Related Subjects: Author Index Reviews Page 1 2
Book reviews for "Israel,_Martin" sorted by average review score:

The Politics of Water in the Middle East: An Israeli Perspective on the Hydro-Political Aspects of the Conflict
Published in Hardcover by Palgrave Macmillan (1999)
Author: Martin Sherman
Amazon base price: $65.00
Used price: $25.00
Average review score:

Is water capable of extinghuishing the Middle East fire?
Hydrology is an aspect central to Arab - Israely conflict. This is one thing commonly ignored by Peace and Conflict scholars. The author suggests a valuable reminder of the water determinant in the political equation of the lengthy Middle East conflict. The book is highky actual in these days due to Israel goverment's effort to achieve peace deals with it's neighbours.


Robert Maxwell: Israel's Superspy: The Life and Murder of a Media Mogul
Published in Hardcover by Carroll & Graf (2002)
Authors: Martin Dillon and Gordon Thomas
Amazon base price: $18.90
List price: $27.00 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $18.50
Collectible price: $21.18
Buy one from zShops for: $17.67
Average review score:

Not a scholarly book but somewhat entertaining.
Authors continue to use material from by ostrovky, an agent who worked for the mossad and then wrote an unking book about them, inorder to portray the mossad. Including one of his most lurid claims about how This is a very slanted view. Shows 0 scholoraship. It includes some of the more fantastic claimes by ostrovksy.If I was interested in ostrovsky view, which is that of a traitor to the mossad, then I could read ostrovsky, but to continue to use ostrvosky material here to describe the mossad is ludicrous.This includes Ostrovsky statement that everyone in the mossad uses sex to advance. Aside from this I wonder how the author got all the info about how the mossad operated with Maxwell, including the details of meetings etc.. How can they know this information, without making up stuff. At no point do I get the feeling of scholarship in this work. This is somewhat of a pot boiler. You might enjoy this work of fiction or (non fiction) any way.

This, maybe, is more than the truth
I doubt if I will ever read another book about Robert Maxwell. This book has more information than a lot of people, presuming the innocence of just about everything, would want to cope with. Among the people listed as interviewees in the front of this book are Efraim ---, six other former members of Mossad, William Casey, and William Colby. The death of William Casey was famously reported in VEIL by Bob Woodward, published in 1987, after Casey had a craniotomy and had been taken to Mayknoll to die. "He contracted pneumonia and was hospitalized on Long Island. There, the morning of May 6, the day after Congress began its public hearings on the Iran-contra affair, Casey died." Woodward interpreted Casey's death as a kind of silence which fell in line with the question: What hurts, sir? "What you don't know," he said. (Veil, pp. 506-507). This book, ROBERT MAXWELL, ISRAEL'S SUPERSPY/ THE LIFE AND MURDER OF A MEDIA MOGUL, (2002), was written in the spirit of William Casey's final interview. If the factual basis for some of its assertions seem a bit ghostly, you might blame all the Bills, or other outrageous bills, or the authors, Gordon Thomas and Martin Dillon, or anyone who seems to know more than any trap-door possessing Prosecutor's Management Information Systems software salesman with investments in newspapers, scientific journals, and an account in the Bank of Bulgaria could keep track of, at the age of sixty-eight, or after November, 1991, when Robert Maxwell, also, was dead.

A society which employs Certified Public Accountants presupposes that people will be able to keep track of certain things, certainly money, for sure, and who people are, though this book finds a certain glory in how easy it is to fool official guardians of the identity assumptions with simple tricks. Obviously, this works best at places like Numec, a company specializing in reprocessing nuclear waste, in Apollo, Pennsylvania. Anybody ought to be able to figure out how likely it is that the following events, prior to December 1982, but reported as background information, might have actually occurred:

His two companions were described on their cards as scientists from `The Department of Electronics, University of Tel Aviv, Israel'.
There was no such department.
The men were LAKAM security officers whose task would be to see the best way of stealing fissionable waste from Numec. All three spent four days in Apollo, passing many hours touring the Numec plant, sitting for more hours in Shapiro's office. What they spoke about would remain a secret. On the fifth day Eitan and his companions left Apollo as unobstrusively as they had arrived.
A month later the first of nine shipments of containers of nuclear waste left Numec. Each container would bear the words: `Property of the State of Israel: Ministry of Agriculture'. The containers would carry a stencil stating they had full diplomatic clearance and so were exempt from customs checks before they were stowed on board El Al cargo freighters to Tel Aviv.
The containers were destined for Dimona, Israel's nuclear facility in the Negev Desert. (pp. 55-56)

