

Little new here
A turn of the century thriller that shouldn't be missed.

Messy and cumbersomeFroment is frustrated by the inertia of the conservative Papal bureaucracy and with the ins and outs of Italian and Church politics. At times, the novel felt like a work by Kafka (a pre-echo of Kafka, you might say) in that Froment is lost amid a seemingly meaningless and endless process: the Church absorbs his efforts.
What really made me struggle with the novel though was Zola's lack of focus - had he concentrated on Froment's experiences,it would have been a better novel, but he meandered for very long stretches: his descriptions of Rome become travelogues, the main plot just disappears. There are other long rambling passages too, for example on Church history, which although not irrelevant to the context of the story, go on far too long, and there is a pot-boiler of a sub-plot about two "star-crossed lovers".
In all, a disappointment compared to "Lourdes".
A wonderful glimpse of Rome and the Vatican of 100 years ago
Used price: $15.00

An even more miserable Werther

Buy one from zShops for: $111.71





This is an angry novel. Zola tilts at political cynicism, the duplicity and insincerity of organised religion, and the social and economic inequities of the time.
Much of the novel is really a rehash of themes Zola explored in his "Rougon-Macquart" novel cycle - so there's little original here, and at its worst, the style becomes annoyingly preachy.
There is an interesting sub-plot in which Pierre's brother, Guillaume, develops a new explosive powder of enormous power - many of the issues raised by Zola about how that invention should be best put to use seemed to me to anticipate debates about nuclear power.