Now the newly promoted Captain Benjamin Sisko of Deep Space Nine has another problem: a massive fleet of Klingon warships has arrived at DS9 on a secret mission. Unable to learn anything from an elusive Klingon general, Sisko turns to Lt. Commander Worf, formerly of the Starship Enterprise. Being the only Klingon in Starfleet, he is asked to try and uncover the truth.
What will happen next will be yours to find out.
Used price: $0.74
Collectible price: $3.18
Buy one from zShops for: $2.50
The whole premise of the story is that the Federation is fighting a war against the Dominion, and losing. This is drilled into us, time and again, throughout the book. And yet we never really see this losing. Just about every battle or conflict that is shown here is won, and even when the station is evacuated, it's not really a horrible defeat -- the evac is done on Sisko's own terms. This shouldn't really seem so bad, except it's jarring because that's the whole point of the book, it seems. This book is so proud of itself, filled with little cliches and epiphanies about the nature of war, the devastation, the horror, and yet we see nothing of that except the talk.
However, the book still would have been salvageable if it had had some decent writing, editing, and length. The word Jem'Hadar is not spelled correctly *once* in the entire novel, and even such basic Star Trek words as Cochrane are misspelled. Often sentences are grammatically unsound, and it's unsettling to be jarred out of a battle scene by a sentence that just doesn't make any sense. And worst of all, none of the scenes are written memorably.
And the adaptation isn't that great. Presumably in an effort to save space, there were occasional whole passages that were nothing but dialogue -- no description or anything. While that can be very effective if done right, here it was just annoying. In addition, there were many battle scenes and crash scenes that weren't included in the shows for budget reasons -- and yet for some reason they didn't appear here, either, although the book could have been much more dramatic and fulfilling if they had, rather than just showing us "before the crash" and "after the crash" scenes.
There were a couple of high points here -- Worf's relationship with Alexander and Martok was much more effective here than on the show, and also we got a good look at Jem'Hadar thought processes and motivations here.
Unfortunately, overall this book just wasn't very good and isn't worth getting. Not enough effort, it seems, was put into it to be able to really take anything out of it.
Used price: $0.74
Collectible price: $3.00
Buy one from zShops for: $2.50
That's what the book is supposed to be about. Forget all of that. The Romulans, the plague, Ambassador Spock and Dr. McCoy are all on the sidelines. The real story is about two young people. One is a Starfleet officer who desperately wants to live up to the legacy of his ancestors who served with Captain Kirk and fought in the Romulan Wars. The other, Zevon, is a Romulan prince and scientist, wracked with the guilt that a simple experiment he created led to the destabilization of an entire world. Both spent four years together as POWs in Red Sector, an area of space sealed off from the rest of the galaxy because of its political instability and hostility to aliens. Stiles eventually gained his freedom, but Zevon remained. Now years later, it is up to Stiles to rescue his friend and return him to Romulus, for his untainted blood is the last great hope for a cure.
If this all sounds complicated, it is. Diane Carey is a wonderful veteran Trek writer, but the plot jumps all over the damn place. She tries to do too many things in too little space. You've got the plague, the conspiracy behind it, the Romulans and all of their political intrigue, one last adventure for Spock and McCoy, Eric Stiles' maturation from a young ensign to a hero and officer in his own right, and Zevon's fight to bring peace and stability back to the planet his experiment had ruined.
Nitpicks: 1) This is supposed to be a medical thriller but it's not. 2) The mastermind villain becomes so mysterious he's almost like a cartoon character. 3) Red Sector is such an artificial plot device. I just can't believe the Federation, Romulans, and everybody else would seal off an area of space just because of some anti-alien hostility on a primitive world. 4) For various reasons, it makes much more sense to have Dr. McCoy treating the Romulan royals than Dr. Crusher, who starts acting just like him in her bedside manner. 5) The Top Gun stuff gave me a headache.
