Related Subjects: Author Index Reviews Page 1 2
Book reviews for "FitzGerald,_Edward" sorted by average review score:

Eight Dramas of Calderon
Published in Paperback by Univ of Illinois Pr (Pro Ref) (April, 2000)
Authors: Pedro Calderon De LA Barca, Edward Fitzgerald, Margaret R. Greer, Pedro Calderon De LA Barca, and Pedro Calderon De La Barca
Amazon base price: $14.95
Average review score:

Bravo Calderon!
Bravo Calderon! for his masterly plays, although it is difficult to find the poetry in this translation by Edward Fitzgerald. The eight plays included in this book are: The Painter of His Own Dishonour; Keep Your Own Secret; Gil Perez, the Gallician; Three Judgements at a Blow; The Mayor of Zalamea; Beware of Smooth Water; The Mighty Magician; and Such Stuff as Dreams Are Made Of. The translations are antique from Edward Fitzgerald (1809-1883) and are reprinted here. However, they provide the only translations available for some of the minor plays that display the wonderful psychological complexity in Calderon's work. The concept of the Spanish Code of Honor causes many difficulties and conflicts that ring true to varying degrees in our own societies today. One must ask how can Fitzgerald present 8 plays in 429 pages when for example Honig presents 6 plays in 444 pages? The size of the print is slightly smaller but a careful comparison reveals that Fitzgerald grossly leaves out parts of the plays "that seemed to mar the breadth of general effect." The page count reveals significant omissions as far at the poetry of the plays is concerned. One is stunned to read the opinion of the translator in his "Advertisement" which is near the beginning of this compilation. In his defense of "so free translations" he pleads that he did not "meddle with any of the more famous plays", and that "whether real or dramatic Spanish passion, is still bombast to English ears and confounds otherwise distinct outlines of characters." Fitzgerald goes on to state that parts of the plays were "not Calderon's better self, but concession to private haste or public taste." The worst is "I have, while faithfully trying to retain what was fine and efficient, sunk, reduced, altered, and replaced much that seemed not; simplified some perplexities, and curtailed or omitted scenes..." Hopefully, we will be able to recruit a more modern translator who will capture the passion and poetry to produce a more enjoyable version in English. In the meanwhile, we can try to see through the twist given by Fitzgerald.


High Treason: The Assassination of JFK & the Case for Conspiracy
Published in Paperback by Carroll & Graf (November, 1998)
Authors: Harrison Edward Livingstone and Robert J. Groden
Amazon base price: $17.95
Used price: $4.30
Collectible price: $9.95
Average review score:

Excellent book, take the time to read it, its worth it!
I felt that this book was well worth the time that it took toread. Groden and Livingstone wrote in-depth all of the inaccuracies ofthe Warren's Report and other conflicting evidence that our government states as being the truth. The only negative thing that I can say about this book is that it can be a bit confusing and takes quite a bit of time to read. I am sure that I will be re-reading it again to pick up on parts that never did sink in. Others have put this book down by saying that Groden made all of the evidence fit his "theory" of a conspiracy. A theory is a speculation just like how the Warren's Report is a theory, its not true fact and most of use would agree with that.

Overall, very good book, worth the time to read. Remember, keep an open mind.

One Of The Most Important Books Ever Written.
"High Treason" is a document written in blood about how government really works. Every American interested in their rights and in our system, should read this book with care. "High Treason" is a magnificent work because it understands the structure of power and how powerful men work. I have not read a more convincing book on the conspiracy to kill JFK. Posner and Livingston present an enormous amount of convincing evidence. I would place this book by Oliver Stone's masterpiece, "JFK." "High Treason" is an important book that I think should be read in schools. Not so much as to educate on the Kennedy assassination, but on the workings of our government and how power really works. I'm glad it has been republished with new information. I was so enfuriated by Gerald Posner's load of shit, "Case Closed." "High Treason" REALLY looks for the truth. And in the end, is disturbing.

Excellent Exposition of Evidence of Conspiracy
This book took me by surprise after reading the 26 volumes of the Warren Report. This book shows you a concise, detailed account of all the evidence ignored by the Warren Commision and the House Select Committee on Assassinations. I highly recommend this book to anybody who believes that JFK's Assassination issue is closed.


High Treason 2: The Great Cover-Up: The Assassination of President John F. Kennedy
Published in Hardcover by Carroll & Graf (April, 1992)
Authors: Harrison Edward Livingstone and Robert J. Groden
Amazon base price: $25.95
Used price: $2.95
Collectible price: $8.99
Average review score:

Not his own words...
Harrison Livingstone is one of the assassination investigators who only write books to stabilize his cash flow. His new work High Treason 2, does not stay on the track and is a dead end. I will not recommend this book to anyone...Instead buy HIS FORMER co-author Robert Groden's book THE KILLING OF A PRESIDENT. ...

