Related Subjects: Author Index Reviews Page 1 2
Book reviews for "Lonnrot,_Elias" sorted by average review score:

The Kalevala: Poems of the Kaleva District
Published in Textbook Binding by Harvard Univ Pr (1963)
Authors: Francis P. Magoun Jr. and Elias Lonnrot
Amazon base price: $25.00
Used price: $19.95
Average review score:

Ian Myles Slater on "Prose, but Enjoyable and Useful"
"Kalevala," variously translated as "Kaleva District" or "Land of Heroes," is a nineteenth-century compilation, revision, and expansion of narratives, spells and charms, and proverbial wisdom collected from the Finnish-speaking peasants and fisherman of areas of modern Finland and Russia. It is made up largely, but not entirely, of "runos," narrative songs when even then survived in isolated, "fringe" areas; ballads with clear connections with other cultures also make an appearance. The material is, for the most part, clearly pagan in origin, with hints of roots in the Viking Age, if not earlier, but processed through centuries of Christianity, Catholic and Lutheran in Finland proper, Russian Orthodox in the Karelia district. Fortunately, Elias Lonnrot, the main collector, and the man responsible for this literary version, was also engaged in laying the foundations of the scientific study of folk traditions, and the collections he made or sponsored formed the basis of a major archive, the publication of which was only recently completed. In the meantime, his popularization had become a part of the world's culture, as well as that of Finland.

The contents are various, but the main themes are the military and romantic adventures and misadventures of a handful of warrior-magicians, as quite with an incantation as with a sword. Vainamoinen, "the Eternal Sage," and a kind of demiurge who sings the Finnish homeland into being, is born old, and his attempts to find a wife lead to the creation of the mysterious and wonderful "Sampo" by the smith Ilmarinen, as a kind of bride-price. These two great heroes share the stage with the irresponsible Lemminkainen, a kind of combined Don Juan and Achilles, and the hapless Kullervo. His story, presented as a cantata by Sibelius, is one of the underpinnings of Tolkien's "Silmarillion." (When the latter first appeared, it seemed obvious that the Quest for the Sampo, and its ultimate fate, was a major inspiration for Tolkien; publication of his early versions show that most of the resemblances emerged over time, in the course of endless reworkings.)

The tireless Lonnrot's literary version went through two major versions, the "Old Kalevala," which has been translated into English once, by Francis P. Magoun, Jr., in 1969, and the "New" Kalevala. Not counting abridged versions and retellings, this was first translated into English, by way of an 1852 German translation, in 1888. The epic was translated directly from Finnish, into imitative verse, in 1907, by W.F. Kirby, a version reprinted for decades in Everyman's Library, in which form it profoundly moved the young J.R.R. Tolkien; there have been several recent reprint editions. In the meantime, Longfellow, already acquainted with European versions, used it as a model for his "Hiawatha," importing a version of the Finnish meter for the purpose. Hence, in an historical paradox, Kirby's translation is often described as being in the "Hiawatha meter." Unfortunately, it seems to work better in Finnish than English.

Neither of these versions was satisfactory for serious study, however, and "Kalevala" is important as, variously, an example of: nineteenth-century romanticism; European nationalist literature; ethnography; folklore; oral epic literature; and, not least, a really good story. To fill at least some of these lacks, Magoun, a leading authority on early Germanic and other medieval literature, prepared a prose translation, published in 1963. It is set out in lines corresponding to the Finnish verses, together with a selection of the early secondary literature (introductions and essays), and a useful apparatus of glossaries, lists of charms, etc. He summarizes modern views, meaning the scholarship of the 1950s. Later printings contain several pages of Corrigenda (corrections and improvements) which originally appeared in his 1969 translation of the "Old Kalevala." (Note: the verses are set out as long lines, with a caesura, not as the couplets, used in most, but not all, Finnish editions; the result looks more like "Beowulf" than Longfellow.)