Despite all of this, the book is still fun to read. Why? Because the characterization is excellent. Ambassador Spock and Dr. McCoy don't appear often, and rarely together, but when they do they shine. You really do feel like you're seeing legends at work. Even more impressive is the creation of a strong character such as Eric Stiles completely out of scratch. His transformation from a young inexperienced ensign to a hero worthy of Kirk makes up more than enough for all of the book's many flaws.
Used price: $0.01
Collectible price: $4.75
Buy one from zShops for: $2.00
Like I mentioned, this book seems to tie some lose ends together. There are two main themes in this book that seem to be rather seperated, but later on in the book become apparent that they do interplay. The first is the U.S.S. Bozeman after fighting the Klingon's 70 years earlier is now in their future and we find out what they were up to then as it affects what is going on now. Another time warp anomaly mixing the twenty-third and the twenty-fourth century's timelines. Well, the U.S.S. Bozeman and her Captain, Morgan Bateson are now in their relative future. Bateson pulls rank on Picard and takes the new Starship Enterprise 1701-E on a shakedown, but that's not all as Bateson believes the Klingon Empire is building it's forces and is preparing to strike the Federation. Now the newly minted Enterprise is on a mission to thwart the threat. Secondly, Captain Jean-Luc Picard is sent on a mission to release Federation prisioners held by the Cardassians. As Gul Madred and Picard work out the details for the release Picard hears about what Bateson is upto.
From the book "Relics" Scotty is onboard the new Entrprise as are via holodeck James T. Kirk and others. As Picard works out logistics with Kirk. Captain Bateson is not without enemies and of course the Klingons will oblige with Kozara who has been nursing a grudge for decades.
Now, Captain Jean-Luc Picard has to decide... choose whether to take back command or let Bateson continue. This book pits present Star Trek with past Star Trek as Carey tries to blend it all together. The book moves quickly and the narrative is lively enough to keep your interest... and the out come is in doubt till close to the end of the story.
After the giving us the back story on how the Bozeman's encounter with a Klingon warship led to their being flung into the future, there are two main plot lines to "Ship of the Line." First, Captain Bateson has taken advantage of his seniority in Starfleet to not only oversee the construction of the Enterprise-E but also be in command of its shakedown cruise. Riker and the rest of the bridge crew join Scotty and the Bozeman's original crew, unaware that Bateson's old Klingon adversary Kozara is once again gunning for him. Meanwhile, Picard is heading off to the Cardassian Empire to negotiate with Gul Madred for the release of Federation prisoners. Eventually, of course, these two plotlines will converge. Carey, an avid sailor, works in numerous lines from C. S. Forester's Horatio Hornblower novels, and much of the starship action seems more fitting for the high seas than deep space. What will not surprise you is that although Captain Bateson had only a line or two in "Cause and Effect," the character is clearly patterned on Kelsey Grammer. How could you proceed otherwise? In the end we are back to the cover of "Ship of the Line," for it is how Picard deals with Gul Madred and Bateson deals with Kozara that provides the twin climaxes to the novel. There is so much going on here that ultimately the story is simply carrying too much weight, but this is definitely a worthwhile story and an above average effort from Carey. Clearly this is a labor of love for her on many levels.
Used price: $2.64
Collectible price: $3.69
Buy one from zShops for: $2.90
Nick Keller and crew are the lone Starfleet presence in the recently settled Belle Terre sector. A very different type of crew on a very unique vessel. So it seems appropriate that Keller and company find themselves slap dab in the middle of a really weird situation. What are they to do with a ship full of animated corpses that seems bound and determined to destroy them, and what is it doing in their little corner of space anyway? It's a mystery all right.
This is the type of novel a reader either likes or loathes. A story you really have to pay attention to. Definitely not a light read. I enjoyed the plot immensely and the characters. But at the same time I found the writing style to be a bit too descriptive, very typical Diane Carey. The story is filled with confusion at times, and then suddenly there is a startling moment of clarity. "Chainmail" is certainly different that's for sure. So if you feel in the mood for something different, a mystery/adventure with a true Science Fiction touch and unique characters give it a try. If you're looking for a Star Trek novel of the kind you are typically used to then I would pass on "Chainmail".