One way to be a Mogul, buying companies close to bankruptcy and investing enough to turn them into successes, is described in this book as just the starting point for how "Robert Maxwell was the Barnum and Bailey of the financial world, the great stock market ringmaster able to introduce with consummate speed and a crack of his whip some new and even more startling financial act. But increasingly his high-wire actions had become more dangerous - and long ago he had abandoned any idea of a safety net." (p. 34). Maxwell's arrangements with Vladimir Kryuchkov, head of the Soviet KGB, who had been involved in the August plot to oust Mikhail Gorbachev from office, made certain bankers insecure enough to want Maxwell to pay some of their loans. Maxwell thought 400 million pounds might be enough "to stave off his more pressing creditors. He asked Mossad to use its influence with Israel's banker's to arrange a loan. He was told to try to do what his fellow tycoon, Rupert Murdoch, had done when he had faced a similar situation. Murdoch had confessed his plight to his bankers and then renegotiated his debts, which were almost twice what Maxwell owed." (pp. 13-14). Actually, Maxwell must have owed far more than he told the Mossad. A Daily Mirror headline in the photographs section, after the "Maxwell Dies at Sea" picture, reported, "Maxwell: 536m pounds is missing from his firms/ The increasingly desperate actions of a desperate man."

Assuming that much, the rest of the book is written around questions raised by Efraim.

`If the truth about Robert Maxwell surfaces and he is destroyed in the process, who else will be compromised? How great will the damage be to Israel?' (p. 15).

Americans might be interested in this book for judging the current chances for success of American policies that seem to parallel the desperation of Robert Maxwell, but might cause Bill Casey even greater pain, if he were still in charge.

Riveting, Shocking, Eye-Opening, and Credible


This book is anything but boring--calling this book boring strikes me as a desperate subterfuge by someone who want to keep its explosive contents from fuller circulation. This book is *fascinating* and explosive, not least because of the very well documented coverage it provides of how Israel's intelligence service, the Mossad, used Robert Maxwell to penetrate not just the U.S. government, including the Department of Justice, the military, and the national laboratories, but many foreign governments including the Chinese, Canadians, Australians, and many others, with substantial penetration of their intelligence service databases, all through his sale of a software called PROMIS that had a back door enabling the Mossad to access everything it touched (in simplistic terms).

Also shocking, at least to me, was the extensive detail in this book about how the Israeli intelligence service is able to mobilize Jews everywhere as "sayanim," volunteer helpers who carry out operational (that is to say, clandestine) support tasks to include spying on their government and business employers, stealing documents, operating safehouses, making pretext calls, and so on. I am a simple person: if you are a Jew and a US citizen, and you do this for the Israeli intelligence service, then you are a traitor, plain and simple. This practice is evidently world-wide, but especially strong in the US and the UK.

The book draws heavily on just a couple of former Israeli intelligence specialists to address Israeli use of assassination as a normal technique (and implicitly raises the possibility that it was used against Senator John Tower, who died in small airplane crash and was the primary "agent" for Maxwell and Israel in getting PROMIS installed for millions of dollars in fees all over the US Government).

Finally, the book has a great deal of detail about the interplay between governments, crime families, Goldman Sachs and other major investors, and independent operators like Robert Maxwell who play fast and loose with their employee pension funds.

This book is not boring. Far from it. It is shocking, and if it is only half-right and half-accurate, that is more than enough to warrant its being read by every American, whatever their faith.


The Sword and the Olive: A Critical History of the Israeli Defense Force
Published in Hardcover by PublicAffairs (1998)
Authors: Martin Van Creveld, Martin Van Creveld, and Martin L. van Crevald
Amazon base price: $27.50
Used price: $6.71
Collectible price: $15.95
Buy one from zShops for: $10.99
Average review score:

