Related Subjects: Author Index
Book reviews for "Wertheim,_Stanley" sorted by average review score:

The Correspondence of Stephen Crane
Published in Hardcover by Columbia University Press (1988)
Authors: Stephen Crane, Stanley Wertheim, and Paul Sorrentino
Amazon base price: $158.50
Used price: $45.00
Average review score:

Very Expensive
This book has important information, but I do not think it is worth the money. The letters are published in other places and Mr. Wertheim does not make useful cojmments to help understand the content.

The Definitive Edition
This is the definitive edition of Crane's correspondence and almost doubles the number of known Crane letters since the Stallman and Gilkes edition appeared in 1960. The sectional introductions constitute a short Stephen Crane biography. The footnores are concise and informative.

The Definitive Edition
Like all important university press books, this definitive edition of Crane's correspondence is expensive, but it almost doubles the number of known Crane letters since the 1960 edition edited by Stallman and Gilkes. The introductions to the various sections constitute a short and authoritative Crane biography. The footnotes are economical and to the point.


The Crane Log: A Documentary Life of Stephen Crane 1871-1900
Published in Paperback by G K Hall (1995)
Authors: Stanley Wertheim and Paul Sorrentino
Amazon base price: $24.95
Used price: $10.98
Buy one from zShops for: $19.95
Average review score:

More fiction than fact
It seems to me that much of this material is made up by the author. I could not understand how private facts of Crane's life would be known in this way. I find this book very disturbing because of this. I think Crane is a great author but this book did not help me understand his work at all.

Not Helpful...Except to go to Sleep
Stephen Crane wrote some great books and lead a fascinating life, but this day to day rehash of every trivial detail with none of the excitement of this great author's life is terrible! This book does a disservice to Crane and his memory...confusing, loooong, and boring.

Finally a trustworthy biography of Crane
The Crane Log is a wonderful book which I have been reading over the past few days. I am surprised by the many underserved poor reviews this book has gotten. It must be stressed that this is a reference work, and one that is probably best read in snatches, and not in chronological order. includes day by day accounts, including fascinating liberal excerpts from memoirs of the people who knew him that allows you to form your own conception of Crane as he lived. For the first time we have a biographical work of Crane that is free of the fictions of Crane's first biographer, Thomas Beer. That is not something to grouse about.


A Stephen Crane Encyclopedia
Published in Unknown Binding by Greenwood Pub Group (E) (1997)
Authors: Stanley Wertheim and Allan C. Reddy
Amazon base price: $71.57
List price: $102.24 (that's 30% off!)
Average review score:

Makes Stephen Crane Boring!
This is a WAY over-priced book that makes Crane a really boring person, which I doubt he was. If you really need to read this book do NOT buy it. Get it from the library and drink coffee. I found numerous errors in this book because the author disregards all the other biographies about Crane and makes up his own material.

Loony Reviews
Many of the reviews of A Stephen Crane Encyclopedia on this site seem to be personal attacks, as the author suggests. One review claims that the author's opinions are in "left field," and another insists that, on the contrary, he simply summarizes the work of others. Wertheim is a leading Stephen Crane scholar, and to a great extent his opinions ARE the field. On the other hand, author encyclopedias do attempt to synthesize prevailing critical stances, and this encyclopedia does this admirably. it is succinct, well-written, and authoritative. A must for serious students of Stephen Crane.

A wonderful reference source for Crane
Some of the reviews on this site are really loony! They seem to be written by one person, over and over again. A Stephen Crane Encyclopedia is the most accurate, clearly written, and informative reference guides on Crane one could buy. It is also probably the very best of the encyclopedias of American authors.


Related Subjects: Author Index

Reviews are from readers at Amazon.com. To add a review, follow the Amazon buy link above.