One problem with Star Trek books is that the authors have to use characters, locations, and situations that are already familiar to us from hours of TV and movies. You miss the creativity of sci-fi epics where the writer shapes the whole universe (Dune, Heinlein, etc)
Which is why I enjoy the Challenger novels (and Peter David's Excalibur series) -- the authors are free to create totally new crews, and getting to know new characters is exciting.
For instance, in "Challenger", we saw a lot of self-doubt and second-guessing from Nick Keller. There's less of that in "Chainmail" -- he's more confident and more assertive. We see him growing as a Starfleet officer.
This book starts off fairly slowly, and early on there are some chapters written from the aliens' perspective where you have no idea what's going on -- a device I'm not fond of. However, by about halfway through the book all the threads of the story come together, and I couldn't put it down. It's got all the elements that make TOS my favorite Star Trek franchise: a clash of cultures, a mysterious, ancient and powerful civilization, eccentric characters, and a minimum of techno-babble. The characters rely on their brains and diplomacy rather than on technology.
Unfortunately, the novel is just a first part, with a "to be continued" at the end. But at least the book was good enough that I'm anxiously awaiting the continuation.
I am amazed I liked this so much, because I see so clearly in my head Bones and Data when they speak in the easy, familiar books I have read, and this is all new stuff, and like algebra instead of multiplication.
I have read every single pocket books star trek novel of every series, so I know of what i speak.
Out of the 4 or 5 hundred novels to date, this easily makes the top 50, and just might be in the top 25.
Bring on more Keller, Diane! You got all the magic!
Used price: $0.01
Collectible price: $2.66
Buy one from zShops for: $2.25
But as I said earlier, a lot of Star Trek fiction just doesn't appeal to me. Maybe because it just keeps getting churned out month after month you get saturated by it. And these big inter-series crossover events happen once a year as well. So I really cannot recommend this book.
Used price: $0.01
Collectible price: $1.55
Buy one from zShops for: $3.00
But this book sets a new low standard for Star Trek: The Next Generation novels, at least in my experience. To give her some (limited) credit, Diane Carey tries to deepen this tale beyond a repeat of the script and descriptions of the sets. But she simply lacks the skill, let alone the talent, to do so with any success. Heavy use of a thesaurus and a scattering of awkward, or simply weird, similes, are not a substitute for writing ability. The characters are not brought to life in any recognisable way, and the tone of the whole book is simply off. I continually found myself being surprised by the way the author used/misused the English language. Carey cannot be held responsible, though, for the way the story degenerates in the second half of the book, as Hugh reappears, Lore reveals himself to be a messiah-figure to the Borg, and way too much time is devoted to Dr Crusher's experience of commanding the Enterprise.
On a related note, two things about the storyline really bothered me. First, that Dr Crusher was placed in command of the Enterprise at all is bad enough; that she is never punished for her selfish refusal to obey Captain Picard's orders to go and get help beggars belief. Second, Data executes Lore. Why is it that Lore is never awarded the same rights and considerations as Data? Why can he be switched off permanently because it seems convenient to do so? Why are the consequences of this act to Data never addressed? We have to assume he feels no guilt at all over what he has done.
In the hands of another author, this could have been a very good tale to bring to life as a book. Unfortunately, Carey was a poor choice. Watch the TV episode instead.
I was looking forward to a grand sweeping adventure featuring TOS entire crew, plus hopefully some interesting characters among the colonists. What I feel I got was a big isn't Kirk the greatest saga. Don't get me wrong, I like Capt. Kirk as much as the next fan. But come on. Almost 2/3's of the text is Kirk talking to himself about how heroic he is forced to be. The other crew members are underutilized. In fact they are barely used at all. Chekov gets a good storyline for once, but it is much too brief and one of the books few highlights.
