Used price: $132.15
Used price: $7.36
Collectible price: $15.88
Buy one from zShops for: $14.98
Throughout Dr Strangelove Foot quotes from the worryingly simplistic series of briefs which shaped the post-war world: a case in point is Eisenhower's brief on Kashmir, "The bulk of whose population is Muslim, like Pakistan's. It is controlled by India, a Hindu nation, and heated feelings remain from the bloody skirmishes between Indians and Pakistanis for control." Foot's own contention that, "India could offer better safety and protection for Muslims than Pakistan itself." could form the basis of an entirely separate, not to say controversial, text. Still, Foot clearly knows India, and her post-war leaders well, and like many born into a colonial world, he has a grasp of the tensions and personalities involved which any front-bencher, including the current Foreign Secretary, clearly struggle to match.
As background to the story of the Indian sub-continent, Dr Strangelove deals with a number of subjects. There are over-lengthy attempts to correct the 'misconceptions' surrounding the Labour party and CND's unilateralist thinking of 1983, and Foot's description of his and Denis Healey's trips abroad are made to sound like shuttle diplomacy, with a centrality to historical events, which they clearly did not have. Lengthy quotes from old CND newsletters are, on balance marginally less useful than Foot's insights into regional power politics. He goes on to do better though.
Aside from events on the Indian sub-continent, the direct link Foot makes between the failure of the official nuclear powers to meaningfully promote any kind of disarmament and the proliferation of the weapons world-wide is the most convincing theme of Dr Strangelove. As Foot recalls, in the early `80s, fresh Cruise and Pershing programmes were being commissioned by Nato as the Salt II agreement was being ratified. And he has a point - the original proliferation of the weapons has impacted on our own more complex world. When countries like Belarus have 36 warheads, managing the balance of power becomes a trickier act - a point better recognised in recent James Bond screen plays than by the topically inactive George Robertson.
Where I wanted a clearer steer from Dr Strangelove was on the future prospects of a safer nuclear world, and here Foot is weaker - a little too taken up with the past. Inspection is key to any level of disarmament, and he enthuses over the achievements of the UN inspectors' work in Iraq. The UN Charter and the creaking structures of the UN, as Foot points out, remain the best way forward for a safer world. But otherwise, his sources are a little old. CND, for example, is clearly an inadequate standard bearer in the 1990s, even for Foot's brand of decency. Dr Strangelove is essentially a history, but like all the best histories, is a tool for comprehending the present.
List price: $14.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $5.95
Buy one from zShops for: $10.17
Each chapter is introduced by a short text piece, and it's actually those text pieces I found most compelling. That's no knock on Mike Oeming's art, which is different from the style Oeming uses these days on books like POWERS -- a little less inspired by current animation, but no less effective, especially on facial expressions. But the text pieces have a certain sense of dread about them, a heaviness of feeling; the narrator seems weighed down by failure and despair in a way that doesn't quite come through in the pages of the main story - it adds a layer of complexity that the comics chapters don't quite have. I hope that in future volumes Krueger works those elements into the story and starts paying off the hints he's dropping here. If he does, and I believe he will, FOOT SOLDIERS will turn out to be a comics saga well worth reading.
Used price: $5.00
Used price: $14.07
Used price: $8.75
Collectible price: $19.99
Used price: $15.00