hero finds that nothing is as he believes it to be.
Is it ever?
List price: $15.00 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $1.25
Collectible price: $5.75
Buy one from zShops for: $4.50
I agree with the reviewer that said the novel was hard to get into....in fact, after falling asleep over the first section several times, I resorted to searching local libraries until I found the audio version of the novel on 16 cassetes! That got me into the story in a flash and then I was hooked....until I got to the numerous fantastical elements of what was already a marginally plausible plot.
I thoroughly enjoyed the story of Peter Mir and his quest for justice as well as friendship with Lucas' family and friends. I held out hope of Peter's success, but the story that resulted is very far from any I had in my head. I was left shaking my head in dismay.
One of the customer reviews refers to an interview with Iris Murdoch regarding her beginning-middle-ending philosophy of literature. I too would like to have a novel tied up better than many modern novels are, but the ending of this novel is so pat that I keep wondering how she ever got it by her editors. Unlike the customer review that said the ending made him/her feel satisfied, I found the ending so unsatisfying that it altered my overall review of what, until then, had been a delightful, if marginally believable, book to listen to.
It was very helpful to listen to the audio version with a wonderful British reader....just fabulous how the narrator did the voices and conveyed the story as though she knew the characters intimately.
I read the novel for a book club that is yet to meet. It will be interesting to see what this most critical group thinks of it. For my part, although I survived the experience, I would not recommend it except as an audio and, even then, only to a person who can accept a saccharin ending.
The going is slow initially- I was reminded of D.H. Lawrence's "Women in Love" because I just *didn't like those people*. I really didn't. I couldn't stand Joan, didn't like Bellamy, thought Harvey was vapid, and the Cliftonians unreal. I stuck around long enough to get to know them, and changed my attitude about some of them. I even became so involved that I was cheered by some of the mistakes being made right- especially when it came to the dog. I wanted to help correct things, and to influence people.
At times, I wondered who the novel was about. Was it Peter? Kind of- Peter transformed people, or so we assumed. (but did he?) Maybe it was the Cliftonians because they featured prominently? No, overall, events happened to them, but they didn't cause them. I thought for awhile that it was about Lucas, and in a way it was. Lucas was quite a force for "the family", even though he was so rarely present. The novel even starts with his absence. But how could a novel be about an absent person? It doesn't matter though- it is about any of them and all of them. The marriages may have been a contrivance, but they were nice, some made sense, and others leave us with a lot to wonder about.
Iris Murdoch is a wonderful writer, and weaves a beautiful web with unexpected moments. Even when I forget the action of a novel, I remember the feeling she left me with.
List price: $16.00 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $1.79
Collectible price: $7.80
Buy one from zShops for: $3.99
I do love the fantastic and the fairytale genre, a great vehicle for great ideas.
The book starts out well enough, laying out the marshy grounds and casting enough fog for three Gothic horror stories. I could almost hear the growls of the Hound Of the Baskervilles while the characters wonder across the bog. The dim epicenter of the story is the beautiful, mysterious and of course aristocratic Hannah. She seems to be voluntarily enduring confinement in the familial castle. Her past as well as the past of her household is murkier then the flood waters in the local stream. Sleeping Beauty is cited more than once. Naturally, almost every character in the book, male or female, obsesses with Hannah and even tries on the shining armor of the rescuer prince. In other words, they all try to resuscitate her to normal life.
So far so good. Then the violent denouement comes and all of a sudden we have more corpses then a Shakesperean tragedy. The dialogue becomes less and less credible and while Shakespearean deaths are written in soul-shattering verse, Dame Iris succeeds in re-enacting the atmosphere of a daytime soap opera. I know the comparison is unfair, the gap is too wide between the tragic and melodramatic but I couldn't help myself.
Overall, an unsatisfying experience, a story unworthy of her otherwise eloquent voice.
The Italian Girl tells the story of an unhappy family on the eve of the death of the family matriarch. The characters include a spartan typesetter, two witchy Russian siblings, a disappointed housewife, and (of course) the Italian Girl.
I don't find this novel to be one of her strongest (not compared to books like The Bell or The Sandcastle) but then again, I can't imagine a book of hers that isn't worth reading.