Although Magoun's translations are quite readable, neither volume is notable for its charm. Sober utility of presentation is the main note, with the main concession being translations of many of the opaque-looking, but meaningful names (Finnish originals in the apparatus, of course). Kirby, despite many failings, was often pleasant to read. (Tolkien, who had been inspired by it to study Finnish, thought that Kirby's version of the rollicking "Creation of Beer" episode was funnier than the original.) There have been two later translations of the "New Kalevala" into English verse, by Eino Friberg (1988) and Keith Bosley (1989), which many will find more appealing. Bosley has also translated a selection of the "Kanteletar," Lonnrot's collection of songs, ballads, and spells, (portions of which also appear in "Kalevala"), and was one of the translators of a volume of the actual songs as collected. But for those who want both the story and all of the details, and either don't care about, or don't care for, such things as meter and rhyme, Magoun's translation remains a first choice. For those who know the epic through other translations, it is still worth consulting. I hold it in high regard.


The Kalevala
Published in Paperback by Oxford Univ Pr (1999)
Authors: Elias Lonnrot, Keith Bosley, and Albert B. Lord
Amazon base price: $10.47
List price: $14.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $9.32
Buy one from zShops for: $9.82
Average review score:

Ian Myles Slater on A Reliable Version in Paperback
This is a welcome paperback incarnation of a solid, reliable, standard translation, originally published four decades ago. I have reviewed the hardcover edition of this translation, and of the similar rendering of the epic's first version, "The Old Kalevala," and will summarize my views here.

"Kalevala," variously translated as "Kaleva District" or "Land of Heroes," is a nineteenth-century compilation, revision, and expansion of narratives, spells and charms, and proverbial wisdom collected from the Finnish-speaking peasants and fisherman of areas of modern Finland and Russia. It is made up largely, but not entirely, of "runos," narrative songs when even then survived in isolated, "fringe" areas; ballads with clear connections with other cultures also make an appearance. The material is, for the most part, clearly pagan in origin, with hints of roots in the Viking Age, if not earlier, but processed through centuries of Christianity, Catholic and Lutheran in Finland proper, Russian Orthodox in the Karelia district. Fortunately, Elias Lonnrot, the main collector, and the man responsible for this literary version, was also engaged in laying the foundations of the scientific study of folk traditions, and the collections he made or sponsored formed the basis of a major archive, the publication of which was only recently completed. In the meantime, his popularization had become a part of the world's culture, as well as that of Finland.

The contents are various, but the main themes are the military and romantic adventures and misadventures of a handful of warrior-magicians, as quite with an incantation as with a sword. Vainamoinen, "the Eternal Sage," and a kind of demiurge who sings the Finnish homeland into being, is born old, and his attempts to find a wife lead to the creation of the mysterious and wonderful "Sampo" by the smith Ilmarinen, as a kind of bride-price. These two great heroes share the stage with the irresponsible Lemminkainen, a kind of combined Don Juan and Achilles, and the hapless Kullervo. His story, presented as a cantata by Sibelius, is one of the underpinnings of Tolkien's "Silmarillion." (When the latter first appeared, it seemed obvious that the Quest for the Sampo, and its ultimate fate, was a major inspiration for Tolkien; publication of his early versions show that most of the resemblances emerged over time, in the course of endless reworkings.)

There have been a number of abridged or retold versions of "The Kalevala" in English, and two early complete versions in verse, by Crawford (from a German translation; available on-line), and the Kirby translation (Tolkien's introduction to the work). Magoun's translation filled a need for a more literal treatment, with more supporting information. There have been two later translations of the "New Kalevala" into English verse, by Eino Friberg (1988) and Keith Bosley (1989), which many will find more appealing. But for those who want both the story and all of the details, and either don't care about, or don't care for, such things as meter and rhyme, Magoun's translation remains a first choice. For those who know the epic through other translations, it is still worth consulting. I hold it in high regard.

