Used price: $4.80
Used price: $2.25
Used price: $10.58
But the central focus of this volume is her love affair with Chicago writer Nelson Algren ('The Man with the Golden Arm'). She meets Algren on a tour she makes of the United States that is funded by a group that brings her over on a reading/lecture tour. (She and Sartre are now becoming famous by the years of this book, 1944 to 1952.) She spends time with him in the United States, making a trip south through the southwest, Mexico and Guatamala with him, which she doesn't outline completely here as she has written of it more extensively in her book 'America Day by Day.' The relationship runs its course within the pages of this book as Algren gives up on her ever being for him what he wants, remarrying his ex-wife by the last pages. Resigned to this fate, not able to leave Sartre or France (though she and Sartre seem to have an agreement to share finances, take long vacations together and work together, they never lived together and are free to see others as they wish), she is still very disappointed by the end of the affair. On the last visit to his cabin outside Chicago, she says she is glad they have come to a mutual understanding and will be friends. Algren replies to her that he can never offer her anything less than love.
The French intelligentsia during this time are grappling with the knowledge of the Holocaust and the onset of the Cold War. Sartre and de Beauvoir were deeply sympathetic with the world's communists, but Sartre never joined the party, apparently because he couldn't countenance on a daily basis the 'thought-control' aspect of the central committee. De Beauvoir writes quite a bit about the various left and right publications in Paris at the time, the political views of their editorial boards and the personal and political attacks that were made from their various pages. Their friendship with Camus breaks up by the end of the book as he has become too anti-communist for Sartre and de Beauvoir and the other editors of their monthly publication, Les Temps Modernes.
This was a much quicker read than the first two, but engaging in the same episodic way. I don't know if it could as easily stand on its own, as she references many things from the second volume as if one should know of them. The story of her love affair with Algren is very moving and sad, and she writes from time to time of difficult times, emotionally, as she ages and confronts herself as a woman in her 40s, making a name for herself.
Used price: $1.99
Collectible price: $5.99
Buy one from zShops for: $12.99
This one was harder to break into than the first, I felt, as she began somewhat vaguely about her philosophy, the things she was working on, etc. The first part of the book vaguely and distantly describes the beginning of her relationship with Jean-Paul Sartre, so the personal is perhaps rather squashed here (maybe that's why I found it less engaging than "Memoirs of a Dutiful Daughter" at first). But as I made my way forward, I found the same compelling qualities of the first, and more -- as de Beauvoir is older: Her interests and her circle of friends are expanding.
This book is interesting on so many levels, and I would recommend it to stand on its own (it doesn't have to be read as part of the whole), as well. It's interesting, as the first one was, for the way she describes her life in Paris at the time (she names all the cafes, neighborhoods, etc., that she frequents), and, as the first one, because it still dwells on how she is beginning her professional life that would lead her to be one of the foremost twentieth century philosophers and writers. So it's got something on both personal and broader themes.
But this book also adds the elements of the writer, as during its years, de Beauvoir writes her first books "She Came to Stay" and "The Blood of Others." I like to read about how writers work, their processes, and de Beauvoir very interestingly dissects her work in retrospect, writing things like, "What I was trying to accomplish at the time through Francoise's character was... but I see now that she comes across as ..." De Beauvoir was a very vigilant and disciplined worker, researcher and writer, and she writes of these routines. For writers interested in how others work, where they get their ideas and how they edit and redraft, I would certainly recommend this.
But this work is also interesting on another level; its most compelling part is when she details the beginning of WWII and the occupation of Paris. Rather than summarize it with the view the passing years have given her, de Beauvoir excerpts her diaries from the time, so that the reader feels the fears, understands the unknown dangers that she felt and gets the immediacy and intimacy of the worries of Parisiens such as de Beauvoir. I really couldn't put these sections down as she wrote about fleeing the Nazi occupiers, then deciding that if Sartre were released, he would only be able to find her in Paris and her desperate journey home again.
The book also starts a theme I can see will continue in all of them, outlining her travels as she (sometimes alone, sometimes with Sartre or others) goes around France and abroad and writes of how she feels and what she discovers there. In this volume, to name a few, she goes to Greece, Spain and all over
France.
The voice of these autobiographies is somewhat distant and aloof, which I find useful, as she seems intent on presenting her life very objectively, but when Sartre is attacked or criticized, she loses this coolness of tone and makes personal attacks on his critics.
