Used price: $1.85
Collectible price: $12.86
List price: $15.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $8.00
Buy one from zShops for: $11.09
Used price: $1.14
Collectible price: $4.75
Buy one from zShops for: $1.24
List price: $15.00 (that's 52% off!)
Used price: $0.99
Collectible price: $4.95
Buy one from zShops for: $14.19
That little passage suggests that, though he may be an excellent diarist, Ellis must have been a lousy reporter, one completely lacking in the objectivity supposedly required by the
profession. If Elvis had had access to Ellis' diary, he might have answered Ellis' question with a question of his own: "How can YOU justify asking ME that question when you did not ask it of Grace Kelly, who not only acquired enormous wealth in her acting career, but married into more millions by bagging Prince Rainier of Monaco?"
Ellis interviewed Kelly in 1956, an experience detailed in his entry of January 11 that year. His questions to her are never more challenging than this one: "Will you see the prince today?" (p. 232) Ellis didn't ask Clark Gable's widow how her late husband justified the millions he made when school teachers were underpaid, nor did the reporter grill composer Irving Berlin on the matter either. Apparently it was alright for Kelly, Gable, and Berlin to make millions because Ellis appreciated their "talents," but Presley and rock and roll didn't pass muster with "America's Greatest Diarist," as Ellis is called on the jacket of his book, and, therefore, it was wrong for Presley to strike it rich. The question, if it was worthy of being asked at all, should have been directed at a society that values performers more than it does the teachers in whose hands our children's education is placed.
That being said, Ellis' book is a worthwhile read for anyone interested in fine writing and a purely subjective (and, as noted, sometimes hypocritical) account of life as it was lived and observed by Ellis in the 20th century.
Collectible price: $42.35
List price: $13.95 (that's 20% off!)
Used price: $2.75
Collectible price: $9.27
Buy one from zShops for: $3.95
Hamill takes us with us on his boyhood as he dreams of becoming a cartoonist. From the streets of Brooklyn where stickball reigned to incarceration in a Mexican jail the life tale woven by Hamill has many unexpected twists and turns. Despite his many faults Hamill has succeeded as a famed newspaper columnist and novelist. His book is easy reading and better than the much more heralded works by Frank McCourt.
The language used by Hamill is rough, often scatological and may be offensive to genteel readers. However I found it well written and engaging. The book is worth a read by anyone interested in Irish American culture, newspaper life or the journey of a man from poverty to prominence.
Throughout all of this, there is much drinking; however, to call this a book about alcoholism would be inaccurate. This is a memoir of a life... one to which drinking is inextricably tethered, but not one that revolves around the art of drinking. Hamill began drinking early, and then as a reporter spent most of his time in bars, and his storytelling ability leaves no doubt that he was probably the center of attention in these bars more often than not. In the end he kicks the habit, for fear that he has been peforming his life rather than living it. He still visits his old drinking haunts, but now sits there quietly with a Coke in hand.
This memoir is well told, and Hamill sees himself with a very clear eye. His voice is unarguably that of a reporter: there is very little fanfare or elaborate language, and the story of his life is always moving. Fortunately for the reader, it is an eventful life, filled with street fights in Brooklyn, mischief at camp, passionate sex with mysterious women, gunshots and jail in Mexico, and much more. The memoir genre is growing tired lately, but this is one of the books that set the craze off, and it is easy to see why.
Used price: $8.75
This is a book that is rich with setting. Hamill paints a post- WWII Brooklyn, filled with tenements, ethnic code and spunky kids playing stickball in crowded streets. He paints pictures of bored priests at mass, snowy city avenues, and a lonely rabbi in a run-down synagogue. Hamill also addresses prejudice in such a genuine manner. Religious prejudice (Catholic v. Jew as well as Nazi v. Jew), Racial prejudice (black v. white in the baseball world) and some economic prejudice are scattered throughout this book as the main character, young Michael Devlin, tries to make sense of a cruel and hate-filled world.
In Snow in August Young Devlin witnesses the near death beating of a local Jewish merchant by an Irish-American gang member. And in this event he has to examine many issues. He has to determine why the Jews who live in his neighborhood are so despised. He then sees a connections with how many whites in America despise Jackie Robinson for being the first black baseball player, and young Devlin is bothered by the hatred that seems to pepper his world.