Contrarian, but valuable.
Martin Van Creveld is a contrarian. This new history of the Israeli Defense Forces (TSAHAL) is by turns complimentary and critical. It starts with the development of self defense forces established in Palestine under the Ottomans and continues forward through the British mandate, then through the various wars up through the Intifada. Enough campaign history is provided to buttress the author's criticism and praise of various leaders. While Van Creveld is critical of the amateur (and often vengeful) nature of the early Zionist and Israeli forces, he does credit them for high morale, aggressive leadership, the ability to learn from mistakes, and to effectively improvise where needed. For Van Creveld the myth of Israeli invincibility rested on stunning successes and tight censorship that covered up mistakes and would-be mistakes. The fall of the IDF starts with the ill-considered invasion of Lebanon in 1982 and accelerated with the response to the Intifada in the late 1980s. Van Creveld sees the surest sign of IDF failure as the inability to participate in the Gulf War; this criticism is unfair and unrealistic as the Israeli military was not designed to project so much power so far, and any Israeli participation in the Coalition would have broken down the anti-Hussein consensus among the Arab participants. Van Creveld shows that the IDF no longer enjoys the invincible reputation and high status that it did 20 years ago. The book covers many topics : the development of Israel's arms industry, the "tank is king" mentality that was so disasterous at the beginning of the 1973 October War, the effect of Israel's nuclear capability, the entangling of party politics, the rise of the Air Force, the usually marginal nature of the Navy, and the status of women. Two interesting aspects of this book : the not-quite-standard English rendering of Hebrew and Arabic words (Mount Chermon for Mt. Hermon, Beqa Valley for Bekaa Valley) and the frequent citation to popular songs, jokes, and sayings that reflect the public image of the IDF. Highly recommended for anyone interested in the Middle East or in the development of national military systems.

Emphasis on "Critical History"
This is a highly engaging book by a very influential Israeli military historian, who having made his reputation addressing other topics, now takes on the IDF. Though the book is a must for anyone with an interest in Middle East military matters, and the IDF in particular, the tone of the book at times is more legal brief than history, as the author presses to complete his thesis. In general, that thesis is that the IDF has been overrated in the past, though it achieved certain heights of glory between 1967 and 1973, and since has been on a rather steady decline. Basically, this is a sound thesis, but pursued too ardently at times. For example, Van Creveld endorses the view put forth by Seymore Hersh that the Syrian offensive on the Golan in 1973 was only halted in the end by Israel "rattling the nuclear saber". ...This is a famous story, much written about, and which produced a number of Israeli heros. To attribute the success of these tankers, whose tactics were much studied and copied by NATO tankers over the years, to a speculative nuclear threat, is a bit much for a historian. There are many more numerous prosiac factors which credibly led to the withdrawal, among them, the fanatic Israeli resistance, the Syrians own heavy losses, the prior commitment of Syria's armored reserve, including the elite Republican Guard, and the effect of IAF interdiction strikes on Syrian supply lines, to name a few. This is not the only example. Van Creveld has virtually nothing positive to say about the 1982 Lebanon campaign, which is already received wisdom in much of Israel and among Israel's critics, and so somewhat tiresome. But his analysis is overly harsh in a purely military history sense. The campaign's early stages were relatively well conducted, though not mistake free, but it is difficult to imagine any other modern army having done better under the circumstances the Israelis faced. This is true regardless of whether the campaign was ultimately was a strategic mistake. As far as further criticism of the book goes I would add that some of the footnotes (the book is heavily footnoted) do not seem to match up to the point being made. This may have something to do with translation problems. The real strength of the book is the last chapters in which Van Creveld takes the IDF to task for undermining its own warrior spirit through Israeli versions of political correctness, overreliance on technology, coddling, etc. Of course, almost everything said could be applied to most modern western armies, and in particular the U.S. Armed Forces. Pretty obviously, the IDF's close links with the U.S. military, which did not realy begin until after the 1973 War, also correlate with the IDF's perceived decline.

An excellent history of the IDF
Martin Van Creveld does an masterful job at writing about the rise and the decline of the IDF. The first part of the is about how the IDF was improvised in the early phases of the First Arabi-Israeli War. According to Van Creveld those who originated from the PALAMCH companies were much more effective in combat compared to their British trained compatriots within the Israeli army. In the middle section Van Creveld criticizes is the IDF's performance in the Suez Canal campaign and the Six Day War. Van Creveld credits the airforces of the British and French in making the Israeli's campaign successful, but the Israelis committed numerous mistakes such the as the paratroop landing at Mitla Pass that was a militarily useless objective. The next chapter Van Creveld questions the IDFs effectiveness during the Six Day War. Van Crevled theorizes that contrary to public opinion the IDF did not practice the much vaunted indircet approach. The IDF mainly attacked the northern and central Egyptian forces in the Sinai. This allowed those Egyptians in the southern sector to escape. The only general to practice the indirect approach was Yoffe, but since Yoffe was an reservist he never received the publicity and the credit that was due to him. The IDF also never made use of combined arms except in the case of Sharon's operations in the Sinai. Van Creveld harshly condems Israeli operations in the opening phases of the Yom Kippur War of 1973. The overcentralized yet disoganized command structure of the IDF led to near disasterous defeats in the early phases of the Yom Kippur War. Van Creveld then evaluates the IDF's performance in Lebanon during the early nineteen eighties. The IDF tried to put too many armored vehicles in a country that had a scarcity of roads. As a result the IDF became bogged down in traffic jams and the PLO was allowed to escape. The IDF proved itself to be incapable of dealing with insurgencys as to seen in their response to the Palestinian uprisings of the late eighties. The IDF would send it's most ill trained sildiers to deal with the uprising. As a result the IDF either used excessive force or prudence, both of which led to defeat. Van Creveld states the Israeli occupation of the West Bank and Gaza is slowly stagnating the IDF and that the Israelis must pull back from these territories.