The last aspect I'll mention of this long volume (nearly 500 pages) is the circle of friends she creates. She happens to befriend Alberto Giacometti, who is my favorite artist, in Paris and writes very fondly of his intellect and engaging conversations. She meets Hemingway and is an aquaintance of Picasso and his longtime lover Dora Marr. She also meets Cocteau through Sartre's theatrical work.
I found the wartime writing of this second one particularly engaging and probably of wider interest than the episodes of de Beauvoir's daily life later on... but we'll see!
List price: $16.00 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $4.89
Collectible price: $9.95
Buy one from zShops for: $10.52
Is the book overly long? Probably. Melodramatic? At times. Too cluttered with phrases of the "smiled knowingly" variety? Without a doubt. But it's redeemed time and again by the keen intelligence Beauvoir brings to bear on her characters and herself. For days after I put the book down, I found myself literally pining for the company of Anne, Lewis and Henri. Is there any greater testament to a novel than that?
DeBeauvior takes these questions and makes them human, and gives hope to our world. But, with any great existentialist thinker, makes the point that living is hard. To exist well we must make choices and be able to live with them. All of the characters in this book show the angst and chaos of war. How they are able to live with each other and themselves is displayed with amazing depth and insight. The complexities of women are shown vividly - especially if you have read The Second Sex. Each of the woman characters are shown struggling with their societial place as Other, yet, show this trancendence that is even more important to her gender.
This is also an incredible demonstration of the power and pain of love. I read this book as a teenager and found that I reread it at least once a year to remind me of the beauty and pain of life. It is a wonderful book about being a woman, and a thinker. I recommend it to anyone who is disturbed about events in this world and how to deal with them.
Used price: $0.01
Collectible price: $2.50
What I do find most interesting, however, is how De Beauvoir (who consults her over-rated companion Sartre in the memoir) seems to be preaching Albert Camus' concept of the quantitative life, and living life with full consciousness. Ultimately, the memoir is rather tragic because De Beauvoirs' dying, once inauthentic mother realizes this on her death bed, when it's too late. It's an excellent message, and although it's better from Camus' pen, it is interesting hearing it from De Beauvoir as well.
List price: $14.00 (that's 20% off!)
Used price: $5.28
Buy one from zShops for: $9.31
Anyway, to get to the book, this book is not like "All Men are Mortal" or "The Second Sex" in that, there is less advocation and pontificating going on here (this is a neutral judgment, by the way). It is more straightforward fiction; I would liken it to a minimalization of Balzac's view for the French society: It captures three woman in sharp, short snapshots at specific points in lives. What comes of this? Read and find out.
Used price: $0.43
Collectible price: $2.50
While Simone de Beauvoir grew up in one of the most privileged families in France and went to all the best institutions, and never worked a day in her life, she nevertheless, along with a great number of the French left, fell under the sway of Chairman Mao in the 1950s and never recovered. A companion volume to this read would be Julia Kristeva's Chinese Women.
The two of these feminists, still considered stellar intellectuals in the world of women's studies, were both simply Maoists for a great part of their life, and a great deal of their thinking went into supporting and amplifying the Chinese Cultural Revolution. The Cultural REvolution is now being relived in every women's studies program in America.
Read this book. It is central to understanding the French mentality in the 1970s and the American mentality today in women's studies.
I felt that the first third of the book, dealing with philosophy (particularly existentialism), and Freudian psychoanalysis, was not as interesting or informative as the latter parts of the book. While some people may disagree, I tend to dislike using a lot of big words to describe simple things, as often happens with philosophers and psychoanalists.
The remainder of the book, dealing with women at different times of their lives, or in different situations, was stronger. Its major deficiency was its being dated, but a large number of her arguments are very relevant today. Many of her then novel reasonings are now standard modern political fare, for example, her arguments about abortion. It was interesting to see them in the original.
Overall, despite its importance, I cannot give this book five stars. It has simply lost too much relevance over the years. The best arguments from this book have become part of the standard fare, while the weaker ones have been lost in time. A modern reader of this book will not gain much insight into women as they are now, but merely a historical view of women and the feminist movement. While this is still a worthwhile goal, "The Second Sex" is simply not as important as it once was.
Used price: $1.79
Collectible price: $6.75
Buy one from zShops for: $8.99
List price: $10.95 (that's 20% off!)
Used price: $1.47
Collectible price: $5.00
Buy one from zShops for: $7.56
If you're really into existentialism, I'd recommend it. If you're into Simone de Beauvoir, stick to the Second Sex, which is a much better read, and her fiction.