We are introduced to a few colonists in a cursory way. There are a couple of potentially interesting characters but they aren't used well. Too bad to. It had the makings of a grand adventure. I would pass on this one if I were you. I usually enjoy Diane Carey's Trek novels but this one sadly disappionts.
All in all, I've got to say this is a good start to the series. What really works is that Carey plunks us down in the middle of the story and fills in details via flashbacks and the characters interacting. The series takes place between the events seen in The Motion Picture and Wrath of Khan and finds Kirk, having temporarily taken a reduction in rank to Captain, leading a fleet of colonists to a new world that is nine months away. The first novel sets up the secondary characters and establishes the mood and the scene. It also sets into place the fact that the planet our heroes are headed for isn't what it seems (frustratingly enough, one of the characters knows what is going on but refuses to tell any one or give any hints....oh well, I guess it is a six-part series and we'll find out soon enough). Before you know it, Kirk is up to his ears in squabbles, disputes and egos other than his. It's interesting look at Kirk as he tries to deal with leading a group of people that aren't in Starfleet and don't necessarily want or have to follow his orders. There's internal intrigue as well as an external threat or two (the planet the colonists are heading for is at the center of two, ancient warring races and the Orions aren't far behind--seeing the colonists as potential profit in the slave trade). Carey balances a lot of elements to make an entertaining novel and one that sets up events well. The stage is set for the next five books and there's enough mysteries involved to keep me curious as what's to come next.
My only fear is that we won't find out the planet's myterious secret until book six and the other four books will be a holding pattern of sorts. Also, minor characters are being set up to be in conflict and you can see some of Kirk's headahces that are ahead. I only hope Carey and the rest of the authors will take some chances and not give into a standard, cliched Trek storyline.
All that said, I will say that Wagon Train to the Stars is a good start. It's an enjoyable summer Trek read--not too heavy, but not too light. I'm definitely interested to see what happens next.
Throughout the novel, Kirk and his crew deal with a variety of situations which have been created out of tales of old west wagon trains but now with a sci fi twist. Kirk is essentially the trail boss dealing with dissension, food shortages, colonist fear and finally maurauders as the wagon train makes its way to its new planet.
I found the starship battles to be very interesting and the battle tactics reminiscent of the old Star Trek. The plot line is a good concept and the novel is a good start for a six book series but I found the characters to be a bit different from the characters which we all know and love. For instance, Kirk is a bit more authoritarian than usual. All together though a good, fun read.
Used price: $1.07
So very much of Ghost Ship is wasted space. Riker insults Data. Geordi throws a tantrum about it. Riker and Deanna wonder if they can maintain a friendship. Geordi whines about his VISOR. Riker wonders if Tasha likes to wear comfortable shoes (yes, that's right). None of it is particularly moving or interesting. True, Carey was tasked with writing a Next Generation novel very early on in the series - perhaps before she was able to see any of the episodes? But that should have been all the more reason to *avoid* character introspection, and focus instead on what could have been an interesting plotline. The occasionally grossly overdone prose ("[Deanna's] eyes, extra large with their touch of alienness, obisidan as eyes that looked out of a Greco-Roman fresco . . . .") further keeps Ghost Ship from reaching the three-star plateau that most Trek books earn.
While the plot is disappointing, the interaction among the main characters is worthwhile if for no other reason than to contrast the original concept with their eventual, more developed, incarnations. The highlights are the budding relationship between Giordi and Data and the contradictory early relationship between Deanna and Riker. But at the same time, Giordi is painted as an arrogant and insubordinant brat and Riker an incompetent buffoon when the two are on the bridge.
Bottom line: This isn't a horrible novel, but there are many superior Star Trek books out there (some of them written by Diane Carey herself). If you are going to invest the time it takes to read a book, invest it in one you'll get more out of.