Used price: $19.93
Plunkett is an articulate ruthless genius, and his narration, is such that it keeps you glued to the pages. As in much of Ellroy's work, all the characters, policeman, murderers, victims are painted with a dark brush. The result, as always, is a book which is almost impossible to put down.
Crime wave is a book of short stories, actual true crime cases, and a few essays written by Ellroy for GQ Magazine.
Reading Ellroy is almost like singing along with a tune on the radio, it's all about rythm. Included are a story about Ellroy's Mother's unsolved murder and another fictitious story involving Dick Contino. The stories that I loved most of all though, were the stories told by Danny Getchell, the dirt digger for HUSH-HUSH magazine.
All in all, I loved Crime Wave because it is a look at 1950s crime in L.A. I think Ellroy fans and non-Ellroy fans alike, should do themselves a favor and pick up a copy of CRIME WAVE.
Collectible price: $582.35
In his mystical quest, Fred Underhill will meet Dudley Smith, a L.A.P.D. lieutenant who'll have the career we know under James Ellroy's pen. Smith or/and the author does have an obsession : the "Black Dahlia" mystery he has been unable to solve. It's the second time in two books that Ellroy evokes this affair that will give a few years later its name to one of James Ellroy's most known novels. Another recurrent Ellroy theme appearing in CLANDESTINE is the description of the death of one of the serial killer's victim, similar to the circumstances of the death of the writer's own mother.
Fred Underhill is also a golf addict and a tormented human being who'll seek redemption during the five years he'll pass in order to solve the case he has discovered. I must confess that the last fifty pages of CLANDESTINE are so gripping that I couldn't leave the book for one minute before its ending.
A book to rediscover.
Many, it seems, felt the ending wrapped up too neatly or improbably, but it worked for me entirely. It's more than a warm-up for his best, BLACK DAHLIA, and stands on its own as noir. Ellroy shows us yet another facet of self-destruction redeemed in the nick of time so that at least SOME good can come from life's horrid injustices.
On a final note, I must confess, I am a dog lover, and the addition of Night-Train was comically wonderful (read it, and you will know what I'm talking about).
James, you've done it again!
List price: $12.95 (that's 20% off!)
Used price: $1.15
Collectible price: $5.00
Buy one from zShops for: $5.95
Don't even check it out of the library...
Used price: $2.99
Collectible price: $5.39
Buy one from zShops for: $4.44
"Dick Contino's Blues" is the best story in this collection. "High Darktown" is also good. The rest aren't very impressive. Having said that, I cannot wait until Ellroy's next novel.
Used price: $75.00
Collectible price: $34.95
I still enjoyed Hopkins as a character, but the whole premis of the book was strained, and there was no opportunity for the main character to really shine. Overall, a weak sister to Ellroy's other Hopkins stories, which are in turn pale comparisons to his other works like "LA Confidential" and "Black Dahlia."
Even if the twists of BECAUSE OF THE NIGHT are highly improbable, the novel still stays as intense as it was when I first read it seventeen years ago (gasp!). Ellroy was then one of the first writers to introduce serial killers in his books and was already a master in describing the psychology of his characters.
What strikes me the most now is the evident relation between the mad psychiatrist Havilland and the writer Ellroy. The symptoms of Havilland's madness are very similar to the creative process of the writer. Havilland tries to recreate traumatic scenes of his childhood by directing "live" the poor souls that have fallen in his trap. How not to recognize here the endless efforts of James Ellroy in order to exorcize his mother's murder books after books ?
So if you have the curiosity to go beyond the main argument of BECAUSE OF THE NIGHT, you will soon find out that this book is not only a unique opportunity given to the reader to analyze Lloyd Hopkins thanks John Havilland's psychological skill but is also a terrifying trip through James Ellroy's own obsessions.
A book to rediscover.
List price: $49.95 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $13.00
Buy one from zShops for: $32.92
It is absolutely fascinating to see how Ellroy succeeds at weaving through the labyrinth of historic events without ever losing the historic thread. And then the story: It goes crash, boon, bang, it's a staccato of plots, counterplots, intrigues, betrayls, murder, revenge, and redemption. The Cold Six Thousand is not a casual read, on the contrary: Its characters and events will remain with the reader for a long time.
Unfortunately, however, the book has more than its fair share of shortcomings.
One is the role the Mafia plays throughout the whole story. Ellroy tries to make us believe that the mob was THE driving force behind most of the events that made the 60s such an explosive pandemonium. Carlos Marcellos and Co. are portrayed as all-powerful and omnipotent. Is is almost as if the Outfit works like the law of nature: No man can escape it, even the mightiest must surrender to its will.
