While the book (actually more of a booklet) is a low budget presnetation ( a couple of drawings, a few maps) the value of the information presented is well worth the price. Its simply one of the best sources of information on the market about this topic and will prove invaluable to anyone researching COIN or LIC.
Used price: $25.00
Buy one from zShops for: $25.20
I have taught music theory and aural comprehension to well over 1000 music students at New York University. These future performers and composers hail from a wide variety of musical backgrounds - classical, jazz, rock, music technology, and music theater - and I have instructed them in ear-training techniques that are similar in methodology to Mr. Arnold's. These techniques have caused dramatic improvement in almost all students that have applied themselves and allotted sufficient time for practice.
In the 10 years of our acquaintance, Bruce Arnold has consistently impressed me with his abilities as a performer, composer, and educator. I share his philosophy of ear-training instruction and feel that he has realized it in a highly functional and useful manner with his books and CDs. For these reasons, I especially recommend his materials to my students, as I recommend them to anyone with the desire to expend effective hard work in the pursuit of their musical aspirations.
Klaus Sinfelt, Assistant Director of Music Theory, Department of Music and Performing Arts Professions, New York University
List price: $25.00 (that's 30% off!)
The method seems helpful, and it is set up quite nicely. ... Was this a needless expense? I guess the explanatory essay might be worth it, but it mostly serves as a reassuring authority of the "relation" principle--for example, no matter what key you are in, or how many octaves apart the tone is, the root note is the root note; the seventh is the seventh; the flat sixth is the...you get the idea. The cds might be worth it for convienience's sake alone, perhaps. (By the way make sure your player has shuffle, or you'll memorize the order of answers. Also, the exercises are with piano, not guitar. I find this no problem, but you might.) Another annoyance is Arnold's acceptance of the Key of C paradigm that pervades music instruction. All three cds use C. Why not use different keys on each disc? Just to prove your point? It should not make a difference if the premise is right, but it would be refreshing to the student and increase her or his confidence.
Take note this is a frustrating set. (But this is coming from someone who has never been able to play anything "by ear".) The learning process is intense for the "ear-challenged" such as myself, but this seems like it'd work better than the other methods, or by random luck or wishful thinking. You are basically asked to proceed by intuition, or some likewise indescribable way of learning. A serious trial by fire. If you need a "how do I do it" guide this is not the place to come. It's more like learning a language by being surrounded by it for a long time, and *not* by someone handing you a vocab list and rules for turning the present tense into the past: you'll learn it, and you might even be better at it because it's *in* you, so to speak, rather than *on* you. But it is an intense and probably prolonged experience.
I hope this helps you decide whether this is for you, and if it is worth the price. I haven't noticed any improvement in myself that I am not convinced isn't just luck; but it could be so subtle I don't see it yet. I do imagine it will help. Time will tell.
His approach focuses on identifing (naming) pitches you hear with reference to a "key center" that you perceive when you listen to a short musical phrase, a motif or a cadence, etc.
This helps especially during live gigs which require my responses to other musicians's playing.
I have worked on eartraining for years, in college as a music major, and after college, ongoing for over 10 years. I could never get the traction I wanted, no matter how I worked. And really, I couldn't tell that anyone else had either.
Turns out that I had been trained in every counter-productive method Mr. Arnold mentions in his work. A lot of horrible habits, given to me by people I trusted...
Those habits are really, REALLY hard to break. But I now believe that it can be done. And after so much sweat over so much time, I'm now certain that the level of hearing I've wanted for so long really is possible. It's really HARD, and I expect to be working on this for years. But, hey... I also expect to be a musician until I die, so it's very much worth the work to do it right.
(One last note: when I first read Mr. Arnold's writing on this method I nearly cried. It was like he'd looked at everything I was doing wrong and all the time I'd wasted and said, very directly, "You should stop that. And you should grit your teeth and do this, if you really want to fix anything." Honestly, the man had my number. Maybe he has yours. You got the guts?)
Used price: $19.99
Buy one from zShops for: $48.99
Used price: $42.31
Buy one from zShops for: $46.95
List price: $45.00 (that's 30% off!)
Used price: $2.15
Collectible price: $4.70
Buy one from zShops for: $4.38
Then somewhere along the line, the book loses what little bit of charm it has and suddenly you're finding yourself not liking Phoebe that much. As each man revolves his way through her life, you begin to dislike her and her choices more and more. Some of the boyfriends listed aren't even boyfriends but rather fantasy characters, penpals and in the case of Arnold Allen (the only Black guy who stereotypically appears on her list) a criminal. By the end of the novel you're thinking that she deserves everything that has happened to her. Some guys aren't good enough, others are too good and why doesn't she have any friends? One word for you Phoebe: THERAPY!!
At first I thought this was going to be a Sheila Levine for the new millenium. Whereas Sheila's self-depreciating humor and poor choices in men endeared you to her, Phoebe's self depreciating humor had you hoping she would grab a bottle of sleeping pills and end it all. I guess Mrs. Rosenfeld is a fairly talented writer as she was able to evoke such dislike for her protagonist from me, but overall this novel went absolutely nowhere and was a complete waste of my time. I liked Bridget Jones better and that's a stretch. I wouldn't really recommend this to book anyone. If you can find a copy, check out Gail Parent's 'Sheila Levine is Dead and Living in New York'. Although it's well over trhity years old now, it still maintains a crisp, hip, cutting edge feel to it unsurpassed by any other writer writing in the same vein as What She Saw.
each chapter takes a look at a different boy/man the main character dated/went with/screwed. a fun idea, but there's such a distance on the page... it's difficult to understand her convictions. i wanted to laugh, and groan in aggreeance, but was left slightly unsympathetic and befuddled. the book begs to be written in the first person, but for some bizarre-o reason lucinda rosenfeld gave us a third person story.
after reading the first chapter i thought it was clunky, and decided to shut it for good, but i was at work, with nothing elese to read, so i kept going, and somehow fell in. i still didn't really like it, but felt hooked nonetheless. weird.
i gave it four stars due to the 'it hooked me factor;' what does it all mean? i suppose it's just as confusing as what she really did see in all of those guys.
Collectible price: $10.59
Buy one from zShops for: $6.50
If you want a book that reads like a transcript of a gambler telling stories over drinks in a bar, name dropping old Vegas stars, talking about the big scores and the big losses, spouting opinions on lotteries and horses, and bragging about nailing hookers, by all means this is your book.
But if you're looking for advice on winning blackjack, look elsewhere.
The subtitle is "how to beat blackjack as a way of life." This is very misleading. There is good advice, mind you, but it's obvious and not worth filling a book. The advice is "quit winners." In any gambling situation, a player will go up and down. Quit when you're up. This is good advice, and it's what I already practice. But I didn't need to buy this book to tell me this.
As this is marketed as a book on playing blackjack, I'd think that instead of giving us the stats on high roller slot machines, or recounting keno stories, or any of the other endless off topic rants, there might be more about money management at the actual table. Showing me a "scorecard" listings wins at various casinos doesn't tell me how those positive numbers got there.
Congrats to Mr Levy on a nice brag book, admittedly getting publishing justification after two really good streaks. But by that standard, I guess I could write my own, having two streaks in a row.
I found much more helpful material for a casual player in Jerry Patterson's Blackjack: A Winner's Handbook. If you're a frequent player, you won't even take Levy's book seriously.