Another aspect that is mentioned in the book is the situation of manpower within the IDF. In the first phase of it's history the IDF was a compact, highly trained, and motivated fighting force. But in the seventies and eighties the force became bloated and ineffective. The IDF accepted so many conscripts that all but the elite units were trained effectively.Van Crevled opionizes that the conscription of women has only made the problem worse. Van Creveld tells about how ill educated IDF officers are compared to their foreign counterparts. Unlike most Western nations the IDF has no formal service academy. Instead IDF officers had to prove their leadership ability while as an NCO and then go to officer training school. The attempt to introduce a defense university has only met with failure in Israeli history. In the eighties and nineties a vast majority of educated Israelis opted out of the IDF officer corps. But very ill educated but religious Israelis became a large percentage of the current Israeli officer corps. Van Creveld believes that these new religious officers pose a great threat to Israelis democracy. The only criticisms that I have with the book is that Van Creveld glosses over Israeli operations in the Golan Heights during the 1967 and 1973 wars. Other than these minor criticisms this is by far the best book about the history of the IDF.


Israel: A History
Published in Hardcover by William Morrow (1998)
Author: Martin Gilbert
Amazon base price: $21.00
List price: $30.00 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $29.83
Average review score:

Israel's history from the Zionist Movement to the present.
Meticulous chronology of the history of Israel beginning with Herzl's Zionist Movement of the late 19th century up through the present. Gilbert's admiration for the builders and defenders of modern Israel clearly comes through, yet he also does a credible job of explaining the Arab point of view. Gilbert is not shy about letting his anti-terrorist bias come through: whether he's condemning the Menachem Begin led Revisionists attacks against the British (or even against their own Jewish people) or Arab and Israeli attacks and counter-attacks against non-military targets.

My only real criticism is a nitpick. This text is in need of a good editor. There are many awkward and plainly incorrect phrases, as well as outright mistakes. My "favorite" mistake was a reference on page 418 to the American President in 1972, Jimmy Carter. Gee, I was pretty sure Richard Nixon was President in 1972 (and I'll wager that Mr. Gilbert knows that, too)!!! Just to satisfy my curiosity, I even checked the index and found that Carter was cross-referenced to the incident described on page 418.

When all is said and done, I highly recommend this book to readers who want a well researched, single volume history of the state of Israel.

A Sturdy Comprehensive History of Modern Israel
Why is it that any history of Israel which does not conclude that Zionism is a crime against human nature is "biased". Even many supporters of Israel regard works that look favorably on the Jewish state as somehow "biased." The reality is that any fair neutral analysis will show Israel in a favorable light and its enemies unfavorably. Martin Gilbert's extensive history is such a book. It is not necessary to re-create the myths of Zionism and to whitewash bad acts of the Israelis in order to conclude that Israel is a just country and one that Americans should support. Gilbert makes no attempt to persuade the reader in this regard. Instead he comprehensively (and sometimes pedantically) lays out the facts and events of history. The book is not biased at all. Gilbert is not gifted at prosaic writing as was the man for whom he is official biographer, Winston Churchill. If you want to read a British historian whose prose resembles Churchill, the author to read is Paul Johnson. But Gilbert is a gifted historian and this book is eminently readable and thus serves as an excellent introduction to and reference guide for Israeli history through the late 90's. Of course recent events beg for a second edition. We will see.