Good But Sometimes Gets Off Track.
Harrison Edward Livingston is certainly right in saying that a conspiracy killed John F. Kennedy. There is too much evidence that proves something strange and suspicious was going on in Dallas on November 22, 1963 and in Washington. His book, "High Treason 2," a follow-up to the bestseller "High Treason" which Livingston wrote in collaboration with renowned JFK assassination expert Robert Groden, is both an informative, eye-opening investigative work and a slippery search for facts and answers. The areas dealing with the medical evidence are meticulous and very important with it's testimonies and detailed accounts of Kennedy's wounds and the evidence that the shot that killed him came from the front. There is a good deal of evidence that Martin Luthor King Jr.'s assassination was also plotted and Livingston provides some interesting insights into the FBI's harrassment of King at the hands of J.Edgar Hoover. He also makes you wonder about the facts behind the assassination of Robert Kennedy and the attempt on George Wallace. However, Livingston's fault is that he writes with a saintly-look at Kennedy and gets too paranoid at times. I can buy that King, Kennedy and Wallace were victims of shady doings, but to also say the attempts on Gerald Ford and Ronald Reagan were results of conspiracies is a little too out there. Also the notion that even the Zapruder film is fake evidence makes for too much paranoia. But what shows Livingston to be more of a radical than just an investigator is his attack on Oliver Stone and "JFK," claiming the movie is damaging to researchers when in fact, it aided in the release of more documents and many researchers, including Robert Groden (who even consulted on Stone's film) have called it a brilliant collage of assassination research material gathered by those trying to prove a conspiracy. Livingston also goes on to attack Jim Garrison, who in my opinion, is a social hero for speaking out and even pushed for the Zapruder film to be shown in colleges so young people would start asking questions. It is easier in this paranoia-driven age, when events like Watergate, Iran Contra and others have made our trust in the government dissimate, for Livingston to speak his ideas and conclusions. Garrison was one of the first to speak out publicly in a time when government conspiracy was still seen as an impossibility by a lot of ordinairy Americans and the government had an easier time shutting people up. He also denounces L.Flether Prouty and his claims eventhough Prouty worked in the intelligence community and military industrial complex for many years, Livingston hasn't. While he is an investigator, Prouty actually lived it. That said, "High Treason 2" in the end is well-written, with some good information and it sure works better than Gerald Posner's "Case Closed," a fascist piece of lies. Livingston has uncovered a lot of valuable things, but once in a while, he tries to put too much icing on the cake, or case.

Retrospection on the Assassination
This 1992 book is very readable and contains many interesting essays that may educate you. Chapter 1 tells how HEL remembers the 1950s. The election of JFK made a difference due to the people; the times they were a-changing. Pages 43-4 tells of the "bureaucratic phenomenon" but doesn't ask if any clique or secret society is responsible. Chapter 2 tells of JFK's medical history. He quotes the curious comments of Dr. Humes on the adrenal glands (pp. 55-6). There would be no reason for covering up any Addison's disease. HEL suggests the use of cortisone by JFK affected his personality: euphoria, strength, endurance, warmth, and libido (p.59).

Chapter 3 tells certain findings are conclusive: the back of the head is missing (p.71). If the photographs and X-rays don't show this, they are forgeries. Or from another body. HEL derides the theory that "the Mob killed Kennedy" on the grounds that they couldn't do a cover-up. But their controllers could! Chapter 5 discusses the events at Bethesda. The face in some of the autopsy photographs does not look like JFK, but of a younger man (p.135). Chapter 6 discusses the conflicts of the autopsy. This is one of the most important chapters in the book!

Chapter 14 tells of the discussion for a 1991 documentary. "The large hole in the back of the head was an exit wound" (p.287). These witnesses insisted there was not entry wound in the back of the head (p.293). Chapter 16 quotes the House Committee report that the authenticity of the photographs was never established (p. 314-6). Chapter 19 discusses some other major political killings following the assassination of JFK. HEL notes that if George Wallace ran for President he would have taken enough votes from Nixon so McGovern would have won (p.403). Friends of this lone gunman soon died or disappeared (p.407). More potential witnesses were bumped off when the House Assassination Committee started in 1977 (p.414). Page 418 summarizes the bottom line of American political history.