Because Devlin refuses to buy into the anti-semetic notions, he befriends the lonely rabbi. Because of this, he becomes a target of the gang member that beat the Jewish merchent, and the boy has to figure out how to keep himself and his mother safe from their violence. And that is where the story fizzles...because the ending is so out of step with the rest of the novel. The book moves from thought provoking to cartoonish in a single chapter. I keep asking myself, "What symbolism is happening here that I am not getting?" but I can't figure it out.
It is worth a read, but be ready to say, "Huh?" when you get to the end.
Used price: $3.25
Collectible price: $7.84
Buy one from zShops for: $8.50
That said, Hamill is a marvelous writer and this is a terrific read for those who are unfamiliar with his story. I devoured every page anyway. The quotes by Sinatra are fascinating, and Hamill's admittedly remote acquaintance with his subject (they met several times in New York) lends this relevance and legitimacy. Hamill also dwells on what is commonly considered the apex of Sinatra's career, his classic albums at Capitol, and even takes a swipe at Gordon Jenkins' string-laden efforts during this period -- so, not a good book if you want an overview of Sinatra's musical legacy. If Sinatra saw enough in Jenkins to have him as an arranger from the 1950s through the '80s, clearly there is something that Hamill is missing that Sinatra cherished.
But -- this is Hamill's heartfelt homage to someone whom he considers an artistic hero of sorts, and his rather narrow focus is completely appropriate for this sort of book.
I would recommend this book to any Sinatra fan. However, you should also read Will Friedwald's "The Song is You" for an exhaustive story of the music. I also enjoyed Donald Clarke's "All or Nothing At All", which is more of a biography with pertinent commentary.
I have dozens of Sinatra albums, and I still discover amazing new aspects to music that I have heard for years. Sinatra definitely matters, and this book was written by another guy who misses him.
List price: $23.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $8.83
Collectible price: $10.59
Buy one from zShops for: $11.95
With this book he presents a portrait -- and sketchy history -- of the city from an angle few people know it. Structuring the story as a fairly continuous though interrupted sail from his home in Long Beach, around the southern tip of Rockaway and into Jamaica Bay, then into Upper New York Bay and the East River, and ultimately to Long Island Sound, Kornblum offers both close-up looks at the water and shoreline, and their past history.
The approach is light and pleasant: Few stories -- whether of the freezing disaster of the privateer "Castel Del Rey" in New York harbor in 1704, knowledgeable black sailors impressed by the British Navy in the War of 1812 and jailed in England for refusing to serve against the US, various ferry disasters, or the vagaries of Robert Moses -- last more than a page or three. The only sections where Kornblum lingers are in Jamaica Bay (its environmental degradation and return), and the dockside concrete industry that built New York's towers and for which the author worked as a kid. Manhattan itself is quickly bypassed though given a loving nod, and there is no venturing into the Hudson side.
In the typo sweepstakes, the book does all right, although it says "mechanical break" on p. 156 when "brake" was meant, and I believe I saw an unintended sentence fragment on p. 143. Most egregious, the great A.J. Liebling is identified on p. 103 as "Libeling" (though the name is correct in the bibliography)! A pity there apparently are youthful editors (I don't suppose there is such a thing as a proofreader in publishing anymore) who do not know this great journalist's work backward and forward.
Another ominous development -- to this reader, anyway -- is that the lovely cover photograph is an unreal composite. Different photographers are credited for different portions of it. I find this vaguely disturbing.
The writing is definitely four-star quality or better. Here's my favorite passage: "Up another shadowy bend stood two snowy egrets, with their outrageous yellow boots and platinum punk haircuts. How chic, these mudbank sushi bars. The egrets were spearing for sand bugs, moving along the edge of the marsh with the herky giant steps of students at a party stepping over empty beer cans."
I give the book only three stars because it is slight. Probably an excellent gift for the average non-reader who happens to love sailing or New York City, or the casual reader who knows little about either, but I would have liked to know more.
I expected the former thanks to a review in the NY Times, I think -- some newspaper, anyway -- that suggested it was less an ecological than an historical journey. Without this preconception, I probably would have liked the book more. If you're from NYC, it's worth a read, but there are many better sailing accounts if you want hairy-chested adventure, or to learn something about sailing in general. There are also better books about ecology of the shoreline.
But the style is pleasant and the author seems like a man who would be an enjoyable sailing companion. That's worth three stars.