Then there are the never-ending outbursts of violence. Raw, graphic, violence that is. In one scene, a Mafia killer tells a fellow hitman how he cracked a woman's skull in a vice; in another, Ellroy describes with relish how Pete Bondurant takes a man out by tearing up and grabbing deep down his throat. In American Tabloid, the violence made sense; Ellroy used it to paint a realistic portrait of a violent era. In The Cold Six Thousand, much of the violence is superfluous and simply gross. I believe that a novelist talks to his readers; in American Tabloid Ellroy seemed to say "I don't like this epidemic of violence, either, but it is my duty as a chronicler to report it". In this book, however, he actually seems to enjoy and take pleasure in it.
Another problem is the language. Short, fragmented sentences. Sometimes they actually add to the excitement; more often, though, they are plainly annoying.
Finally, I feel that Ellroy is a much better writer of hard-boiled fiction than of romance. Too many men fall in love with too few women. Wayne loves Lynette, Janice, and Barb. Littel loves Jane, Barb, and Janice. How these women hold such an attraction for every man they run across and make them not just want them but actually truly love them remains a mystery.
In conclusion, I would like to stress my belief that a GREAT writer like Ellroy is clearly not oblivious to these flaws (at least not to the ones that have been pointed out by a large number of reviewers, which gives our criticism a certain degree of legitimacy). As a matter-of-fact, I don't know very much about him, but I can't help my suspicion that he feels he has reached a level that gives him the right not to give a damn about his readers. I will most definitely read the last book in the series once it is publised; however, I also feel it is time to move on and turn to another author.
List price: $13.00 (that's 20% off!)
Used price: $3.30
Collectible price: $6.34
Buy one from zShops for: $8.32
Without giving away too much of the book, the most chilling moment for me is a scene where two serial killers meet and compare notes. Their conversation could almost be that of two traveling salesmen comparing sales territories. The ordinariness of this scene is what made it so terrifying for me. Monsters with human faces, not numb, but indifferent, to what they do, will surface again in later Ellroy novels, but their closeness to rest of the world has not been drawn as sharp as it is here.
1) People say serial killers are really like the character in this book.
2) This book's plot os not as intricate as those found in other Ellroy books.
I can agree with 2 but I've never been inside the mind of a serial killer so I can't vouch for 1. However, I have to say that I found Pluncket a believable serial killer, and to me, that's all that matters. I don't really believe that all serial killers must fit into a certian profile; there are many unsolved murders in the world that are probably the world of serial killers who do not.
I found this book to be as interesting as other Ellroy books because of the intense focus on a single character as compared to looks at a number of characters that are not as detailed. I personally enjoy the characterizations in Ellroy's books more than the plots, although I do appreciate both. So this book was a treat for me.
I have to agree with some other reviewers, though, that the end of the book was less satisfying than the beginning. Using the "end at the beginning" format did not impress me, nor did some of the final moments of the book.
Despite a few small complaints and some dissimilarity to Ellroy's other work, I would reccomend this book to any Ellroy fan or to those interested in intense characterizations.
Used price: $9.95
Collectible price: $7.00
Buy one from zShops for: $19.98
Although there are glimpses of the darkness and passion that Ellroy would perfect in his later novels, I can't recommend shelling out for the hardcover. If you must, you must. Hey, I know what it's like: I'm an Ellroy addict, and I know how it is to "jones" for his pitiless, high octane vision. This isn't it. Alas.
I love that these books take place in the '80's. When you read other Ellroys you wonder what his take on the "modern world" would be. I found it just as relentless and glorious as the other time periods used in his later novels. Ellroy was writing these at the same time Brett Easton Ellis was writing Less Than Zero, the same time that the movie To Live and Die in L.A. appeared in theatres. This is a time and place in American history with tremendous dramatic literary potential. The fact that Ellroy's characters and story lines could exist in the 40's, 50's or 60's, with bourbon and jazz replacing cocaine and punk is a testement to Ellroy's undeniable brilliance.
And Lloyd Hopkins, the hero of these novels? He lacks the charm of a Spenser or Carella, posesses the demons and frailties of a Robicheaux or Scudder, but is still an Ellroy original. Love him or hate him while you read these books, but I guarantee you'll miss him when you're done.
Read L.A. Confidential or American Tabloid for the best Ellroy there is. Read L.A. Noir and just enjoy Ellroy.
Martin Plunkett is a serial killer and his narrative interspersed with newspaper clippings tells of his murderous and depraved odyssey in 70's America.Evil told in the accents and tone of one recounting a trip to the shopping mall,
Midway through the book Ellroy pulls a twist that throws the reader shrwedly off balance and keeps him that way throughout
I admired the book but without really liking it,maybe its that I like a moral centre to my crime writing and this is a massively amoral book
Just like the century that spawned it Ellroy's book is a fascinating,compelling thing but dont look for the easy resolution of empty comfort of the archetypal crime novel
Fiction as reality ,not as escapism