List price: $14.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $1.48
Collectible price: $1.45
Buy one from zShops for: $6.50
Used price: $24.50
_The Hidden Library_ discusses many of these, largely as expressed through Lee's novels rather than her copious short stories. Since many of these novels are now out of print, Mavis Haut thoughtfully summarizes them before proffering analyses. Some of the summaries are a bit confusing-- not too surprising in view of the twists and turns which Lee's plots can undergo-- but generally there's enough information to understand the discussions that follow: recurring symbolism, mythological roots, the significance of names, structural parallels, and so on.
Truthfully, while I enjoyed the book and found that it offered some insights that would've never occurred to me, I still have to consider it a bit slim for the price. However, the book also contains a lengthy interview with Lee, as well as information about forthcoming books in the "Flat Earth" and "Blood Opera" series; these features are, as far as I know, available nowhere else.
In conclusion, while I can recommend this book for Lee fans, I must do so with mild reservations. True completists may have fewer quibbles with it than I do, as one of my frustrations with the book was being intrigued by summaries of novels which are now out of print and nearly impossible to acquire, except at rates even higher than for this book.
Used price: $0.94
Collectible price: $0.94
Used price: $0.99
Collectible price: $8.75
It's distinguishing characteristic is that the world it's set in is very different than typical fantasy-ie; not medeival European, but something else, not-of-this-world. The book's only weakness is also that-it's a partly created world where there are gaps in teh world-creation.
Used price: $2.97
Collectible price: $12.00
Buy one from zShops for: $2.98
Still, among recent "serious" novels about the French Revolution, Gods is a more entertaining read than Marge Piercy's City of Darkness, City of Light; but it can't hold a candle to Hilary Mantel's brilliant A Place of Greater Safety, another biographical novel about Camille Desmoulins which I think Lee must have read and, consciously or unconsciously, emulated (she makes the same minor errors of fact in one or two places).
(Postscript: Frankly, I wonder how any "literary" reviewer could take this novel quite seriously when faced with the author's absurd jacket photo, a decade or two old at least--Lee looks about nineteen--and featuring in-your-face cleavage and raccoonish goth eyeliner. Definitely a photo for one of her (quite wonderful) works of dark fantasy, but not for mainstream, hardcover fiction. Big, big mistake, Tanith.)
It is, however, an enthralling read.
Told in fragments, songs and doggerels, alternating between the first and third person (which some may find confusing), accounts, she tells of the French revolution, from the idea, the catalyst and the overwhelming bloodtide that inevitably followed a flawed idealism.
It's deftly and passionately written -an evident labour of love, but at times so convulous (spelling?) it leaves one head-scratching over her meaning.
Still, whether an old fan or just someone in search of a good read, give it a try -you may be surprised.
I think my own interest in this novel was actually dampened by the fact that Lee had to work with historical figures. Her own creations are usually more alien, perverse and aesthetically pleasing than Robespierre could ever be.
Used price: $0.25
Collectible price: $2.00
If there is a plot in there honest I just couldn't find it. The main character does NOTHING. She whines, she complains, she let's events sweep her along, . . .but she has no impact and never even tries to. Honestly I wanted to reach through the page and smack her. "Heroine of the World" ??? I have to assume that was ment irronically.
If you're looking for an action-packed, sword-weilding, Conanesque adventure (not that there's anything wrong with that--I like my Conanesques just fine), this is the wrong book.
If you're looking for a compelling, sweeping epic with grand vistas, politics, intrigue, and beautiful writing, this is the right book.
This book, set in almost-19th century Russia, has stayed with me for 7 years, and I must say that it's one of the best fantasies I've ever read despite--or maybe even because of--its different focus and scope.
There are few books out there that I really wish that I have written. This is one of them.
List price: $14.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $19.51
Collectible price: $26.47
I get the feeling that Tanith Lee is getting lazy with her novels. They're not as tight as they usually are; all of her latest stuff seems half-hearted, a rough draft, not polished at all. Strange. Perhaps Lee needs to do something completely different for a while, or something, to get back in the swing of things.
Still, even with its problems, Lee's Darkness I is definitely worth reading. Her characters are, as usual, excellent, real, and completely different from any other. Lee's best qualities are her prose style, both lush and spare at the same time. Amazing. Her characters, as ever, are wonderfully drawn, remarkably different, unusual.
I just hope that when Tanith Lee writes again, she's rejeuvenated; I miss the tight writing and plots that I expect from her. I'm looking forward to another sterling book.
List price: $14.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $4.44
Buy one from zShops for: $3.99
Note that I could either be talking about the ancient tale of Demeter and Persephone, or about the fairy tale "Snow White." Tanith Lee weaves the two together masterfully in her novel, "White as Snow." As I read it, I kept reading a scene and then thinking, "Hey, WAIT a minute, that was the part where Demeter tries to make the little kid immortal", and so forth. It just fit incredibly well; the book followed both the myth and the fairy tale, making me realize just how much symbolism the two stories had in common in the first place. It is a testament to Lee's skill that after reading the book, I began to seriously wonder whether the fairy tale truly *is* a corrupted version of the myth, distorted through centuries. Whether there is any real connection, the world may never know--but Lee makes us believe there is.
And as I write this, I remember that in ancient times Demeter was associated with the mirror.
I deducted one star because I had trouble sympathizing with the characters; they seem emotionally cold throughout much of the book. It makes sense, given their traumatic pasts, but it doesn't make it any easier to relate to them.
Still, four solid stars for a richly archetypal neo-myth.
Like Terri Windling's series, I am always excited when I see a new Tanith Lee novel. I had just finished reading Wolf Tower (which is a wonderful book) and saw White as Snow was due out soon...I waited with much anticipation for the book's arrival and I am happy to say I wan't disappointed by Tanith Lee's retelling of Snow White. This is one of her many reworkings of this particular fairy tale, but what makes this one different is that it is also a powerful and ingenious parallel of the Persephone/Demeter myth. As usual, Lee's prose is gorgeous and the story is challenging and unpredictable. There are a lot of layers to this novel and it deserves to be read and reread so that one can savor the imagery and emotion that this book builds. I particularly liked the dark psychology of the book--the war between mother and daughter, the war fought within oneself, the war between the sexes...everything resonates in this book and scenes continue to echo in my mind. This book belongs on the shelf next to Deerskin,by Robin McKinley and The Armless Maiden, an anthology by Terri Windling, for it is a powerful novel dealing with the more common, darker emotions of humanity.
Used price: $6.00
Author Tanith Lee creates a fascinating world where magic treads just lightly enough to make history into something colorful and wonderful. Her richly drawn characters, especially Silvio and Beatrixa, with their doomed love, cannot help create reader sympathy and fascination. Lee's descriptions of her mythical Venice (Venus) ring true both for the Venice of our own history and for that of myth.
Readers looking for action and adventure will not find much of that here. Instead, A BED OF EARTH is a strange and doomed romance, a poem of people and souls, and a bit of philosophy.