Chapter 20 summarizes the changes in America since the Nixon and Reagan reigns (p.422); it doesn't cover the 1990s. Page 458 claims the Schoolbook Depository rifle was not fired that day (from negative evidence)! Chapter 24 discusses JFK's "intent to withdraw from Vietnam", while the military sought to send in combat troops. That happened with the new President. Vietnam is important since it borders the oil-rich South China Sea; and Big Oil is the most powerful special interest in the country.

Chapter 25 tells of Jim Garrison's investigation. "A secret investigation ... pointed in the direction of Hoffa, Marcello, some Texas oilmen, and a few involved with the CIA in the New Orleans and Dallas area" (p.511). But Garrison couldn't get a conviction of anyone. David Ferrie, and others, soon died (p.513). Pages 518-9 discuss the justice system: "too often a case can be rigged". Jim Garrison was the first official to question the Warren Report in the 1960s. Oliver Stones's "JFK" was based on Garrison's book; he make a popular film about a Presidential assassination - a Hollywood first! It did renew a wider interest in the books on this case.

Chapter 28 gives HEL's ideas of "What Really Happened", and summarizes this case. Watergate and Nixon's removal were caused by Nixon's use of political murders. Page 571 imagines an "ice bullet" that would disappear; isn't it more likely that a plastic bullet would not show up on X-rays? Pages 573-7 gives HEL's ideas on how the real government works: politicians are like actors on a stage, spouting the lines written by the invisible government. He says "our elections are rigged from the
start". And that a vast amount of money was made by those who sold short on the morning of 11/22/1963 due to advance information. The Warren Commission and the Administration were from the high-level banking and financial interests that control our nation.


Killing the Truth: Deceit and Deception in the JFK Case
Published in Hardcover by Carroll & Graf (November, 1993)
Author: Harrison Edward Livingstone
Amazon base price: $27.95
Used price: $2.21
Collectible price: $8.99
Buy one from zShops for: $10.50
Average review score:

garbage
I found this at a used bookstore. Was happy not to have my money go to the author. His arguments, like all the conspiracy theorists, are based on innuendo or explainable "discrepancies" in the evidence, which is presented in a very selective manner. HEL ignores the truly compelling evidence that shows that three shots and three shots only were fired at JFK's car. He counts up to 6 shots. Where are the bullets? The shells? The shooters? Several witnesses saw a rifleman in the Book Depository window. No one reported seeing any other shooters, even though potential witnesses were everywhere. Plus - 88% of the 178 witnesses said they were certain they heard three shots. HEL doesn't bother to mention this

Livingstone, where did you leave the tracks?...
It appears that HEL is shooting from the hip in his final book. The summation of facts in the first half of the book is compelling and somewhat satisfying, but from here comes the kind of stuff that the Gerald Posners of the world use to create the impression that researchers are paranoid and inaccurate. How can someone with a clear concsience say that all the people who shot photos and film in the Plaza were placed there by the conspirators? That researchers like Weisberg are on a disinformation campaign? There's no disagreement that the Groden questions raise doubts as to his credibility; the others sound a lot like elevator excuses. I read this book at the library, and a friend of mine moved recently and left a copy of this book for anyone to take with them.

No one took it.

After a thorough examination, I can see why.


Agamemnon: A Tradegy Taken from Aeschylus (Poetical and Prose Writings of Edward Fitzgerald (7 Volumes))
Published in Library Binding by Classic Books (1906)
Author: Edward FitzGerald
Amazon base price: $98.00
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Arenas of Greed: The Great Chicago Commodity Market Sham
Published in Hardcover by Devin Pub (December, 1990)
Author: William Edward Fitzgerald
Amazon base price: $24.95
Used price: $5.90
Collectible price: $10.89
Buy one from zShops for: $5.94
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Blest madman : Fitzgerald of Canterbury
Published in Unknown Binding by Canterbury University Press ()
Author: Edmund Bohan
Amazon base price: $
Used price: $127.91
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Dictionary of Madame De Sevigne Volume 2
Published in Hardcover by Burt Franklin (01 January, 1971)
Author: Edward Fitzgerald
Amazon base price: $
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Dictionary of Madame de Sévigné
Published in Unknown Binding by B. Franklin ()
Author: Edward FitzGerald
Amazon base price: $
Used price: $58.00
Average review score:
No reviews found.

The Downfall and Death of King Oedipus: A Drama in Two Parts, Chiefly Taken from the Oedipus Tyrannus and Colonaeus of Sophocles (Poetical and Prose Writings of Edward Fitzgerald (7 Volumes))
Published in Library Binding by Classic Books (1880)
Author: Edward FitzGerald
Amazon base price: $98.00
Average review score:
No reviews found.

Related Subjects: Author Index Reviews Page 1 2

Reviews are from readers at Amazon.com. To add a review, follow the Amazon buy link above.