Used price: $5.50
Collectible price: $12.95
Buy one from zShops for: $24.28
List price: $15.95 (that's 50% off!)
---Megan W.
Used price: $7.35
Collectible price: $23.29
The protagonist is an 11-year-old girl who descends into a nightmare world beneath her home. The underworld that she encounters is every bit as weird and unsettling as Lovecraft's Dreamlands.
While sometimes billed as a children's book, I feel that the work is too disturbing for someone the age of the protagonist. And the prose, while beautiful may prove cumbersome to younger readers.
Once you get into the second chapter or so, the plot is compelling. The only reason that I did not give this book its fifth star is because the first chapter did not pull me in. I had purchased the book from the SFBC (apologies to Amazon) and I had picked it up two or three times only to put it back down after reading the first chapter. But now that I have finished it, I highly recommend it to anyone in their late teens and older.
I also have a personal bias for Durbin's work because he and I happen share the same literary neighborhood of contemporary fantasy, a subgenre of fantasy too often eschewed by publishers in exchange for yet another mindless Tolkein-derivative "trilogy" of 16 books.
In addition to an interesting plot, the reader is also treated to a number of fine touches. Mr. Durbin's description of October in the first chapter resonated so well with me, I had to wonder if he had read my mind. (Probably not. I can't write that good.) I loved the characters, as well. They weren't your stereotypical fantasy folk, but seemed like real down-to-earth folk facing a fantastic and dangerous new world. The appearance of a couple of Dragonfly's relatives at the climax was a special treat.
All in all, I was left wondering if Mr. Durbin has written anything else. If not, I guess I'll just have to settle for rereading this one again.
Used price: $12.50
Used price: $0.84
Collectible price: $8.47
Buy one from zShops for: $9.00
What I don't understand is why he wrote it, or why we are supposed to enjoy reading it. The girl Ursula is a stupid, self-centered, insensitive, thoroughly repulsive excuse for a human being. Not that she isn't convincingly depicted--Tuten did all too good a job on her--but I can't think why we are supposed to care about her and want to read about her. And certainly not why we are supposed to admire and approve of her, as Tuten obviously does.
That Van Gogh might have fallen in love with someone like her is all too plausible--he did, after all, have a record of wasting himself on women who were far beneath him. But Vincent's love for Ursula is not shown as yet another self-destructive folly, but rather as something fine and beautiful.
Vincent himself is handled a good deal better. The flashback to his days as a preacher among the coal miners is perhaps the best thing in the book. The attempt to get inside his deteriorating mind is very fanciful and speculative, but then so is any attempt to see what goes on in the head of a schizo-affective.
As for the modern-day narrator, he is simply pathetic. Who can care about him? Who even wants to know about someone like that?
Furthermore, Tuten might have made a little more effort to get his facts straight. For one very big thing, the "Night Cafe" that Van Gogh painted and wrote about was located in Arles, not in Auverre-sur-Oise.
I have to admire the artistic courage that went into the writing of this book, but the results are just too badly flawed. But I admit I would like to try reading something else by Tuten. He is undeniably a gifted writer.
The center of the book is a wonderfully enigmatic woman named Ursula -- Van Gogh's lover, friend and fellow artiste (she's a photographer). She's also a morphine addict. Sharing addiction with Vincent (his addictions being to pain, art, and absinthe) gives them a bond that unites them in not only love but life. When Ursula steps through a crack in time to emerge into late 20th century Greenwich Village, the 'progress' she sees breaks her heart. She attempts to embrace it -- as she does everything else in her life -- but ultimately feels herself drawn back to her own time, to Vincent.
The novel is subtitled 'a love story' -- and it is certainly that, but not in the traditional sense. The love here is not just the romantic variety, but love of life, of creation, of joy and pain -- all of the things that besiege and bless us all. The trick is to understand how to accept them.
After reading about some of Tuten's other works, I'm not really sure if I want to read them or not -- I'll have to investigate them further -- but I'm certainly glad I stumbled across this little gem. It's a beautiful story, gently and lovingly told.
Used price: $2.23
Collectible price: $50.00