Used price: $15.00
At first, it may look to some readers like the book is just another formulatic epic-battle-type fantasy, but Tanith Lee takes all the old, used-up cliches of this sort of fantasy and reweaves them, turns them upside-down, completley rejeuvenates them.
This is a wonderful book, and a worthy sequel. I would have liked it perhaps if Tanaquil had just gone on adventures by herself (and the peeve) and there had been no war element, but this sequel is still good the way it is.
Altogether, I wasn't disappointed. Fun book! Well worth reading!
Used price: $35.06
The first section's greatest contribution is its perspective on individual Old English words. If you are intrigued by kennings, then there are two or three interesting chapters in this book which seem to offer a novel treatment of the subject. This work has a comprehensive bibliography and seems solidly based in text.
The Christian context, in structure, language, character, etc. is the overarching theme of the second half of the book, which is divided into chapter length essays. This section would be most useful to someone investigating the pagan/Christian juxtaposition in Beowulf. At times I disagreed with various points/premises, but the overall argument was compelling.
List price: $24.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $17.42
Buy one from zShops for: $13.99
Used price: $14.71
Collectible price: $13.72
The book promotes that it tells the "true story" of this labor dispute and the criminal probe. Yet, I found I had to question the impartiality of the authors, when they omitted or interpreted some details of the case to further their viewpoint. Case in point: during the trial the authors referenced, in very sanitized language, the crude manner in which the accused had spoken of female boss, Peggy Witte. The hateful language actually used, published and quoted elsewhere, would have allowed the reader insight into the mind of the accused. Watering-down and glossing over this testimony in the book, seemed to me to be an effort to shelter the reader from understanding this man's capacity for hatred.
For those interested in the case, I recommend more highly, the book "The Third Suspect." It describes the situation in, what I believe to be, a more impartial manner. It tells the story and accepts the jury verdict of guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.
List price: $19.95 (that's 20% off!)
Used price: $10.75
Collectible price: $10.59
Buy one from zShops for: $13.44
List price: $16.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $8.95
Buy one from zShops for: $10.00
I only made it about 150 pages before I bestowed upon this book a rare honor, one that I have only bestowed upon two other books in my life: I threw it away. I refuse to allow any other human being to be subjected to its unfocused, egotistic narrative.
Avoid this book and (unless you're interested in personal accounts of lesbian difficulties) everything else written by Susan Lee Johnson.
This is a "People's History" sort of book, a tale of the minor characters in history, in particular the miners and their society. In such a book, there are oppressors (often white males) and oppressed (usually women and non-whites). Johnson supports this thesis with numerous tales of robbery and murder, which may all be true, but also reflect a political agenda that she is trying to promote. This removes any real objectivity from her book.
The main problem with this book, however, is it is not very well-organized. Johnson has filled the book with some good (and some not-so-good) anecdotes, but there is not all that much joining these stories together. The result is a sometimes informative but usually rambling work. In the end, I felt like I hadn't learned very much about this era other than a few tales that needed a better context.
Used price: $125.91
Whole sections of the text are lifted directly from Vincent Seyfried's "The Long Island Railroad: A Comprehensive History." And the source of some of Brian Merlis' photos must be questioned.
Used price: $17.34
Collectible price: $26.42
Buy one from zShops for: $17.34
Used price: $8.00
Collectible price: $15.99
Buy one from zShops for: $15.86
Used price: $1.25
Collectible price: $3.11
Buy one from zShops for: $5.00
While not, in my mind, quite as enjoyable as the first one, Gold Unicorn nonetheless remains a well-crafted fantasy in a creative and unusual world. Darker than its predecessor, Gold Unicorn explores Tanaquil's struggles between loyalty to her half-sister Lizra, now the dreaded conquerer, and her own belief that the ideal world her sister strives for cannot be achieved by war. Added are several complications-- a massive mechanical gold unicorn Lizra has ordered Tanaquil to fix for her war campaign, the mischievous peeve, stinging mousps (a magician's creation formed of mice and wasps), Honj, the enigmatic consort of Lizra...and a hell world to parallel the perfect world Tanaquil saw in the last book.
Obviously some people won't appreciate this book, but to those who enjoy Tanith Lee's particular style, Gold Unicorn is the perfect way to spend an afternoon.