Shamanic Epic of the North
The Kalevala is one of the greatest (and yet largely unknown) epic poems of all times. Although relatively young when compared to the works of Homer and so forth, this Finnish epic draws deep into Finland's Shamanic heritage and is indeed based off these old myths and legends. It concerns the adventures of Vainamoinen the wise Shaman, his companion Ilmarinen the smith and the bold, young Lemminkainen. Those who have studied Shamanism will already see a Shamanic aspect in the association between Vainamoien and Ilmarinen, for in many cultures smiths and Shamans are linked together. There are many more Shamanic archetypes and beliefs found throughout this book, such as a bear sacrifice which is startlingly similar to that observed amongst the Ainu and Lapps of recent times. This book, perhaps the only real direct source of Finnish mythology and religion, explores an oft neglected culture. After all, any school child can tell you of the myths of the Greeks, Romans or Germanic peoples, yet the mythology and heroes of Finland have remained largely unknown. A real pity as this epic is filled with deciet, trechery and heroism which easily could stand beside the works of Homer, Virgil or Valmiki. This translation, perhaps the best available, both for the price and in terms of being generally accessable, is certainly worth owning. Whether you are interested in mythology, history, anthropology, Finland or just like a good story, there is bound to be something in this book which appeals to you.

The Finnish Illiad
This sister to the Norse Sagas is the masterwork of Finnish mythology.

In it we follow the three main heroes - the elderly Vainamoinen, wise in everything except love; his brother Ilmarinen, the presumably middle-aged master smith; and Lemminkainen, the reckless young lothario who causes his wife and mother endless headaches but who we like enough anyway that we worry about him when he gets into trouble.

In some ways, it's a product of it's time. This was written in a time when women had no say in who they married; they had no recourse if their husbands were abusive; and they were virtually their mother-in-law's slaves until their younger brother-in-laws or sons got married and they weren't the low women on the totem pole anymore. Althoug Aino's story offers a message about this system, it's pretty much accepted. This is what life was really like at the time these stories were sung.

In other ways, though, it's surprisingly modern. Although the results usually aren't so serious, we've almost all been taken down a peg by an elder like Joukahainen at some point in our lives when we've needed it. I would imagine that many widowers - and widows, for that matter - can relate to Ilmarinen's sense of loss when he loses his wife.

And then there's Kullervo. He wins the all-time teen angst award hands down. It's fascinating how his cycle deals with a question psychologists have grappled with for centuries - are kids taught to be good, or are they just born good or bad? He's a danger to society, yes - but he may also never have had a chance. No matter what you feel about what he does, the scene where he wanders pitifully among his family asking if anyone would cry if he died until he gets what he needs to hear from his mother, can move you to tears. Just read the headlines about the latest school shooting. There really are kids almost this messed up out there.


Elias Lonnrot's "Kalevala": A Study Guide from Gale's "Epics for Students"
Published in Digital by The Gale Group (23 July, 2002)
Amazon base price: $3.95
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Elias Lënnrot : zhizn§ i tvorchestvo
Published in Unknown Binding by Izd-vo "Kareliëiìa" ()
Author: E. G. Karkhu
Amazon base price: $
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Elias Lönnrot : monitietäjä
Published in Unknown Binding by Suomalaisen kirjallisuuden seura ()
Author: Raija Majamaa
Amazon base price: $
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Elias Lönnrot and his Kalevala : a selective annotated bibliography with an introduction to the national epic of Finland
Published in Unknown Binding by Library of Congress ()
Author: Elemer Bako
Amazon base price: $
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Kalevala
Published in Unknown Binding by Våaònåi Prakåaâsana ()
Author: Elias Lönnrot
Amazon base price: $
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Karel§skaia narodnaia ballada i "Kanteletar" Eliasa Lennrota
Published in Unknown Binding by Karel§skiæi nauch. ëtìsentr RAN ()
Author: R. P. Remshueva
Amazon base price: $
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Kirjoitelmia ja lausumia
Published in Unknown Binding by Suomalaisen Kirjallisuuden Seura ()
Author: Elias Lönnrot
Amazon base price: $
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Kolme näkijää ja tekijää : Lönnrot, Runeberg, Snellman ja Suomen suunta
Published in Unknown Binding by Gummerus ()
Author: Reijo Wilenius
Amazon base price: $
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Related Subjects: Author Index Reviews Page 1 2

Reviews are from readers at Amazon.com. To add a review, follow the Amazon buy link above.