Peace Beyond the Pale
The history of modern Israel is a search for security and peace -- an elusive, tragic search at best. Martin Gilbert's history can be viewed as slanted toward Israel, but that would miss his point, which is that Israelis have self-consciously wished for and worked for peaceful and fruitful co-existence with their neighbors and with the Palestinians from the beginning. Certainly, there have been grave misdeeds by Israelis (and Arabs) that have resulted in senseless loss of life. But if we go off on that track we will never see what Gilbert's point really means. What both sides would likely acknowledge is that the idea of peaceful coexistence has been more seriously entertained by Israelis than by Arabs -- Palestinian and otherwise. If this book is one-sided then it is so because because Gilbert has revealed this critical asymmetry in a way that has not been made clear before. The book is overflowing with details, anecdotes, portraits and asides that lend it an splendid depth. Yet the author never indulges himself in the sort of speculative forays that might confer color to his work at the expense of careful historical analysis. As a result, there is a critical neutrality toward the facts, with a minimum of bias, emotion or polemic. Perhaps the most emotional part of the book surrounds the events leading up to the assassination of Rabin, a masterful, moving account the whole world should read. Gilbert does not provide an argument for the Labor party or a brief against the Palestinians. Instead, he draws out the tragic dimension of a lost opportunity for peace in a part of the world where peace seems always beyond the pale. In the end, this is a hopeful, though sober and cautious work, and certainly not a book that favors one or the other side. It is a book that should be read by both sides, not with the aim of quibbling about who is represented more favorably, but to see how fragile is the chance for peace and how a knowledge of this brief history of Israel can aid in the efforts to bring about stability and justice for all in this long-suffering part of the world.


Atlas of Jewish History
Published in Hardcover by Fromm Intl (1985)
Authors: Martin Gilbert, T. A. Bicknell, and Arthur Banks
Amazon base price: $5.98
Used price: $9.00
Collectible price: $19.06
Average review score:

A good place to start, but not entirely accurate
I enjoy the way that Gilbert chronicles Jewish history through maps. I found at least one error in his maps, however -- and one of the more recent maps at that -- which makes me question the accuracy of the entire work. The 1947 Partition Plan Map of Palestine, partitioning Palestine into 2 separate countries -- a Jewish state (Israel) and an Arab state (Palestine) -- is blatantly incorrect. While Beersheva is part of present-day Israel, it is improperly reported to be part of the Jewish partition in this book. In fact, all of the area surrounding Beersheva was part of the Arab partition in the UN Resolution. Similarly, the Arabs were also given a larger chunk in Gaza than what is depicted here. Martin seems to take the outcome of the Arab war -- what Jordan and Egypt were able to wrest and occupy (and incidentally, not give to the Palestinians) -- essentially though not exactly the Green Line map of 1949 -- and represent that land as what was suggested in the UN Partition Plan. In my view, this is a serious shortcoming, especially in light of the events surrounding the present peace process and the history leading up to it.

Excellent work
The author of this book chronicles and displays the Jewish history beautifully in this atlas.


Let's Go 98 Israel & Egypt (Annual)
Published in Paperback by St. Martin's Press (1997)
Authors: Taya Lynn Weiss, Adam B. Stein, Jennifer R. Weiss, and St Martin's Press
Amazon base price: $19.99
Used price: $1.89
Buy one from zShops for: $1.95
Average review score:

The best travel guide to the area
There are a zillion Egypt travel guides, and I've at least flipped through most of them. The Let's Go is the best, most up-to-date, and most practical. I have also found the sections on Jordan and Syria, though fairly small, to be more useful than whole other guides devoted to those countries. The Lebanon section is rife with errors, probably because it is new. I expect it will get better over time.

My biggest complaint about this series is the sometimes inappropriate use of humor. Humor is welcome, of course, but the 1992 edition led a (admittedly somewhat gullible) friend of mine to the remote fishing village of Abu Qir in search of the International House of Pancakes Let's Go said was there. Many people seem to memorize the Cairo drivers' "honking dictionary" that appeared in the 1998 edition, when this was either a joke or the product of a serious lack of understanding on the part of the authors.

All in all, though, a very good book and the one to buy if you're coming to the region.

Great in 98
The Let's Go books tend to improve every year, so it's not surprising that some things in this version are out of date. If you are planning a trip to the Middle East, buy a more up-to-date version of the book!

That said, I used this book in 1998 to travel around Egypt, Israel, and Jordan, and I found it useful, insightful, and (yes) funny too. The Let's Go authors share more interesting observations, pay closer attention to detail, and express themselves more clearly than the authors of most other travel guides I've used (and I have used many).

The maps in the book were definitely a weak point. I suggest taking along a supplemental map or two, especially if visiting the big cities.

getting better all the time
The Let's Go books tend to improve every year, so it's not surprising that some things in this version are out of date. If you are planning a trip to the Middle East, buy a more up-to-date version of the book!

