Used price: $1.84
Collectible price: $5.50
Buy one from zShops for: $4.90
Used price: $43.52
List price: $14.99 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $4.99
Buy one from zShops for: $9.85
In the same order package, I purchased 'Telling Lies for Fun and Profit -- A Manuel for Fiction Writers.' I was very dissapointed to find that the second book was an almost verbatim version of the 'Writing the Novel...' book.
Keeping that in mind, if/when you order either of the books, go for the cheapest used version you can get of either because Mr. Block tells the same anecdotes, the same thoughts, and information in both books--almost verbatim.
I just wish that on either of the books information, either in Amazon or Printer's Editorial/Description, it would have been noted that the first book was a rewrite of the second (or vice versa).
As to the value of the information that is provided in either book--it's OK, but nothing earthshattering that will help you write a blockbuster novel. The text itself reads easily, as if you were having a conversation with Mr. Block in the same room. Very friendly and easy to understand--nothing you would need a college degree to comprehend.
Used price: $3.00
Used price: $3.24
Collectible price: $15.88
Fans of Lawrence Block should check out this book for a different view of an author who normally produces great novels.
Used price: $6.25
Collectible price: $10.00
There's a lot of recapping going on -- in the first few chapters, Block retells four or five stories from the earlier novels, which turns out to be necessary for the plot, but which is a bit tiresome for those of us who've already read those stories before. The bits of business with Elaine are perfectly believable, but ripe with the sort of squashy domesticity that has sapped some of the noir juice out of the most recent installments in the Scudder story. Jive-talking TJ has always been something of an embarrassment, and he remains one here, although his schtick is (thankfully) somewhat toned down. And there's a "spring cleaning" feeling to the whole affair, as legions of the series' supporting characters are offed. Not that Block (or Scudder) doesn't treat the deaths with sufficient gravity -- it's just that you get the feeling of an author saying, "Let's wipe the slate clean and start Scudder off on a new path, with less baggage." (Which may be a good thing for the next Scudder novel -- less recapping to be done, perhaps -- but it casts a shadow over this one.)
The book isn't bad, not by a long shot, but it doesn't sparkle (on the whole) with the sheer brilliance of the best Scudders.
Perhaps it's because Block can seem like several writers sharing the same name - the author of the Evan Tanner series vs. the author of the Matt Scudder series vs. the author of the Bernie Rhodenbarr series - so readers may not know what to expect when they see the latest Block on the (real or virtual) bookstore shelf. If they pass this one up, though, it's their loss. This is hard-boiled detective fiction done to absolute perfection, and ranks up at the top not only of Block's output (although "Eight Million Ways to Die" still finds a soft spot in my heart), but among the great works of the genre going back all the way back to Hammett and Chandler.
Hyperbole? Perhaps. Buy it anyway.
List price: $25.00 (that's 72% off!)
Scudder is a constantly evolving character. In the earliest novels, he was a standard hard-boiled private eye, but soon he came to terms with his inner demons (in particular, his alcoholism) and learned how to reconstruct his life. Now, he is sixty-two, not as inclined to get in dangerous situations, but still out to expose murderers.
This case deals with a couple who is killed in a home invasion robbery. Soon, the killers are themselves dead in a murder-suicide, but Scudder, when drawn into the case, begins to think there is a third man. Along with his investigation, he is involved with a subplot involving the death of his ex-wife and his relationship with his estranged sons.
Block is always at his best when writing about Scudder, and this case is no exception. Admittedly, this book works best if you have read the others in the series, but even as a standalone, this is a good novel.
HIT MAN is a short story collection about one of the best characters to arrive on the urban crime noir scene in years. Instead of being a hero, Keller is an anti-hero. The stories are all trademark Lawrence Block: gritty, exciting, and entertaining. However, what makes this terrific book so appealing is that Keller could be the guy next door taking out your sister on a date. To make matters even more interesting, Keller, despite his profession, is a likeable character. Let's hope for more Keller works in the near future. He is fascinating!
Harriet Klausner
Used price: $1.40
Collectible price: $3.67
Buy one from zShops for: $4.69
So much for explaining the concept of the series. The Burglar in the Closet is the second book in the series. I strongly suggest that you begin the series by reading Burglars Can't Be Choosers. Each story in the series adds information and characters in a way that will reduce your pleasure of the others if read out of order. Although, I originally read them out of order and liked them well enough. I'm rereading them now in order, and like it much better this way. The Burglar Who Liked to Quote Kipling comes next in the series.
As Stephen King likes to point out, a great way to start a book is to put a character in an unusual situation and then let things happen from there. The Burglar in the Closet certainly follows that route in a successful manner with what reads and feels like a very realistic (and hilarious to think about) burglary experience.
The complications soon start coming from all directions like sharpened spears, and Bernie's ducking before one of them hits him! Along the way you'll meet The World's Greatest Dentist and his hygienist, some remarkably vivid barflies, and visit again with the brilliant, but bent cop, Ray Kirschmann from Burglars Can't Be Choosers. Bernie gets accused of just about everything but what he actually did, and as before, straightens matters out through his own investigation.
I thought that the identity of the more serious criminal was pretty obvious, but the plot develops in such a witty, charming way that I didn't really mind. The plot is pretty complicated, and will keeep you on your toes . . . so pay attention!
This book is definitely a step up from Burglars Can't Be Choosers and really establishes the series as a solid one for fans of off-beat mysteries.
As I read this book, I was reminded of Murphy's Law (anything that can go wrong, will). Most of the unpleasant situations in our lives come about because we ignore Mr. Murphy. This book will certainly remind you to think through what could go wrong . . . before you go ahead.
Donald Mitchell
Co-author of The 2,000 Percent Solution, The Irresistible Growth Enterprise and The Ultimate Competitive Advantage
The Matt Scudder character is the important feature of this book as we follow his tortured journey around New York City chasing up clues in a long-dead case. He unearths clues and leads as a good detective should, but it's his battle with the bottle that proves the most fascinating story. He finally gets a good hard smack across the chops in this book which may help put him on the road to sobriety, at least, it scares him enough to consider he may need help.
This is another fine example of an outstanding modern hardboiled mystery, just part of an outstanding hardboiled series.