Used price: $4.94
Collectible price: $18.66
Used price: $196.48
List price: $16.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $0.38
Collectible price: $3.00
Buy one from zShops for: $0.99
Like another reviewer, I was not happy with one-third of the book being devoted to twistors, since these strike this outsider as higher on mathematical elegance than on physical content. I will not fault Peat, however, for doing this since: A) due to his friendship with the Penrose Twistor group he is specially qualified to popularise this subject, and B) the Twistor program, a child of Penrose's brain, is rich in guiding principles, and provides therefore a healthy antidote to the superstrings, which grew up higgeldy-piggeldy by a sequence of "accidental" discoveries -- "It seems to work, but, heck, we don't really know why." Twistors have been less a matter of trial and error. At least they work well for massless particles. (Sidelight: In a blackboard discussion w/ Penrose at Cal Tech that I chanced to overhear about 25 yrs. ago, Feynman told Penrose that no one had succeeded in making massless fields cohere together so as to act like massive fields.)
Used price: $26.95
Buy one from zShops for: $31.77
But if you're a information-hungry "techie" who is relatively new to F1, you will enjoy the book. It serves as a valuable reference guide to the recent (mid-90s) history of F1 technology. It helps you put things into perspective, explaining how current F1 technology arrived at its present state.
List price: $59.95 (that's 30% off!)
He second guesses US designer's analysis of British ships (like I always say, 20-20 hindsight is a wonderful thing) but then admits that these were probably for ships for which he (Brown) lacks references for. He then puts up future DNC Goodall's contemporary analysis of US designs without noting the errors contained in them that have been exposed for literally decades (see Friedman's "US Battleships" for one).
Mr. Brown also raises the old bug-a-boo about the all-or-nothing protection scheme of the "Standards" as being possibly overwhelmed by numerous hits on their unprotected ends. Somehow, he seems to be forgetting the fact that every post-war British capital ship design used nearly the same scheme, to say nothing that such fears were shown groundless by the pummeling that the USS Colorado received during WWII. If the all-or-nothing protection scheme was so bad, why then was it copied in most of its essentials in British post-WWI capital ship designs? Why didn't the Nelson's, KGV's, Lion's and Vanguard continue to use the incremental armor scheme so favored in the pre-war dreadnoughts? Perhaps Mr. Brown is saving such thoughts for the next volume in this series, but it's a glaring omission, nonetheless.
But, my very favorite passage was where Mr. Brown discusses the wartime exploits of British battlecruisers. In what can only be called revisionist history, Mr. Brown states that "the author believes that the basic concept of the battlecruiser was sound. Invincible's glorious career at Heligoland Bight, Falklands and Jutland justifies that statement. The three magazine explosions at Jutland (and the later case of Hood) have obscured the real value of such ships."
Sorry, but that just reminds this reader of that famous U.S. saying, "Other than that, Mrs. Lincoln, how did you enjoy the play?" The exploits of a single ship, no matter how glorious, can not be said to justify a ship type that is most remembered for "sinking and leaving barely enough survivors to man a Yugo," to use a phrase I wish I'd thought of first (my hat's off to Cen). I'm afraid that the author's admiration for these ships' undeniably powerful appearance has kept him from applying his considerable talent for design analysis to their equally obvious flaws.
That said, this book does offer very interesting insights into the ships of all classes being built in Britain in the 1906-22 time frame. If you stick to following what the author knows best, the British design process, you won't go far wrong. His examples of British naval design thinking are mostly original, and include details for the lessor known ships, such as destroyers and submarines, that are so hard to find for pre-WWI vessels.
Finally, he cleared up something that has always puzzled me; why the British were so reluctant to fit super-firing turrets on their warships. For that alone, this book was a worthy addition to my library.
Used price: $43.64
He does very little to address his thesis, that Princess Alice had sides to her character which were not shown in her letters to her mother; she did, but Duff provides no evidence of any.
I was also disappointed in Duff's treatment of the Hessian royal family. Alice's in-laws are relegated to a mere footnote and one or two mentions in the text. Considering the frequency in which they are mentioned in her letters, this would seem untoward.
There are some good points. The brief biographical notes on minor characters in Alice's life are interesting (but again, many people who should not have been are relegated to these brief notes). The author includes large excerpts from the fascinating but unpublished memoirs of Alice's oldest daughter.
But overall, the narrative drags, the analysis of the subjects seems superficial at best, and Duff often seems to display a "wow, look what I found" attitude towards his voluminous research. (It's nice that he knows what all of Alice's wedding presents were. Do we really need a one-page footnote listing them all?) It's a pity, since so little material exists on Queen Victoria's second daughter, and even less on her adoptive family of Hesse. Unfortunately, until something better comes along, we're stuck with "Hessian Tapestry."
Used price: $12.95
Collectible price: $21.18
Buy one from zShops for: $39.18
Used price: $42.35
Collectible price: $58.24