That said, I used this book in 1998 to travel around Egypt, Israel, and Jordan, and I found it useful, insightful, and (yes) funny too. The Let's Go authors share more interesting observations, pay closer attention to detail, and express themselves more clearly than the authors of most other travel guides I've used (and I have used many).

The maps in the book were definitely a weak point. I suggest taking along a supplemental map or two, especially if visiting the big cities.


Golda Meir: The Romantic Years
Published in Hardcover by Scribner (1988)
Author: Ralph G. Martin
Amazon base price: $19.95
Used price: $0.01
Collectible price: $1.06
Buy one from zShops for: $3.69
Average review score:

A COLLECTION OF GOSSIP
Golda Meir was a remarkable woman, but you would never be able to tell by this book. If you want to learn more about her, read a better book than this (almost any book is), like one by her son, or one by her friend, or one by herself. This book is very unsubjective and is based on superficial rumors. It is basically a collection of gossip in disguise as a book.

What's wrong with quoting those around her
The previous "reviewer" contradicts him/herself when claiming that the book was very "unsubjective" and based on rumors. Did s/he mean subjective? What's wrong with quoting those around her anyway? Why would an immediate relative have to write the book, as that reviewer argues? Ralph Martin is a professional and does a fine job here.


Pangs of the Messiah : The Troubled Birth of the Jewish State
Published in Hardcover by Praeger Publishers (2000)
Author: Martin Sicker
Amazon base price: $62.95
Used price: $49.95
Average review score:

Pangs of the Messiah: The Troubled Birth of the Jewish State
While Martin Sicker does an exemplary job in synthesizing the historical information of pre-1948, he provides very little personal analysis on how the problems of Zionism provide insight into the problems of contemporary Israel. Furthermore, he presupposes that the reader is aware of what those problems are, as he gives virtually no commentary on the obstacles contemporary Israel faces. As such, Sicker only completes half the task he set out to prove with his thesis. By illustrating only the "events and circumstances that precipitated... [Israel's] emergence..." he fails to show what those events foreshadowed, leaving much more to be desired from his book.
Sicker could have enriched his book greatly by explaining how the factions of Zionism translated into different political parties within Israel after 1948. For example, while he offers great detail on the Revisionist ideology, he offers no exposition on how that ideology translated into a more realistic and more nationalistic "Zionism" after 1948, one that is distinguished by the Likud party of Israel. Furthermore, Israel faces many problems today for which Sicker gives no mention in his book. Sicker never expounds on the conflicting ideologies and cultural antagonism of the Sephardic and Ashkenazi Jews. Moreover, he gives no explanation on the roots of perhaps the greatest threat to the domestic cohesion of Jewish politics, the threat from the religious far right. One can certainly trace the roots of parties such as the NRP and the Agudat Israel to the early days of Zionism. Even though the religious right may not have been a key player in the Zionist movement, its opposition to secularism and Western ideals in contemporary Israel warrants its mention in Sicker's book. If Sicker intended to foreshadow this religious nationalism by mentioning the Revisionist ideology, he never actually explains the connection for the reader.
Finally, while Sicker spends a good portion of his book talking about the external
impediments posed by the British and the rest of the international community, he goes very little beyond the historical facts surrounding the Arab resistance. Indeed, one of the greatest obstacles for the state of Israel is its hostile neighbors, and Sicker can greatly improve the historical value of his book by expounding on the roots of the current Arab-Israeli conflict.
In short, it is obvious that many of the problems faced by contemporary Israel have their foundation in the events that led up to the birth of Israel. However, one can identify many obstacles that find no mention in Sicker's book, and even some that are not alluded to in the historical references of pre-1948. While Sicker has done an excellent job in summarizing the chronological events that led to the birth of Israel, his lack of personal analysis and insight into how the history affects current day politics leaves his book to be a little more than a historical reference.


The Talmud of the Land of Israel: A Preliminary Translation and Explanation: Terumot (Chicago Studies in the History of Judaism)
Published in Hardcover by University of Chicago Press (1988)
Authors: Avery-Peck Alan J., Jacob Neusner, Martin S. Jaffee, and Alan J. Avery-Peck
Amazon base price: $95.00
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Amphiktyonie im Alten Testament : forschungsgeschichtliche Studie zur Hypothese von Martin Noth
Published in Unknown Binding by Friedrich Reinhardt Verlag ()
Author: Otto Bächli
Amazon base price: $
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Related Subjects: Author Index Reviews Page 1 2

Reviews are from readers at Amazon.com. To add a review, follow the Amazon buy link above.